Post-Trial Reply Briefs Filed in 2257 Case

PHILADELPHIA — The Free Speech Coalition and Justice Department filed post-trial reply briefs on Friday and Monday, respectively, in the case over federal record-keeping act 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257 and 2257A.

The replies, in response to last week's post-trial filings, aimed to rebut each other's ground in the long-running battle waged by the adult entertainment industry to overturn a law aimed directly at producers who, on a wholesale level, allege an unfair and unnecessary burden on companies or individuals presenting any sort of erotic depictions.  

The FSC, along with 15 other plaintiffs, said that the government spent  a good portion of its post-trial brief trying to persuade the court not to render a decision on the merits of Fourth Amendment claims, notwithstanding a federal appeals court's remand for the development of an evidentiary record for that purpose.

"The remand, however, anticipated a determination on the merits, so plaintiffs will begin there," FSC attorneys wrote.

The FSC made five points in their reply to the Justice Department, including that the U.S. conducted unconstitutional warrantless searches, the searches were not consensual, the statutes authorizing warrantless searches were unconstitutional on their face, plaintiffs have standing to challenge the inspection scheme under the Fourth Amendment and that the inspection regime cannot be upheld based on the totality of the circumstances.

As for the Fourth Amendment issue, the FSC said the gist of the government's argument on standing is that the FBI stopped conducting inspections  when a 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision found the statute to be unconstitutional in 2007; the program was not resumed after that decision was vacated and reversed; the inspection program is not currently being funded by Congress; and there are no concrete plans by the FBI to begin it again.

"On these facts, the government argues, that when the inspection program resumes, it may take another shape. Thus, it laments, there is no basis to think that future inspections will any way resemble the prior 29 [2257 searches] and therefore, any decision regarding the regulatory inspection scheme is simply advisory," FSC attorneys said.

"There are some significant pieces of the picture missing from the government’s analysis, however. In its entire discussion of the inspections that have taken place and inspections yet to be, the government does not once mention [inspection of records law] 28 C.F.R. § 75.5. Yet that is the regulation under which the inspection program was created, pursuant to which the 29 inspections were carried out, and with which any future inspections must conform."

As a result, the FSC argues, there is no uncertainty about the parameters of future inspections compared to the previous 29.

"They must be carried out in consonance with 28 C.F.R. § 75.5,which sets forth the protocol for those inspections. Importantly, we know that government agents are authorized to enter producers’ premises without delay, without a warrantor probable cause, and without advance notice."

The Justice Department focused its rebuttal on how narrowly tailored 2257 is, as applied to the adult entertainment industry, and that the FSC hasn't proven that the law is substantially overbroad.

"[I]t is reasonable to require ID checks and records, and a means of  finding the records for a depiction no matter where the depiction ends up," the Justice Department said. "After all, child pornography causes harm both at the point that it is made (highlighting the importance of prophylactic measures rather than relying solely on after-the-fact criminal laws) and by remaining as a permanent record of that act.

"And once an image is created, it can be disseminated through different channels, copied, and re-sent many times, making its origin difficult to trace. Plaintiffs identify no reason for exempting them from these prophylactic measures, none of which prohibit their expression," the Justice Department said. "Rather, all plaintiffs in this case fall squarely within the legitimate scope of 2257 because they use youthful looking individuals in their work, and have no intention to stop doing so in the future. Nor can plaintiffs’ flawed evidence establish that, relative to the vast universe of commercial, publicly available pornography, any invalid  applications are substantial."

U.S. District Judge Michael Baylson said he would rule on the case before the end of the month.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Hentaied Founder Romero 'Mr. Alien' on Fetish, Fantasy and Finding Order in Chaos

A sharp sting pierces the woman’s skin. Something foreign slips beneath the surface. Eggs, maybe. She doesn’t know it yet, but soon her body will become a vessel, a hive, a source of contamination.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for July, August

AEBN has published the top search terms for the months of July and August from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

The Guardian Devotes Feature Article to XBIZ Amsterdam

British newspaper The Guardian sent a reporter to cover XBIZ Amsterdam earlier this month, resulting in a lengthy article about the annual European adult industry conference.

Bree Mills Unpacks Power, Pain and Family Ties in New Pure Taboo Film

Bell is shooting a scene for “The Secrets We Share,” a new feature from Pure Taboo and Adult Time — and moments like this remind the crew that they are not out to make just another adult movie.

Cubbi Thompson Stars in Latest From Brazzers

Cubbi Thompson stars with Keiran Lee in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "Slippery Business."

Pineapple Support Taps Char Borley as Brand Ambassador

Pineapple Support has named Char Borley as its newest brand ambassador.

Adult Time Drops Bree Mills' 'Hard Stop Reunion' Documentary, New Scene

Adult Time has released a documentary feature on the recent Bree Mills-helmed drama “Hard Stop” as well as a new cast orgy scene, titled “Hard Stop Reunion Orgy.”

Gal Ritchie Performs Her 1st Anal for Brazzers

Gal Ritchie performs her first anal scene alongside Ricky Johnson in the latest Brazzers release, titled “Say Hello to My Little Arsehole.”

Michigan Legislators Propose Online Porn Ban

Michigan lawmakers have introduced a bill that would make it illegal to distribute pornography via the internet in the state.

Florida AG Sues Aylo, Segpay Over State AV Law

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed lawsuits against Aylo and Segpay on Monday with the 12th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida for noncompliance with HB3, the state's age verification law.

Show More