FSC Files Summary Judgment Motion as 2257 Trial Nears

PHILADELPHIA — The Free Speech Coalition on Friday filed a motion for summary judgment in the trade organization's civil case against the federal government over the legality of 18 U.S.C. § 2257.

The FSC asked the federal court in Philadelphia to dump the federal record-keeping law for adult producers because the statutes are unconstitutionally overbroad on their face under the First Amendment and that the laws and implementing regulations authorize warrantless searches and seizures in violation of the Fourth Amendment.

Also on Friday, the Justice Department filed its own memorandum in support of its own motion to dismiss the case.

With both sides arguing their points of law in pretrial motions, U.S. District Judge Michael Baylson likely won't rule on the motions as trial is scheduled to begin next month.

In March, Baylson noted that because the case is on remand from the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for determination of certain facts, he's more inclined for a trial rather than deciding summary judgment.

Baylson earlier said that if the case goes to trial, a decision would be expected before August.

FSC attorneys said in their motion for summary judgment filed Friday that 2257 and its companion section 2257A burdens a substantial amount of speech that lies far beyond the statutes’ purported goal “of protecting children from sexual exploitation.”

Sections 2257 and 2257A impose a record-keeping requirement on producers of sexually explicit materials and require that they make such records available to the government for inspection at all reasonable times.

The regulations spell out requirements for the maintenance, categorization, location and inspection of records, as well as legal grounds for exemption of these requirements. They require that records be maintained for five years after the dissolution of a business that had been required to maintain them.

FSC attorneys in their motion said that times have changed in the years the case has been litigated and that millions of citizens exchange sex depictions and images on computers as private citizens not engaged in an economic enterprise but simply “to share sexually explicit images with one another."

As a result, the FSC's attorneys said, "each person who sends a sext, creates a boudoir photo or video, or exchanges sexually explicit images on an adult social network website must maintain a copy of his or her photo identification together with a copy of his or her sexual imagery and must label the image with a statement listing the location of the records, namely, his or her home address."

"Millions of Americans who share purely personal sexually explicit imagery with one another as part of their sexual lives are required, on pain of criminal prosecution, to comply with 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257, 2257A," FSC counsel said.

FSC attorneys recited information relative to 29 inspections conducted between July 24, 2006, and Sept. 19, 2007 without a search warrant under 2257. 

According to FBI records, companies inspected during that period included Evasive Angels, Darkside (inspected twice), Silver Star, All Good, Robert Hill (inspected twice), Diabolic, Tennervision, Private Media Group, K-Beech, Wicked Pictures, Dead Men, Angry Young Men, Moonlight, Shanes World, Don Goo, JT Video, Bacchus, Cinema Play, Gentlemens, Temptations, Agency, Shooting Star, Real Wild Girls, Alexis Lords, Candid Cams, Ghost Pro and Pony Boy.

FBI agents entered the places of businesses to perform inspections of 2257 records — six were private residences — and inspected records for upwards to six hours,  according to Justice Department testimony.

"[The government] constituted a common law trespass as well as a violation of the producer’s reasonable expectation of privacy in his or her home and private business areas and records to which the general public is not granted access," FSC attorneys said. "And in each instance, the searches were conducted without probable cause and without a warrant.

"Moreover, the agents’ examination and copying of the producers’ records and taking photos while on those premises constituted a search and seizure under the Fourth Amendment."

The FSC relied on depositions from co-plaintiffs against the government's stance over 2257, including testimony from  Barbara Alper, Francis Biro, BettyDodson, Jeffrey Douglas, Marie Levine, David Levingston, Eugene Mopsik, Barbara Nitke, Carol Queen, Carlin Ross, Steven David Steinberg and Linda Dian Wilson.

The court also heard from leading authorities in sex and technology and computer forensics, including Dan Linz, Marc Zimmerman, Michelle Drouin, William Livingston and Kristi Witsman.

The federal government, in its own memorandum in support of its own motion to dismiss the case, maintained that the interest in ensuring producers take "the simple precaution of checking the ages of the individuals who appear in such work, and keep records having done so, is compelling."

"Indeed, if the prophylactic measures set forth in 2257 and 2257A fail, the gravest consequence is not that other statutory provisions (those that criminalize child pornography possession and distribution) will be violated; it is the risk that children will be harmed through their exploitation in the creation of sexually explicit material," the Justice Department said.

In their motion Friday, the government requested the court grant summary in their favor on their First Amendment facial overbreadth and Fourth Amendment claims.

View FSC's latest motion for summary judgment

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

'Swing Nation' Hosts Lacy and Dan Star With Serenity Cox in WIFEY Return

Lacy and Dan, hosts of the "Swing Nation" lifestyle podcast, star alongside Serenity Cox and Anton Harden in their return to Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for September, October

AEBN has published the top search terms for September and October from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Lauren Phillips, Cali Sweets Front New 'Buttman' Release

Lauren Phillips and Cali Sweets star with director Glenn King in the latest release featuring Evil Angel studio honcho John Stagliano's iconic Buttman character.The scene opens with Buttman concerned about King's recent unreliability, as he's been missing deadlines for submitting videos.

Amy Nosferatu Leads Latest From TGirls.xxx

Amy Nosferatu stars with Jason Leescott in a release from Grooby paysite TGirls.xxx, titled "The Tattoo Parlour."

Reptyle to Debut Cross-Site Cosplay Series 'Live Action Hentai'

Reptyle is premiering the new limited cosplay series "Live Action Hentai" on studio imprints Family Strokes, TeamSkeet, Freeuse, and Pervz.

BranditScan Launches Black Friday Creator Promo

BranditScan has launched its annual Black Friday promotion, offering creators a 69% discount for the first month to creators signing up for the DMCA leak protection and takedown anti-piracy subscription service.

Cheerleader Kait, Isa Bella Topline Latest Volume of 'Sorority Girls' From Sweetheart Video

Cheerleader Kait and Isa Bella headline the fourth volume of "Sorority Girls," from Mile High Media studio imprint Sweetheart Video.

Penny Barber, Dee Williams Star in Latest From Girlsway

Penny Barber stars alongside Dee Williams in the latest release from Girlsway, titled "Homemade Sex Ed."

Rachael Cavalli Leads Latest From Girlsway

Rachael Cavalli stars with Cami Strella and Kimmy Kimm in the latest release from Girlsway, titled "Beautiful Inside and Out."

Show More