Private's Suit Against DrTuber.com Is Rejected

CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa — A federal judge this week rejected Private Media Group's copyright infringement suit against Russian citizen Igor Kovalchuk, who was said to operate tube site DrTuber.com.

U.S. District Judge Mark Bennett dismissed the suit after ruling that Private hasn't "sufficient minimum contacts with Iowa to satisfy due process and permit the exercise of personal jurisdiction over him."

The case, filed last year at federal court in Iowa, alleged that DrTuber.com streamed 31 of its videos. Private was asking for $4.65 million in damages, as well as attorneys fees and court costs.

Private, in its complaint through its Fraserside IP unit, asserted that DrTuber is "one of the rogue pirates running such a site and willfully violating its copyrights and trademarks in the process."

But on Monday Bennett ruled that Kovalchuk, DrTuber's reported operator, would be entitled to succeed in a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction because Private could not establish that he actually operated the site.

"[Private] asserts that specific jurisdiction over Kovalchuk exists because Kovalchuk has directed tortious conduct at it, an Iowa business, through his ownership and operation of the website  DrTuber.com," Bennett wrote. "Although I accept as true [Private]'s allegations that the website  DrTuber.com has infringed Kovalchuk’s registered copyrights and trademarks, these allegations, alone, fail to demonstrate that Kovalchuk 'uniquely or expressly aimed' any tortious acts at Iowa."

Bennett, who made a similar ruling in another Private suit against xHamster earlier this year, said he considered five factors developed by the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which presides over federal cases in Iowa, determining whether a nonresident defendant has sufficient minimum contacts with the forum state to exercise personal jurisdiction over it. 

Those factors include, Bennett said, the nature and quality of the contacts with the forum state; the quantity of the contacts with the forum state; the relation of the cause of action to the contacts; the interest of the forum state in providing its residents a forum; and the convenience of the parties.

"Kovalchuk has no employees in Iowa, no telephone number in Iowa and no agent for service of process in Iowa, "Bennett said. "Kovalchuk has never visited Iowa and has never conducted any business in Iowa. He does not own or lease any real estate in Iowa."

The DrTuber judgment Tuesday's decision is another setback for Private, which has vowed to appeal Bennett's similar xHamster dismissal to the 8th Circuit. At post time, it wasn't clear whether Private would appeal the DrTuber ruling, as well.

Meanwhile, Private apparently has reached a deal with operator Joe Olivero and tube site TubeRip.com over copyright infringement charges in which Barcelona-based Private was seeking $7.65 million in damages.Terms of the apparent settlement were not disclosed.

TubeRip was alleged to have poached and streamed 51 Private movies.

With the settlement, Bennett signed off on dismissing that suit on Wednesday.

Private did not respond by post time for XBIZ comment on the pair of cases.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

XBIZ 2026 Conference to Debut All-New Company Lounges, Community Track

The event website for XBIZ 2026 is now live, offering information about North America’s largest adult industry conference, set to take place Jan. 12-15.

Maria May Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Creator Maria May stars with her husband Jeff, Hollywood Cash, and Jamie Knoxx in the latest release from Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

Alexis James Stars in Latest BAM Visions Scene

Alexis James stars alongside multi-XMAs winner Mick Blue in a new scene co-directed by Blue and Maestro Claudio, aka BAM Visions, from Evil Angel.

Charlotte Sins Performs Her 1st Gangbang for Adult Time

Charlotte Sins performs her first gangbang in the latest release from Adult Time.

Cutting Edge Testing Joins PASS as New Partner

Performer Availability Screening Services (PASS) has added Cutting Edge Testing (CET) as a new testing partner.

Andylynn Payne, Emma Rosie Topline Joey Silvera's 'Trans-Active 32'

Andylynn Payne and Emma Rosie headline director Joey Silvera’s “Trans-Active 32” from Evil Angel.

Mymember.site Integrates VR Functionality

Mymember.site has added virtual reality playback capability to its website management platform.

Texas Patti to Launch Fetish Platform 'EmpireDom'

Performer and content creator Texas Patti is launching a new platform for doms and fetish creators, EmpireDom.com.

Vince Karter Discusses Directing for Evil Angel

After 13 years on screen, Vince Karter has taken his talents to the other side of the camera. He recently made his studio directing debut for Evil Angel, where five scenes helmed by the two-time Euro XMAs Male Performer of the Year are already streaming on the site.

WIFEY Names Serenity Cox Brand Ambassador

Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint WIFEY has named Serenity Cox as its brand ambassador.

Show More