Attorney Evan Stone Fined $10K Over 'Improper' Subpoenas

DALLAS — A federal judge has fined attorney Evan Stone $10,000 for sending out subpoenas before getting court approval.

But Stone told XBIZ he plans to appeal the ruling and said that people have lost sight of why these BitTorrent suits are happening in the first place.

"Years ago, we in the entertainment industry made a deal with the nation’s largest Internet service providers," Stone said. "Part of this deal stated that we wouldn’t sue ISPs for unlawfully distributing content through their networks [at the behest of their customers] provided that the ISPs would help us identify the individuals engaged in these unlawful activities.  The problem now is that the ISPs have welshed on their end of the deal."

Stone, who earlier this year filed a BitTorrent lawsuit at U.S. District Court in Dallas targeting 670 John Does on behalf of Mick Haig Productions , asked the court to allow him to send out subpoenas to Internet service providers to find out the identities of the infringers.

But the court never made a ruling on the request and instead ordered the ISPs to store the information for a later date.

Stone said that the only alternative seems to be is to file a federal lawsuit and obtain a court order specifically granting discovery that IPSs had originally promised to comply with on their own volition. 

"This 'sue first and ask questions later' approach we are left is far from ideal for everyone involved, but the copyright holder’s right to conduct discovery to identify wrongdoers should not be in question," Stone said.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation represented the defendants in the case and asked the court to disallow subpoenas seeking the identities of the accused Does.  The judge ruled that Stone was not to send out any subpoenas until after the court ruled if it was proper to do so.

However, Stone sent out the subpoenas anyway, and began identifying individuals, even though the court had not ruled if it was proper.

By serving invalid subpoenas, Stone necessarily, “imposed an undue burden or expense on each ISP and the putative Does,” the court said. “To say that the subpoenas imposed an undue burden on their targets fails to capture the gravity of Stone’s abdication of responsibility because Stone obtained information that he had no right to receive.”

Stone was ordered by the court to pay $10,000 in sanctions and take remedial steps outlined by the judge.

"Discovery can, most certainly, be guided by the court," Stone said. "But for an order to be issued at the outset of a case that discovery itself should be opposed continues to perplex me."

Stone added that Congress had some notion of the "volume of piracy we would be experiencing now and noone, even today, could suggest with a straight face that the simple, essential step of matching an account holder to an IP address merits the scrutiny of a federal judge every time someone unlawfully downloads the content of another.  That scrutiny should be reserved for the merits of the case."

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Missouri AG Announces Age Verification Rule to Take Effect Nov. 30

Newly appointed Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway announced Friday that the state's recently approved age verification regulation for adult websites will go into effect on Nov. 30.

Aylo, Woodhull Freedom Foundation to Host 'Online Censorship' Event

Aylo and Woodhull Freedom Foundation will co-host a virtual panel addressing online censorship on Sept. 30.

Judge Awards Plaintiffs Over $400K in Attorneys Fees in Derek Hay Civil Case

California Superior Court Judge Gail Killefer has awarded former clients of LA Direct Models over $400,000 in attorneys fees and court costs, to be paid by agency founder Derek Hay.

Former Backpage CEO Carl Ferrer Sentenced to 3 Years Probation, $40,000 Fine

Former Backpage.com CEO Carl Ferrer was sentenced in federal court today to three years' probation and a $40,000 restitution fine for a conspiracy conviction related to money laundering through the defunct website.

Playboy Wins $81 Million Judgment in Chinese Licensing Arbitration

Playboy Inc. was awarded $81 million in damages on Monday by the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre, in a licensing dispute with former partner New Handong Investment (Guangdong) Co. Ltd.

GirlsDoPorn Owner Michael Pratt Sentenced to 27 Years

Michael Pratt, former owner of the website GirlsDoPorn, has been sentenced to 27 years in federal prison.

Aylo Fined $5 Million as FTC, Utah Settle Safety Practices Complaint

The Federal Trade Commission and the state of Utah on Wednesday settled a complaint against Aylo, requiring the company to pay a $5 million penalty and implement measures to prevent illegal content from appearing on its sites.

XBIZ Amsterdam 2025 Show Schedule Announced

XBIZ is pleased to announce the release of the full show schedule for XBIZ Amsterdam 2025, set to take place Sept. 2-4.

FSC: Missouri Age Verification Rule Will Not Take Effect August 30

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced that Missouri's proposed age verification legislation will not take effect on August 30, as it had originally estimated.

Germany Will Block Payments to AV-Noncompliant Adult Sites as of Dec. 1

Starting Dec. 1, Germany will implement new rules prohibiting financial institutions from providing payment services to adult sites deemed to have inadequate age verification systems and making it easier for the government to target websites mirroring the content of such sites.

Show More