Condom Distribution Battle Goes Forward in Federal Court

SAN FRANCISCO — In a battle over distribution channels and pricing of condoms, a federal judge has dismissed only one of Mayer Laboratories' 12 counterclaims in an antitrust suit against Church & Dwight, the maker of Trojan and other brand name rubbers.

The suit, filed at U.S. District Court in San Francisco, and its counterclaims hone in on the growing competitive  market of ultra-thin condoms, which purportedly comprise approximately 22 percent of the overall retail market.

New Jersey-based Church & Dwight (C&D) sued Mayer of California in November 2008 seeking declaratory judgment over the use of alleged anticompetitive activities.

But Mayer answered the suit with  12 counterclaims in February 2009 that alleged that the Trojan maker engaged in five distinct but related anticompetitive activities that have the combined effect of "greatly diminishing and in some cases eliminating competition in the relevant markets."

Mayer's countersuit included allegations of violations of the Sherman Act, California professional and business codes, violations of California laws on exclusive dealing and secret rebates, tortious interference, unfair competition and trademark violations.

U.S. District Judge Edward Chen's 34-page ruling last week means Mayer can go ahead with nearly all of its counterclaims against C&D, with the exception of one on retailer deals called "planogram agreements."

Planograms are  diagrams showing where specific products are to be positioned in the space allotted by a retail store for a particular category of products.

Mayer, known for its Kimono and Kimono MicroThin condoms made by Japan-based Sagami Rubber Industries, claims it was "instrumental in establishing the ultra-thin condom segment in the U.S. market." In fact it registered its trademark for "MicroThin" condoms in 2009.

Mayer alleged that C&D engages in five distinct but related anticompetitive activities that have the combined effect of "greatly diminishing and in some cases eliminating competition in the relevant markets."

Mayer claims C&D offers "'Condom Planogram Agreements' to large chain retailers, which together account for nearly 100 percent of condom sales nationwide."  

"Such agreements give the chain the opportunity to receive a substantial kickback or rebate on its purchases of C&D condoms," Mayer attorneys said in the suit. "Rebates are given if the retailer accepts and follows a planogram designed by C&D and guarantees that C&D's condoms occupy a specified minimum percentage of the available facings on its in-store display."

Secondly, Mayer attorneys also say that retailers allegedly have agreed to give C&D the "ability to decide and influence which brands of condoms are included in a chain's stores, where individual condom  [products] are placed in the store displays, which condom [products] are discontinued, and which new condom [products] are added."

C&D purportedly uses this position "to obtain preferential display locations for its products, to recommend replacement of competing brands with [C&D] products, and to reduce visibility for (or exclude altogether) competing brands, including Mayer Labs' products.'

Thirdly, Mayer alleges that C&D has exclusive dealing arrangements with some retail chains, including 7-Eleven, obligating them to sell only C&D condoms.

Mayer in its fourth claim asserts that in 2006 C&D began targeting the Japanese-made, ultra-thin condom market segment. C&D initially distributed "Trojan Ultrathin" condoms

Mayer asserts C&D began using the term "ultra-thin," which had previously associated with Mayer's products. C&D allegedly began using the term MicroThin for its Trojan brand Ultrathin condoms in 2007, and for its ThinTensity condoms in 2008.

Mayer as a result says its sales of Kimono Microthin condoms declined 33 percent, from $1.17 million in 2006 to $1.12 million in 2007 due to C&D's anticompetitive conduct.

Lastly, Mayer claims that in 2007, C&D tortiously induced its Japanese maker, Sagami, to begin supplying it with condoms in violation of an exclusive contract Mayer had with Sagami.

The suit has revealed some interesting numbers delivered from Mayer.

According to the company, Trojan is the largest-selling brand of condoms in the U.S. and that C&D's condoms account for more than 75 percent of all retail condom sales. The next popular brand is Durex, marketed by SSL Americas Inc., with approximately 15 percent of sales. The third largest-selling brand is Lifestyle, marketed by Ansell Healthcare, with 8 percent of the market.

"Together, condoms sold by these three companies account for over 98 percent of the nationwide market," Mayer attorneys said in the suit.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Orion Debuts 'Ride On 2' Vibepad

Orion Wholesale has introduced its new Ride On 2 vibepad.

Report: TDR Capital Reaches $460M Deal to Acquire Lovehoney Group

Private equity firm TDR Capital has reached an agreement to acquire Lovehoney Group in a deal valued at approximately €400 million ($460 million), according to a report by Sky News.

Aylo Defeats Indiana Lawsuit Over VPN Use to Bypass Age Verification

A Marion Superior Court judge on Wednesday dismissed Indiana’s lawsuit alleging that Aylo violated the state’s age verification law by failing to prevent access by users who employ VPNs and similar means to avoid geolocation.

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

Wild Brands to Unveil 1st Product Collection at XBIZ Expo

Sexual wellness company Wild Brands will introduce its debut product collection at XBIZ Expo in January.

EngErotics Launches Capital Raise Through Campaign on CataCap

Sexual wellness brand EngErotics has launched a campaign to raise capital for expansion on the CataCap philanthropic investment platform.

PinkCherry Relaunches Wholesale Division

Pleasure distributor PinkCherry has relaunched its wholesale division.

Beisar Introduces 'PhoenixGP' Unicorn-Inspired Thrusting Vibe

Beisar has debuted its new PhoenixGP unicorn-spired thrusting, vibrating dildo.

Ofcom Proposes Requiring Adult Sites Hosting UGC to Use Hash Matching Tech

U.K. media regulator Ofcom on Monday asked Parliament to approve proposed new codes that would, among other changes, require adult platforms hosting user-generated content to implement hash matching technology in order to detect CSAM.

Orion Adds New Stocking Styles to 'Cottelli Legwear' Line

Orion Wholesale has expanded its Cottelli Legwear collection with several new stocking styles.

Show More