Ohio Justices Hear Arguments Over Challenge to Obscenity Law

COLUMBUS, Ohio — The Ohio Supreme Court heard oral arguments Tuesday in a case that seeks to interpret a 2002 Ohio law that attempts to shield minors from obscene material on the web.

First Amendment attorney Michael A. Bamberger — who represents American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression — argued Tuesday that the law, meant to shield children from online pornography and predators, violates free speech and is vague.

But Ohio justices were skeptical that his hypothetical scenarios involving website and chat room postings could lead to criminal prosecution under the statute, O.R.C. § 2907.31, which is titled Disseminating Matter Harmful to Juveniles.

Arguing on behalf of the statute, Ohio Solicitor General Ben Mizer said O.R.C. § 2907.31 was revised in 2004 so it would avoid the fate of laws in six other states that were declared unconstitutional.

The law makes it a crime to directly send obscene or harmful material to a juvenile via the web, email, messaging and chat rooms.

A pair of federal laws in the 1990s pushing decency restrictions and safety online were struck down as unconstitutional. So have been similar state laws in Michigan, New Mexico, Arizona, South Carolina, Virginia and Vermont. A law similar to Ohio’s is still pending in the courts in Utah.

Ohio’s statute initially prohibited dissemination to juveniles of material considered "harmful to juveniles," but the law was blocked by U.S. District Judge Walter H. Rice because he ruled its terms did not comply with a U.S. Supreme Court obscenity precedent, Miller vs. California.

In 2003, Ohio amended the law to fix the legal definitions and again faced 1st Amendment and Commerce Clause challenges.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals earlier this year asked Ohio's high court to formally respond to two questions about whether O.R.C. § 2907.31 exempts private email, chat rooms and websites from liability, as the state attorney general has argued.

The 6th Circuit asked Ohio whether its attorney general is correct in construing the law “as applied to electronic communications, to personally directed devices such as instant messaging, person-to-person emails and private chat rooms” and whether it is “exempt from liability material posted on generally accessible websites and in public chat rooms.”

Ohio justices are expected to decide on the case before the end of the year.

View court brief

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

JuicyAds Launches Summer Advertiser/Publisher Promo

JuicyAds has launched a summer promotion for advertisers and publishers.

FSC to Honor Board Chair Jeffrey Douglas for 30 Years of Leadership

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) will honor board chair Jeffrey Douglas for his 30 years of service to the industry at an event on June 27.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches by Country for April, May

AEBN has released the list of popular searches from its straight and gay theaters by country in April and May.

French Court Suspends Age Verification Rule for EU Sites

The Paris Administrative Court has suspended enforcement of age verification regulations for sites based in other European Union member nations, pending a final judgment on whether France’s AV rules align with EU standards.

UK Parliament Weighs Proposals Targeting Adult Content

The U.K. Parliament this week debated proposed amendments to the pending Crime and Policing Bill, including clauses criminalizing “choking” content — and potentially outlawing paying for sex acts in cam performances and custom clips.

Rights Groups File Amicus Brief Supporting Backpage Defendants

Woodhull Freedom Foundation has joined Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, Reason Foundation, and Electronic Frontier Foundation in filing an amicus brief in support of an appeal by the former operators of Backpage.com.

UK Lawmaker Calls for Ban on Choking in Online Adult Content

British lawmaker Jessica Asato stated in an interview aired on Sunday that she plans to ask Parliament to outlaw online adult content featuring the act of choking.

Feet4Cash Joins Pineapple Support as Sponsor

Feet4Cash has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Report: VPN Usage Surges in France After Aylo Restricts Access to Pornhub

France has experienced a surge in virtual private network (VPN) signups after Aylo, which operates Pornhub, Redtube and YouPorn, cut off access to those sites in the country in the wake of new age verification regulations, business news site MENAFN is reporting.

New Creator Directory 'TrustyFans' Launches

TrustyFans, a newly launched directory designed to help fans discover their favorite creators, is now live.

Show More