FSC Challenges Utah’s Anti-Spam Registry

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah — The Free Speech Coalition, in its first legal challenge against legislation regulating spam, has filed a federal suit against the state of Utah, claiming that its Child Protection Registry Act is unconstitutional.

“This suit is all about the unfairness of the registry, the lack of wisdom in the law, which went into effect in July,” FSC Communications Director Tom Hymes told XBiz. “For smaller companies, the Act would pretty much drive them out of business. The monetary cost is real significant.”

The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Salt Lake City, said that the Act violates the right of free expression, treats e-marketers differently than other marketers and potentially prohibits interstate communications outside the state, among other claims.

Utah created the Child Protection Registry Act to protect minors from receiving email messages that promote or contain adult products or services.

The law established a “Do Not Email” registry containing email addresses that belong to, or can be accessed by, Utah minors. It also criminalized the sending of prohibited email to any email address listed in the registry for more than 30 days.

Further, the Act provides criminal, administrative and civil enforcement mechanisms, and requires email marketers to “scrub” their lists against the registry for a per-scrub fee of $0.005.

Hymes said that the cost of “scrubbing” email lists against the registry database on a monthly basis could be prohibitive, leading to a chilling effect on legitimate Internet marketing. It’s also incompatible to Mac and Linux based systems, he said.

“From the moment this law was introduced, we saw it as a red flag,” he said.

Hymes said that while the purpose of the law is commendable, it also is flawed in a number of ways.

Most significantly, he said, the law conflicts directly with the federal Can-Spam Act, which was enacted by Congress in 2003 to regulate and standardize email marketing in the U.S.

In ratifying Can-Spam, Congress considered the creation of a national “Do Not Email” list, and directed the Federal Trade Commission to prepare a plan for implementation.

But Hymes said that the FTC concluded that such a registry wasn’t feasible, would increase the prevalence of unsolicited email messages and would expose children to even more inappropriate content.

The FSC’s complaint identifies other problems with Utah’s new law, including that it creates a mechanism by which hackers, unscrupulous email marketers or pedophiles could potentially obtain the email addresses of minors.

The suit was filed by Utah attorney Jerome Mooney on behalf of the FSC. Attorneys Ira P. Rothken, Gregory A. Piccionelli, Jeffrey J. Douglas and Reed Lee also are working on the case.

The FSC complaint seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, asking the court to render the Act invalid.

Hymes said the FSC also would target Michigan’s similar soon-to-be-enacted law.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Aylo Fined $5 Million as FTC, Utah Settle Safety Practices Complaint

The Federal Trade Commission and the state of Utah on Wednesday settled a complaint against Aylo, requiring the company to pay a $5 million penalty and implement measures to prevent illegal content from appearing on its sites.

XBIZ Amsterdam 2025 Show Schedule Announced

XBIZ is pleased to announce the release of the full show schedule for XBIZ Amsterdam 2025, set to take place Sept. 2-4.

FSC: Missouri Age Verification Rule Will Not Take Effect August 30

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced that Missouri's proposed age verification legislation will not take effect on August 30, as it had originally estimated.

Germany Will Block Payments to AV-Noncompliant Adult Sites as of Dec. 1

Starting Dec. 1, Germany will implement new rules prohibiting financial institutions from providing payment services to adult sites deemed to have inadequate age verification systems and making it easier for the government to target websites mirroring the content of such sites.

FSC Launches Age Verification Toolkit for Adult Websites

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced today that it has launched a comprehensive toolkit to help adult websites navigate age verification laws.

Trump Administration Issues Executive Order Against 'Debanking'

The White House on Thursday issued an executive order limiting financial institutions’ ability to restrict access to financial services for people or groups involved in lawful industries, a longtime goal of adult industry advocates and stakeholders.

Florida AG Sues EU-Based Adult Companies for Failing to Age-Verify Users

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a lawsuit Monday with the 12th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida against five EU-based adult companies for allegedly failing to require age verification before allowing access to adult content.

Arcom Warns 5 Adult Sites Over Age Verification

French media regulator Arcom has sent enforcement notices to the operators of five adult websites that the agency says have failed to implement age verification as required under France’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

FSC: Identity Theft Targeting Adult Performers

The Free Speech Coalition has issued an alert warning of an individual found to be targeting adult performers for identity theft.

European Commission to Assess Pornhub, XVideos, XNXX Compliance With Digital Services Act

The European Commission plans to conduct a study to determine how well adult sites Pornhub, XVideos and XNXX are addressing illegal content and other potential harms under the EU’s Digital Services Act.

Show More