trends

A New Legal Reality

If you would have told me on George W. Bush's inauguration day in 2001 that we would reach the last year of a two-term Bush presidency with merely a handful of federal prosecutions of adult entertainment entrepreneurs, I would have politely provided you with a litany of lawyerly reasons why you were, well, delusional. Yet, with less than a year left in Bush's presidency, that is exactly what has transpired.

Despite repeated promises of numerous and broadly based obscenity prosecutions by evangelical Attorney General John Ashcroft and his successor Roberto Gonzales, we have yet to see the porn apocalypse hoped for by the religious right (and some criminal defense lawyers). Despite two onerously expansive revisions to the 2257 regulations, as well as passage of the CAN-SPAM Act and a new criminal deceptive domain law ("The PROTECT Act"), instead of prosecutorial pornagheddon, what the industry got instead was a glut of content and whole lot more competition as the numbers of adult businesses grew almost as fast under the Bush administration as did our national debt.

So, as we enter the final year of the Bush administration with the industry larger than ever, many are wondering if the days of governmental harassment and politically motivated prosecutions of the industry are finally over.

Some reasonably ask: "Can we now simply conclude that the adult entertainment industry has won its culture war with the religious right?"

The answer, unfortunately, is not quite yet. I do not think the adult industry should emulate Bush's mistake of prematurely declaring victory. But clearly, to quote Bob Dylan, "The times they are a-changin'."

Once George Bush leaves office, assuming the likely result that a Democrat or a moderate Republican wins this year's presidential election, there are good reasons to believe that the criminal prosecution of the producers and distributors of adult materials may not be a high priority of the federal government for some time thereafter.

Consider the fact that by 2009, large numbers of Generation Y, the kids of the baby boomers, will join their baby boomer parents and Generation X-ers to make up the vast majority of American voters. All these groups were raised in a cultural environment that was a lot more sexually permissive than the generations preceding the baby boomers.

For most adults today, erotic and sexually explicit forms of entertainment have been a part of their culture their whole lives. Consequently, given the serious problems facing 21st century America, like Islamic extremism, global warming, a collapsing health care system, foreign competition from China and other serious economic challenges, for most members of the post-World War II generations, diversion of government resources to prosecute pornographers makes less and less sense unless its for the enforcement of child pornography laws.

Thus, despite what we can expect to be a continued clamoring by the morality police of the religious right that government must "protect children" by prosecuting mainstream adult erotica, to borrow a phrase often used by Bill Clinton, "That dog just won't hunt no more."

But along with the diminished threat of prosecution that accompanies the greater cultural acceptance of erotica that will likely typify the post-Bush era, will come new legal challenges to the adult entertainment industry.

Ironically, after Bush departs, the more likely source of legal problems for a typical adult entertainment company will not be parties seeking to destroy the market for adult content, but will instead be parties seeking to capitalize on the enormous market for erotica.

For example, demand for adult content is at the core of a huge and growing piracy problem that will pose a much greater threat to the viability of adult businesses than government obscenity prosecutions.

The government is also likely to switch to a more economically self-serving strategy in the types of cases it brings against the adult industry.

For example, in the post-Bush era, it will probably be less likely that the government will initiate prosecutions of adult entertainment companies for violating the obscenity laws or the 2257 regulations than it will be for the government to initiate tax collection and tax evasion cases against adult enterprises.

As our firm saw during Clinton administration, we are also more likely to see cases filed by the Federal Trade Commission against large mainstream adult entertainment companies seeking massive monetary forfeitures than we are likely to see new criminal actions filed by the Justice Department against such adult enterprises.

The view that adult entertainment companies will probably face a diminished threat of criminal prosecution in the next administration does not mean that adult entrepreneurs should stop complying with all the laws that apply to them.

After all, there will always be some parties who elect to distribute extremely offensive materials that will likely face an increased risk of criminal prosecution because of the nature of the material they distribute or because they have engaged in some other activity that has made them an attractive prosecutorial target.

Also, it is clearly possible that the government may want to pad a criminal tax evasion case brought against an adult entertainment businessperson with additional criminal charges such as alleged violations of the obscenity laws which would, in turn, entitle the government to bring even more serious charges such as money laundering and racketeering.

But while the risk of serious criminal prosecution will always remain a part of doing business in the adult industry to some extent, there is a new set of legal realities that will confront adult entertainment businesspersons after George Bush leaves office.

Successful adult entertainment companies in the next era are likely to be those that quickly grasp this fact and effectively exploit the new emerging legal landscape.

This means, for example, that for an adult entertainment company to be competitive in the years to come, it must be able to effectively develop, protect, exploit and enforce its copyrights, trademarks and other intellectual property rights.

It also means that adult companies will have to learn how to minimize their risk of tax enforcement actions and prophylactically protect themselves from vexatious and unnecessary litigation from competitors, consumers, employees and others. Meanwhile, shrewd and effective deal-making and contract negotiation will become more important than ever.

To help our readers obtain a better working knowledge of the legal issues they are likely to confront in the post- Bush era, in the coming months, in addition to reporting and commenting on events of legal importance to the industry, this column will focus on a number of adult business law issues that I believe will be of critical importance for adult entertainment companies in the years to come.

In association with XBIZ, I will discuss many cutting edge business law issues and provide helpful tips and techniques that our firm has used for many years to assist our clients in their development, exploitation and enforcement of their intellectual property rights and their negotiation of some of the industry's biggest deals. Stay tuned.

The future is bright: it's bye-bye Bush.

Gregory A. Piccionelli, Esq. is one of the world's most experienced adult entertainment business attorneys. He can be reached at Piccionelli & Sarno at (310) 553-3375 or at greg@piccionellisarno.com.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Consent Verification Could Shape the Next Wave of Platform Regulation

Five years ago, age verification wasn’t a priority for most online adult platforms. While some markets had laws in place, enforcement was fragmented, and many platforms still relied on users to self-declare their dates of birth. Today, regulators worldwide are mandating stronger age-assurance measures, with detailed technical standards and greater scrutiny of how platforms implement them.

Andy Lulham ·
opinion

How Adult Platforms Can Prepare for California's AB 1705 Requirements

California’s AB 1705 takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, giving adult website operators a short runway to prepare. Signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 30, the law creates new obligations involving uploader verification, age and consent certifications, record retention and content already displayed on covered websites.

Corey Silverstein ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Help Merchants Avoid Onboarding Delays

Adding a new acquiring partner, whether directly through a bank or through a payment facilitator, can mean an onboarding process that takes up to two months.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Layered Fraud Controls Can Stop Card Testing Before Chargebacks Hit

You suddenly have 400 new $1 trial signups. Sales are up, the approval rate looks great and, at first glance, the numbers seem worth celebrating.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Falcon/NakedSword Makes Every Body Count in 'Deeper by the Dozen'

Double trouble is on the menu in NakedSword’s “Deeper by the Dozen,” an all-sex buffet where personal space is scarce and temptation is plentiful. Trading scripted drama for a fresh batch of bare buns, the studio serves up two gangbangs with exclusive Jaxx Cody and “Trailer Trash Boys” regular Ian Sterling as the main course.

Christian Cintron ·
profile

BranditScan's Aerie Saunders on Fostering Creator Knowledge, Confidence and Community

Aerie Saunders is firmly in her season. When she sits down with XBIZ, a fall-scented WoodWick candle burns in the background, pumpkins decorate her desk and the first signs of spooky season are already on display. Not that Saunders waits until autumn to embrace the macabre.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

What Mastercard's Scam Monitoring Program Means for Adult Merchants

Mastercard's Scam Merchant Monitoring Program (SMMP) has introduced a new, investigation-led framework that works very differently from the ratio-based chargeback programs the industry has relied on for years. It applies to card-not-present merchants globally, and Mastercard's guidance on business models warranting closer attention includes adult content and dating platforms, along with subscription services, digital goods and forex.

Len Garcia ·
opinion

Why the Right Merchant Category Code Matters for NSFW AI Businesses

You explained exactly what your NSFW AI business does to your payment processor and they seemed to get it. The underwriting process felt thorough and exhausting, but it was well worth it because you began processing.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How Local Payments Can Expand Access and Reduce Friction at Checkout

Global adult platforms often enter new markets with a familiar assumption: If their checkout accepts major cards, they're ready for local customers. In reality, payment habits vary widely by country. Dutch consumers use iDEAL for online shopping, BLIK is a leading e-commerce payment method in Poland, and India's UPI handles billions of transactions each month.

Mitch Platt ·
opinion

How Detailed Receipts Build Consumer Trust and Reduce Chargeback

When was the last time you bought something online? Chances are you looked for the confirmation almost immediately. Did the transaction go through? Does it show what you bought? Were you charged correctly? And if there's a problem, who can you contact?

Cathy Beardsley ·
Show More