opinion

The End of the Beginning?

When I saw attorney and Free Speech Coalition Board Chair Jeffrey Douglas recently at a Los Angeles trade event, where he was speaking on a panel after having just returned from Phoenix and the just-concluded JM/5 Star obscenity case, he was like a new man.

With an irrepressible Cheshire cat grin and eyes glinting with glee, he leaned into the microphone and recounted in withering detail (and palpable satisfaction) how miserably deficient the government's case had been, and how important the victory had been for the plaintiffs and the industry.

But like all experienced lawyers, Douglas knows that benevolent tidings for an outlaw industry can never be counted on to last very long. Indeed, when we win big victories, they seem to inspire dreadful overreaction by an assortment of enemies at all levels. The result is that we seem to be the boy forever sticking an insufficient number of fingers into the holes of the dyke.

The problem with this perception of uncertain advancement is that it may be less accurate than it appears. The big picture reality, which is so hard to glean when dealing with a battlefield so vast and disjointed, could be that the tide truly is starting to turn regarding the ability of adult companies to stay in business without having to always keep an eye over their shoulder for the next insufferable zoning law, dancer/performer regulation, township ordinance, obscenity charge, 2257 inspection, etc.

The justification for optimism is not just the JM victory, but also the ruling in October by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that overturned the 2257 record-keeping regulations in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee. That ruling came in the Connection Distributing vs. Gonzales case, brilliantly litigated by Connection attorney J. Michael Murray, which has been underway since 1995 and has taken a public back seat to the more widely-publicized FSC vs. Gonzales lawsuit brought in 2005 in U.S. District Court in Colorado.

In the Connection case, the government had argued that 2257 was aimed only at conduct and not speech, but Judge Cornelia G. Kennedy said in the opinion, "This argument is unpersuasive. While the government is indeed aiming at conduct, child abuse, it is regulating protected speech, sexually explicit images of adults, to get at that conduct."

We do not know at this time if this ruling will be appealed by the Justice Department, first to the full panel of the 6th Circuit and then if affirmed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but hopes are high that the sound reasoning of the court will prevail across the board. If so, it will be a stunning victory for the industry and the federal courts, which will have upheld an essential legal right that is also one of the cornerstones of democratic jurisprudence.

The Justice Department has only just had its new attorney general confirmed by the U.S. Senate, so we have no clue whether it will continue to play hardball with the industry. Neither do we know if the final year leading up to the presidential election will bring an avalanche of anti-porn accusations and demands for action from both Democratic and Republican candidates, but I would not doubt it.

What I do know is that these victories could not have come at a better time. We needed them because we needed to see that we are not alone and have "friends" in high places. The question now is whether we can we get our act together to build on those victories?

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

WIA Profile: Lexi Morin

Lexi Morin’s journey into the adult industry began with a Craigslist ad and a leap of faith. In 2011, fresh-faced and ambitious, she was scrolling through job ads on Craigslist when she stumbled upon a listing for an assistant makeup artist.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Still Rocking: The Hun Celebrates 30 Years in the Game

In the ever-changing landscape of adult entertainment, The Hun’s Yellow Pages stands out for its endurance. As one of the internet’s original fixtures, literally nearly as old as the web itself, The Hun has functioned as a living archive for online adult content, quietly maintaining its relevance with an interface that feels more nostalgic than flashy.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

Digital Desires: AI's Emerging Role in Adult Entertainment

The adult industry has always been ahead of the curve when it comes to embracing new technology. From the early days of dial-up internet and grainy video clips to today’s polished social media platforms and streaming services, our industry has never been afraid to innovate. But now, artificial intelligence (AI) is shaking things up in ways that are exciting but also daunting.

Steve Lightspeed ·
opinion

More Than Money: Why Donating Time Matters for Nonprofits

The adult industry faces constant legal battles, societal stigma and workplace challenges. Fortunately, a number of nonprofit organizations work tirelessly to protect the rights and well-being of adult performers, producers and industry workers. When folks in the industry think about supporting these groups, donating money is naturally the first solution that comes to mind.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Consent Guardrails: How to Protect Your Content Platform

The adult industry takes a strong and definite stance against the creation or publication of nonconsensual materials. Adult industry creators, producers, processors, banks and hosts all share a vested interest in ensuring that the recording and publication of sexually explicit content is supported by informed consent.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

Payment Systems: Facilitator vs. Gateway Explained

Understanding and selecting the right payment platform can be confusing for anyone. Recently, Segpay launched its payment gateway. Since then, we’ve received numerous questions about the difference between a payment facilitator and a payment gateway. Most merchants want to know which type of platform best meets their business needs.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Reinventing Intimacy: A Look at AI's Implications for Adult Platforms

The adult industry has long revolved around delivering pleasure and entertainment, but now it’s moving into new territory: intimacy, connection and emotional fulfillment. And AI companions are at the forefront of that shift.

Daniel Keating ·
profile

Nicole Vaunt on Turning Desire Into a Work of Art

It’s not every day you come across someone who can speak just as passionately about smutty novels and tabletop board games as they can about lighting, lens choices and shooting adult content in sub-zero temperatures. But Nicole Vaunt doesn’t fit easily into one box — and that’s just the way she likes it.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA: Sara Edwards on Evolving Clip Culture and Creator Empowerment

Though she works behind the scenes, Sara Edwards has had a front-row seat to the evolution of adult content creation. Having been immersed in the sector since 1995, she has a unique perspective on the industry.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

Segpay Marks 20 Years of High-Risk Triumphs

Payment processors are behind-the-scenes players in the world of ecommerce, yet their role is critical. Ensuring secure, seamless transactions while navigating a rapidly changing regulatory landscape requires both technological expertise and business acumen.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More