opinion

The Growing Threat of Synthetic Shoppers

The Growing Threat of Synthetic Shoppers

Fraud isn’t a new thing. In fact, people have been posing as other people for as long as civilization has been in existence. With the global pandemic, so many shoppers have resorted to solely digital transactions. COVID-19 has changed the face of business across the globe, and has created an ever-growing list of online businesses, and the customers to go with it. Along with all of this online business comes the synthetic shopper as well. What’s a synthetic shopper? A synthetic shopper is an online customer using a fraudulent identity to acquire merchandise, loans, etc.

Synthetic identity fraud uses a combination of real and false information. Social security numbers, physical addresses and email addresses can be used to create a new identity to gain credit cards, and assorted loans to make online purchases. It can be hard to validate the entirety of an identity when they have enough true information to make their fake persona seem real.

The problem with most forms of fraud protection is that synthetic identities are based off of mostly true information carefully distributed to throw off the scent.

In 2019, there was an article put out by the consulting and managing firm McKinsey & Company, which described online identity fraud as one of the fastest growing financial crimes out there. With access to so much information about people, without actually having to search very hard, it’s not difficult for those inclined towards fraud to build a convincing identity.

What Does an Increase in Synthetic Identities Mean for Businesses?

It could have the worst effect on merchants that offer up their own from of credit account for their customers. Private credit accounts won’t have bigger banks and credit companies behind them, which means the business owner will be the one responsible for any lost funds. It also means there won’t be the backing of fraud investigation teams, which could be essential when trying to track down and recover lost funds. Fraud affects all business, and the trickle down is going to eventually reach everyone, which is why it’s good to prepare for synthetic identities whenever you put your business online.

How to Discover a Synthetic Identity

Most currently existing forms of fraud protection aren’t designed to deal with newly formed synthetic identities. Forms of fraud protection are traditionally based around finding the items that don’t match up with a real identity, and using those to base the investigation off of. The problem with most forms of fraud protection is that synthetic identities are based off of mostly true information carefully distributed to throw off the scent.

Another part of the problem is that lenders are just writing the fraudulent activity off as a loss, and so it’s staying undetected by any fraud investigators. If the lenders think that the client they underwrote is just a loss, then they don’t necessarily think about it as a crime, just a bad customer. There are plenty of fraud crimes that have been able to slide under the radar due to lack of being reported.

It’s a smart move to hire a company to protect you from synthetic identity fraud. This kind of work requires a massive amount of data collection, and is still growing to keep up with the evolution of fraud.

Don't Scare Off Your Real Organic Customers

There isn’t a perfect form of synthetic identity detection out there, so as a business owner you also have to be aware of false positives. Because so much of the information being used isn’t made up information, it can be easy to have someone’s real identity be mistaken for a fake one. Be aware that you really don’t want to start scaring off customers, and that it may be worth it to place more faith in an identity that might be hard to validate.

Typically, there will be AI systems in place as a first line of defense against synthetic ID fraud, and it’s worth the risk to keep your customers feeling happy and secure, instead of feeling like they are constantly under questioning. Maintaining customer relations has to be one of the most important aspects of your business, if you wish to keep expanding your customer base.

With this new form of fraud, comes a whole new mess of problems for merchants, but it’s still worth running your business online. The market out there has grown so vast, and with the current standard of social distancing during the pandemic, it’s worth taking the risk to keep your business going and growing. There will always be new forms of fraud being invented, and that just means it’s worth keeping yourself up to date on what types of fraudulent activity are being committed. Keeping a watchful, but not paranoid eye on your business, and increasing clientele base that you will probably never meet, is going to help you head towards a profitable future.

Jonathan Corona has 15 years of experience in the electronic payments industry. As MobiusPay’s EVP, Corona is primarily responsible for day-to-day operations as well as reviewing and advising merchants on a multitude of compliance standards set forth by the card associations. MobiusPay specializes in merchant accounts in the U.S., EU and Asia. Follow them @MobiusPay on Twitter, Facebook and IG.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Platforms Can Tap AI to Moderate Content at Scale

Every day, billions of posts, images and videos are uploaded to platforms like Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and X. As social media has grown, so has the amount of content that must be reviewed — including hate speech, misinformation, deepfakes, violent material and coordinated manipulation campaigns.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

What DSA and GDPR Enforcement Means for Adult Platforms

Adult platforms have never been more visible to regulators than they are right now. For years, the industry operated in a gray zone: enormous traffic, massive data volume and minimal oversight. Those days are over.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Making the Case for Network Tokens in Recurring Billing

A declined transaction isn’t just a technical error; it’s lost revenue you fought hard to earn. But here’s some good news for adult merchants: The same technology that helps the world’s largest subscription services smoothly process millions of monthly subscriptions is now available to you as well.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Navigating Age Verification Laws Without Disrupting Revenue

With age verification laws now firmly in place across multiple markets, merchants are asking practical questions: How is this affecting traffic? What happens during onboarding? Which approaches are proving workable in real payment flows?

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Adult Businesses Can Navigate Global Compliance Demands

The internet has made the world feel small. Case in point: Adult websites based in the U.S. are now getting letters from regulators demanding compliance with foreign laws, even if they don’t operate in those countries. Meanwhile, some U.S. website operators dealing with the patchwork of state-level age verification laws have considered incorporating offshore in the hopes of avoiding these new obligations — but even operators with no physical presence in the U.S. have been sued or threatened with claims for not following state AV laws.

Larry Walters ·
opinion

Top Tips for Bulletproof Creator Management Contracts

The creator management business is booming. Every week, it seems, a new agency emerges, promising to turn creators into stars, automate their fan interactions or triple their revenue through “secret” social strategies. The reality? Many of these agencies are operating with contracts that wouldn’t survive a single serious dispute — if they even have contracts at all.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Sustainable Revenue Without Opt-Out Cross-Sales

Over the past year, we’ve seen growing pushback from acquirers on merchants using opt-out cross-sales — also known as negative option offers. This has been especially noticeable in the U.S. In fact, one of our acquirers now declines new merchants during onboarding if an opt-out flow is detected. Existing merchants submitting new URLs with opt-out cross-sales are being asked to remove them.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How to Handle Payment Disputes Without Sacrificing Trust

You can run the best-managed and most compliant website out there, but that still doesn’t completely shield you from the risks tied to payment disputes. Buyer’s remorse, an unclear billing description or even a simple misunderstanding can lead a customer to dispute a transaction. Accumulate enough disputes, and both your reputation and revenue could be at risk.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Taylor Moore

With a 70-person team and a growing slate of tools for content creators, the Teasy Agency has developed a reputation for putting talent first. That commitment owes a lot to co-founder Taylor Moore’s own experiences as a cam model.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Cathy Turns Creator Platform Experience Into a Model-First Playbook

As both a model and industry executive, Cathy lives in two worlds at once. “Since I do both things, I can act as the liaison between the model community and the rest of the SextPanther team,” she tells XBIZ.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More