opinion

Can Adult Break CP Link?

As director of nephrology at the Children's Hospital in San Diego, Dr. Jacques Lemire specialized in pediatric kidney transplants. The well-respected doctor retired from the institution in 2004; in April, federal investigators searched Lemire's home and office at UCSD Medical Center and discovered thousands of child pornography images on his computers. For now, Lemire faces one count of possessing child pornography.

Six days after the Lemire story broke, Jerzy Sieczynski, a 55-year-old Catholic priest in San Antonio, Texas, pleaded guilty to having child pornography on his home computer. Most of the pictures, investigators claimed, were from websites that featured 12-14-year-old boys.

The same week that Sieczynski entered his plea, Edward Gwaltney, a former teacher at a girls preparatory school in Chattanooga, Tenn., announced his intention to plead guilty to one count of possession of child pornography. Gwaltney taught at the school for 17 years before being dismissed for downloading 173 inappropriate images to a faculty computer.

Doctor, priest, teacher. Aside from child pornography, what do these three stories have in common? Absolutely nothing, according to Joan Irvine, executive director of ASACP.

"These are tragic cases, but nobody is accusing churches, schools and hospitals of harboring child pornographers," Irvine says. "And there's no more factual basis for linking child pornography to the adult industry than there is in linking it to those institutions."

Irvine believes that the government knows what child pornography is and where it comes from, and yet the Justice Department and politicians are constantly attempting to link the production and marketing of child porn with the legitimate adult industry.

"Members of Congress and the attorney general go around repeating the phrase 'obscenity and child pornography' as if just putting the words next to each other in the same sentence make them the same thing," Irvine says.

From local news broadcasts to the 24-hour information networks such as CNN and Fox, anchors and reporters are breathlessly commingling the words "child pornography" and "obscenity" while warning viewers that an Internet predator is just one MySpace page away from snatching your children.

Gonzales' Take
"At the most basic level, the Internet is used as a tool for sending and receiving large amounts of child pornography on a relatively anonymous basis," Attorney General Alberto Gonzales said in an April address before the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Gonzales used the address to announce a new legislative initiative aimed at protecting children from becoming exposed to explicit material and also encouraging "electronic communications service providers" to report the presence of child porn on their systems, as if the safeguards provided by U.S.C. 18 § 2257 record-keeping law are not enough. "The threat is frighteningly real," Gonzales said. "It is growing rapidly and it must be stopped."

At the time of Gonzales' speech, adult entertainment attorney Lawrence G. Walters applauded the government's repeated efforts to crack down on child pornography as noble but noted that they have again managed to blur the lines between legal material produced for consenting adults and patently illegal material.

"This is just another dishonest attempt to tie the issues of child pornography with adult entertainment," he said. "These are two completely different issues, and it is an attempt to rile up the American people and focus that ire on the adult industry, which is not responsible for child pornography. We see this over and over again."

Gonzales' speech was well timed; April and May are two of the top sweeps ratings period for every one of the 210 television markets in the U.S., and news outlets pounced on the story. For Justice, the conditioning process of the American people could hardly be easier.

Commingling child pornography with mainstream adult entertainment has been an objective at the federal level going back to the 1980s, says Phil Harvey, president of Adam & Eve.

"Most Americans understand the difference very, very clearly," Harvey said. "The American people have very strong feelings about child pornography and often have ambivalent feelings about straight pornography despite the concerted efforts to conflate the two."

On the flip-side, Robert Peters, president of Morality in Media, is at the head of the parade where efforts to mingle kiddie porn with mainstream porn are concerned. Peters tells XBIZ that he believes there is "growing evidence that 'adult' pornography on the Internet is transforming essentially 'normal adults' into child sex predators."

What begins as an interest in pornography that does not depict children, Peters fervently believes, "progresses to an interest in 'teen porn' and/or child porn, and culminates in a desire to have sex with children."

First Amendment Attorney Joe Obenberger scoffs at the notion that teen-themed porn indoctrinates users into the dark side.

"If you had a nickel for every auto accident that happened because some guy was craning his neck to get a look at a 16-year-old girl in a tube top, you'd have a stack of nickels that would go from the Empire State Building to the Golden Gate Bridge," he tells XBIZ.

Those who make the leap from mainstream-produced 18-year-old flesh epics to the dark side of child pornography, Obenberger believes, are freakish anomalies and not the norm.

Government attempts to fight child pornography by stifling legal adult entertainment miss the mark badly, for one simple reason, Irvine said.

"All of these attempts, such as 2257, are based on a flawed premise — that the online adult industry is eager to exploit minors," Irvine said. "Our data indicates the opposite."

Child pornographers, Irvine added, are not selling images of young-looking 18-year-olds, "or even of real 16-year-olds," all of which are the sort of images 2257 is designed to catch.

"Sadly, these criminals specialize in the most heinous sexual abuse of much younger children," she said. "We have seen material involving children as young as 2 and 3 years old. Believe me, the pedophiles and criminals who produce and sell this material are not about to maintain records of the type regulated under 2257."

No one denies that pedophilic material flourishes on the Internet — traded primarily on private bulletin boards, in chatrooms and through bit-stream technology — but in the war on child pornography, no one takes the cake for sheer media-grabbing hyperbolic language quite like Rep. Diana DeGette, D-Colo.

In May, in preparing to propose an amendment to a telecommunications bill that would require ISPs to retain data on users so that law enforcement could access the information, DeGette stated to the press.

U.S. High on the Charts
"America is the No. 1 global consumer of child pornography and the No. 2 producer. This is a plague we had nearly wiped out in the 1970s, and sadly the Internet — an entity we practically worship for all the great things it has brought us — is being used to commit a crime against humanity."

The efforts of organizations like ASACP have proven that child pornographers are not adult webmasters or mainstream ISPs looking for a little extra cash. They are criminals, Irvine said, many of which are based in Eastern Europe.

After reviewing more than 150,000 reports, ASACP's data clearly shows that 99.9 percent of the real child porn sites they investigate are not related to the professional adult entertainment industry.

Why then do lawmakers and the media choose so vigilantly to perpetuate this misunderstanding, this blurring of the lines?

"The bottom line is, equating adult entertainment with child pornography helps politicians justify a broad anti-porn agenda, which caters to the Religious Right," Irvine said. "This is dangerous because those politicians are apparently more interested in winning votes than in actually protecting children."

As attorney Lawrence G. Walters said, this is an effort that has been and will be repeated "over and over again" as the federal government and law enforcement agencies attempt to get a grip on the ever-elusive explosion of child porn on the web.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

WIA Profile: Lainie Speiser

With her fiery red hair, thick-framed glasses and a laugh that practically hugs you, Lainie Speiser is impossible to miss. Having repped some of adult’s biggest stars during her 30-plus years in the business, the veteran publicist is also a treasure trove of tales dating back to the days when print was king and social media not even a glimmer in the industry’s eye.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

Fighting Back Against AI-Fueled Fake Takedown Notices

The digital landscape is increasingly being shaped by artificial intelligence, and while AI offers immense potential, it’s also being weaponized. One disturbing trend that directly impacts adult businesses is AI-powered “DMCA takedown services” generating a flood of fraudulent Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) notices.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Seamless Checkout Flows for High-Risk Merchants

For high-risk merchants such as adult businesses, crypto payments are no longer just a backup plan — they’re fast becoming a first choice. More and more businesses are embracing Bitcoin and other digital currencies for consumer transactions.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

What the New SCOTUS Ruling Means for AV Laws and Free Speech

On June 27, 2025, the United States Supreme Court handed down its landmark decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, upholding Texas’ age verification law in the face of a constitutional challenge and setting a new precedent that bolsters similar laws around the country.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

What You Need to Know Before Relocating Your Adult Business Abroad

Over the last several months, a noticeable trend has emerged: several of our U.S.-based merchants have decided to “pick up shop” and relocate to European countries. On the surface, this sounds idyllic. I imagine some of my favorite clients sipping coffee or wine at sidewalk cafés, embracing a slower pace of life.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

Andi Avalon Talks Wifey Life and the Joys of Suburban Chaos

Fans crave authenticity. For most adult content creators, this has become gospel. Everybody is looking for “the real deal” — and as it happens, you can’t get much more real than MILF creator-performer Andi Avalon.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Salima

When Salima first entered the adult space in her mid-20s, becoming a power player wasn’t even on her radar. She was simply looking to learn. Over the years, however, her instinct for strategy, trust in her teams and commitment to creator-first innovation led her from the trade show floor to the executive suite.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

How the Interstate Obscenity Definition Act Could Impact Adult Businesses

Congress is considering a bill that would change the well-settled definition of obscenity and create extensive new risks for the adult industry. The Interstate Obscenity Definition Act, introduced by Sen. Mike Lee, makes a mockery of the First Amendment and should be roundly rejected.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

What US Sites Need to Know About UK's Online Safety Act

In a high-risk space like the adult industry, overlooking or ignoring ever-changing rules and regulations can cost you dearly. In the United Kingdom, significant change has now arrived in the form of the Online Safety Act — and failure to comply with its requirements could cost merchants millions of dollars in fines.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Understanding the MATCH List and How to Avoid Getting Blacklisted

Business is booming, sales are steady and your customer base is growing. Everything seems to be running smoothly — until suddenly, Stripe pulls the plug. With one cold, automated email, your payment processing is shut down. No warning, no explanation.

Jonathan Corona ·
Show More