The Outer Limits of Pornography

In his latest book, Remix: Making Art and Commerce Thrive in the Hybrid Economy, Stanford Law School professor and Obama transition team consultant Lawrence Lessig makes yes another appeal for a massive overhaul of copyright law. He fervently believes we need to embrace the economic potential of the digital age while also preventing the further criminalization of succeeding generations of content users.

The "remix" phenomenon in the title refers to the incorporative ways in which digital content is taken and used — often by young artists — to create original works. The most common uses that come to mind are music remixes, of course, but increasingly people are taking video and mashing it up to create new works that also incorporate music and ideas "borrowed" from others. The field is a burgeoning realm of creativity, and Lessig is worried that everyone currently working in it is also living with the fact that they are a criminal. Few, if any, of them pre-license the digital content they use as their inspiration and raw material.

One of Lessig's points with respect to how we should think of remix or mash-up culture is to compare it with how we traditionally think about using the written word. No one, for instance, would consider asking for prior permission from an author before quoting from his or her article or book. We take for granted the right to "mash-up" the written word. Lessig's point is that young people think of music and video as previous generations think about text. It has essentially morphed from content to language, and Lessig is saying that we do not want to, and ultimately cannot, restrain its usage through the use of laws that criminalize every time we make a copy, even unwittingly, which is just about a hundred times every day.

He also advocates for copyright laws that help promote "hybrid" economies, by which he means "a commercial entity that aims to leverage value from a sharing economy, or... a sharing economy that builds a commercial entity that better supports its sharing aim." (BTW, I did not contact Lessig before quoting from his book.) The paradigm example of a sharing economy is Wikipedia and its many offshoots, which exist and thrive because of the unremunerated contributions of many people. Paradigmatic commercial economies online are many, of course, and include Netflix, Amazon and Google, to name a few.

A hybrid economy combines the two. Some examples Lessig uses of successful hybrids include Craig's List, Flickr, Dogster and YouTube. In the adult sphere, we have our own hybrids. The adult chat board, Go Fuck Yourself, is in fact a hybrid economy, in which its value is derived from the active participation of people, many of whom derive no direct revenue from their participation. That is not to say that they do not derive any value from their participation, but that the value is often indirect and personal, and not quantifiable. This value dynamic is true of all shared and hybrid economies, however.

GFY itself, of course, derives direct revenue from the site, and has incorporated increasing subsets of revenue into the model. It remains to be seen if this commercialization throws off the balance necessary to sustain its collective appeal. All current hybrids are in fact experiments in finding that balance. Alienate your contributors and you could find them fleeing to spaces that better meet their community requirements.

Artists making mash-ups or remixed content using porn, and the extent to which the industry should care, will be the subject of a future column. Adult entertainment may be a special case.


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles


Legal and Business Safety for Creators at Trade Shows

As I write this, I am preparing to attend XBIZ Miami, which reminds me of attending my first trade show 20 years ago. Since then, I have met thousands of people from all over the world who were doing business — or seeking to do business — in the adult industry.

Corey D. Silverstein ·

Adding AI to Your Company's Tech Toolbox

Artificial intelligence is all the rage. Not only is AI all over the headlines, it is also top of mind for many company leadership teams, who find themselves asking, “How can this new tool help our company?”

Cathy Beardsley ·

The Ins and Outs of IP Addresses: What Website Owners Should Know

Think about your home address, the place you live. It is unique. That’s important because when you decide to invite someone over, they will need directions to find you. It’s even more important if you want a lot of visitors.

Brad Mitchell ·

AI Is Coming: A Look at What's Ahead and Its Implications

The AI era has dawned, and the impact of this technology is beginning to be felt across the adult industry. We are already seeing a plethora of content, synthetic interactions and customizable avatars enabled by artificial intelligence.

Alejandro Freixes ·

Navigating Fraud Prevention in Credit Card Transactions

In the digital age, credit card transactions are essential to global commerce, providing unmatched convenience for consumers and businesses alike. With this convenience, however, comes the risk of credit card fraud, which can result in considerable financial losses and harm brand reputation.

Jonathan Corona ·

A Guide to Avoiding Scams in Hard Link Media Buying

‘If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” So cautionary wisdom reminds us, yet people still get scammed all the time. Fortunately, there are “red flags” you can watch for to help you identify scams and thereby avoid them.

Juicy Jay ·

The Dos and Don'ts of AI-Generated Content

AI is a hot topic. From automation to personal assistance to content generation, AI technology is already impacting our daily lives. Many industries, including adult, have had positive results using AI for customer support and marketing.

Cathy Beardsley ·

Strategic Upscaling of Non-4K Content

If content is king in adult, then technical quality is the throne upon which it sits. Technical quality drives customer acquisition and new sales, while cementing retention and long-term loyalty.

Brad Mitchell ·

'Traffic Captain' Andy Wullmer Braves the High Seas as Spirited Exec

Wullmer networked and hobnobbed, gaining expertise in everything from ecommerce to SEO and traffic, making connections and over time rising through the ranks of several companies to become CEO of the mobile business arm of TrafficPartner.

Alejandro Freixes ·

To Cloud or Not to Cloud, That Is the Question

Let’s be honest. It just sounds way cooler to say your business is “in the cloud,” right? Buzzwords make everything sound chic and relevant. In fact, someone uninformed might even assume that any hosting that is not in the cloud is inferior. So what’s the truth?

Brad Mitchell ·
Show More