Home > News > Legal News > German ISP May Block Access to Google • Bookmark   • Register
Search Options

NEWS STORY

German ISP May Block Access to Google

A German court has been asked to block the search engine for displaying adult content without age verification, something prohibited under German law.
XBIZ POLL
Have your Blu-ray sales met expectations?
Yes
No
We don't sell Blu-ray titles
 
Monday, Dec 10, 2007    Text size: 
FRANKFURT — A German adult website operator has filed for expedited proceedings in the district court in Frankfurt to force the German ISP Arcor to block Google.de and Google.com in order to prevent the display of adult images without age verification, which is prohibited under German law.

The request was filed by Huch Medien GmbH, the company that owns and operates AmateurStar.de, according to the news site Heise.de.

In its filing, Huch Medien reportedly said it would not simply sit back and watch as Google’s image search displayed pornographic images to users of all ages, including “clearly prohibited animal pornography.”

Huch Medien reported the issue to Arcor directly on Nov. 20, according to reports, and waited to see if the ISP would take measures to block Google. After receiving no response from Arcor to the original report or to a subsequent formal cease and desist letter sent by the company’s attorneys, Huch Medien took the matter to court.

Huch Medien Executive Director Tobias Huch said that he’s merely trying to get the German legal system to clarify the scope of the liability exemptions offered to ISPs under the German Telemedia Act.

“The court needs to tell us whether the German way is the only way,” Huch said.

Huch asserted that since Germany blocks sites like YouPorn.com — as the court ordered Arcor to do in October — then the country theoretically should block all websites that violate relevant German and/or European Union law.

If Germany is going to maintain such a legal posture and engage in blocking sites in widespread fashion, then “we should not complain when China blocks a large number of websites,” Huch said.

According to German attorney Daniel Koetz, the only European member of the 1st Amendment Lawyers Association and a bar-certified specialist in copyright and media law, the German law requiring age verification applies to all websites that can be accessed from Germany.

Koetz told XBIZ that the Telemedia Act requires “all sites bearing content presumably harmful to minors such as pornography to have an age-verification system.”

“Such an age-verification system has to ‘secure that minors cannot access the site,’” Koetz said. “Such is the written law.”

Koetz said that under the law, German authorities and courts only deem an age-verification system to be secure if the system forces end users to have personal contact with a third party who verifies their age.

“[It is] just like when entering an adult bookstore; the owner sees the customer, and the customer is over 18 years old,” Koetz said. “So, we have a ‘PostIdent-Verfahren’ which is an identification-process via your post office. You go there with a form, clerk sees the form and your passport, acknowledges your being over 18 and there you go.”

One of the problems with that system, Koetz said, is “who wants to go through all that hassle to enter a porn site, and who wants postal clerks to know you’re a pervert watching porn?”

Koetz said that as a result of the law, traffic to German porn sites is low because “everybody goes to other countries’ sites.”

Those foreign sites, however, are subject to being blocked by German ISPs by order of the courts, Koetz said — as Huch has requested that the Frankfurt court to Arcor to do with Google.

Koetz said that Huch’s request was filed in order to demonstrate “the perversion of all this.”

“Germany does not have a porn problem — it has a freedom-of-information-via-the-Internet problem,” Koetz said.

   
Share this article:
del.icio.us technorati fark
More ways to get news:  XBIZ RSS  |  XBIZ Newsletters  |  XBIZ Desktop News  |  XBIZ Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !

LEGAL PERSPECTIVES

Competition, Branding and Trademarks

Once upon a time, not too long ago, the adult entertainment industry consisted of a few dozen brave producers and wholesale distributors who dared to create and sell explicit motion pictures and magazines... More »

An Erosion of the Law

Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the July, 2008, issue of XBIZ World Magazine. If you have been paying attention to the news lately you've probably seen dozens of reports about melting... More »

Demystifying Contracts

For many in the online adult industry the idea of entering into written contracts with someone you do business with can be an intimidating one. As with most phobias, the fear of written contracts can be... More »
XBIZ NEWSLETTERS
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.







POPULAR PRODUCTS & SERVICES
Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
XBIZ Premiere™, the industry's premier trade journal, features in-depth and comprehensive business news and information targeted for producers of adult videos, novelty product manufacturers, and retailers - get it today!

UPCOMING EVENTS

Ocean Social

Oct 13 - Oct 17
Port Canaveral, FL

VENUS

Oct 16 - Oct 19
Berlin, Germany

Island Gathering

Oct 17 - Oct 20
Curacao, Netherlands Antilles

Island Gathering

Oct 17 - Oct 20
Curacao
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!