After 5 Years, Extreme Associates Case 'Running its Course'

PITTSBURGH — According to an article posted this week on the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette website, the Extreme Associates obscenity case, which is in its fifth year, has stalled. But Extreme attorney H. Louis Sirkin says that, to the contrary, the case is running its course.

However, Sirkin did tell XBIZ that certain delays have taken place due to unavoidable scheduling conflicts with U.S. District Judge Gary Lancaster, who is presiding over the case.

"The last time we had a telephone conference, the judge was getting ready to undergo a very long trial, so he said that he was willing to give us some alternate dates to have some additional hearings on some motions," Sirkin said. "Our understand is that that trial ended up with a hung jury, and that they started again and that it’s on a delay now."

Sirkin added that they are still waiting to have a routine status conference call, the agenda for which was unclear.

"I don’t what [Lancaster] wants to talk about, but maybe we will pick a motion hearing date and also some day in the future as to a possible trial date, I don’t know," he said.

Sirkin did say that the calendar does not bode well for concluding any major business this year.

"I’m not even sure we’ll have any oral hearing on the remaining motions that the judge wanted to have before the end of the year," he said.

One outstanding motion has to do with clarifying the definition of "community" with respect to Internet distribution of adult material, something Sirkin believes is certainly on the agenda for the next oral hearing, whenever it takes place.

"Yes, that’s what [Lancaster] wants [to talk about] and of course the case law in the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has improved for us with the recent COPA (Child Online Protection Act) decision," he said, adding that because there is no established consensus as far as Internet distribution is concerned, the manner in which this case deals with the issue should be of interest to courts around the county.

"It’s a very interesting questions, especially for every judge around the country who I think will pay attention to the argument that when dealing with the Internet the marketplace becomes a much different thing," Sirkin said.

When asked whether he believes Lancaster is interested in dealing directly with the question, Sirkin answered unequivocally.

"Absolutely," he said, repeating, "Absolutely."

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

JustFor.fans Wins Trademark Infringement Case Against Fraudulent Domain

The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has ruled in favor of fan site JustFor.fans in a case against a website using an infringing domain.

Elegant Angel Debuts 'Charlotte Sins Is Slutwoman' Showcase

Charlotte Sins takes on the role of "Slutwoman" in the latest iteration of Elegant Angel's signature showcase series.

Jade Venus, Zariah Aura Topline Latest Volume of Aiden Starr's 'PansexualX Porn Crush'

Jade Venus and Zariah Aura headline director Aiden Starr's "PansexualX Porn Crush 14," from Evil Angel.

Aylo Moves to Settle Two 'Children of Pornhub' Class-Action Lawsuits

Aylo has agreed to terms for a settlement with the plaintiffs in two long-running class actions over allegations that former Pornhub parent company MindGeek knowingly allowed and profited from CSAM on its sites.

Ophelia Fae, Ameena Green Take a Bow at Screening of Casey Calvert's 'Straight Girls'

Casey Calvert returned to Elysian Theater in Los Angeles on Thursday night for an intimate screening of her new Adult Time/Girlsway feature "Straight Girls," which just so happens to have been filmed on that very stage.

Busty Anabel Makes Studio Debut, Performs Her 1st DVP for Immoral Productions

Busty Anabel has made her studio debut and performed her first DVP alongside Matt Bird, Jacob Coldwater, and studio honcho “Porno Dan” Leal in the latest trilogy from Immoral Productions.

Kira Noir Leads Latest From Brazzers

Kira Noir stars with Eddie Jaye in the studio's latest release, titled “Couples Massage Getaway.”

Tigerlilly Launches 'SugarCoatedSweethearts' Through PAYSITE

Tigerlilly has launched SugarCoatedSweethearts.com through PAYSITE.

Gender X Debuts Jim Powers' Limited Series 'Trans Deliveries'

Gender X Films has debuted the first installment of director Jim Powers’ limited series "Trans Deliveries."

Lo Lacey Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Lo Lacey has made her debut for Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY alongside her husband Nathan, Dan Damage, and Goldey.

Show More