Napster Dismissal: File Sharing Not Piracy

SACREMENTO, Calif. — A district court judge has dismissed a copyright infringement lawsuit against Napster Inc., stating, in essence, that simply making a copyrighted file available on a file-sharing network does not constitute infringement.

The upshot is that Judge Marilyn Patel’s decision contradicts early media interpretations of the recently passed Artists’ Rights of Theft Prevention Act of 2005, which was seen as lowering the bar for online copyright prosecutions.

The ART Act, signed into law last month, established criminal penalties of up to three years in prison and hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines for the distribution of "pre-released" movies over the Internet.

At the time of the law’s passage, it was widely interpreted to mean that leaving files open in shared or exposed folders would be enough to prosecute peer-to-peer network operators, regardless of whether any files were downloaded.

This is the argument that plaintiffs in the case, which included UMG Recordings Inc., used in their motion against Napster — that simply making a file available for distribution should be considered an infringing act and that websites that offer such files for download should be held criminally liable for copyright violations.

But in her three-page dismissal order, Patel said she found the plaintiffs’ argument unconvincing because they failed to show evidence of distribution.

Patel went on to say that despite media speculation to the contrary, the language of the ART Act actually makes a clear distinction between “making available” something for distribution and the act of distributing it, and that the plaintiffs conveniently disregarded that language in their abstract.

If Congress had intended to make it a criminal offense to leave files open for download on P2P networks, Patel pointed out, they should have and could have explicitly done so in the language of the law.

Yale Law School fellow Ernest Miller said Patel’s decision could have far-reaching consequences for defense against prosecution under the ART Act.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Federal Appeals Court Vacates FTC 'Click to Cancel' Rule Pending Review

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit on Tuesday vacated the Federal Trade Commission’s “click-to-cancel” rule aimed at making it easier for consumers to cancel online subscriptions, pending further review.

NYC Adult Stores Lose Challenge to Zoning Law, May Face Relocation

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit on Tuesday upheld a lower court’s decision to allow enforcement of a 2001 zoning law aimed at forcing adult retail stores out of most parts of New York City.

FSC Drops Florida AV Lawsuit in Wake of SCOTUS Decision

A U.S. district court judge granted on Tuesday a motion by Free Speech Coalition to dismiss the trade association’s lawsuit over Florida’s age verification law, a case that had been on hold pending the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on the constitutionality of state AV laws.

Ukrainian President Responds to Porn Legalization Petition

President Volodymyr Zelensky responded Tuesday to an OnlyFans model’s petition to decriminalize pornography in Ukraine, stating that he would wait for the legislative process to play out “in accordance with established procedure.”

Only Tax Deductions Joins Pineapple Support as Sponsor

Adult industry accounting firm Only Tax Deductions has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Adult Empire Launches 'Conversations' Podcast Series

Adult Empire has launched a new official podcast series hosted by Nicole Chappelle and Charlie.

Sex Work CEO Launches 'Teams Plan' for AI Assistant

Sex Work CEO has introduced the new Teams Plan for its AI-powered, NSFW text generator, GPTease.

2025 XBIZ Amsterdam Website Launches With Call for Speakers

XBIZ is pleased to announce that the website for its annual European conference, XBIZ Amsterdam, is now live.

NC Governor Vetoes Bill Targeting Adult Industry, Override Possible

North Carolina Governor Josh Stein today vetoed a bill imposing new regulations that adult industry observers have warned could push adult websites and platforms to ban most adult creators and content.

25,000 Sign Petition to Legalize Pornography in Ukraine

An OnlyFans model’s petition to decriminalize pornography in Ukraine has amassed the 25,000 signatures required for official consideration by President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Show More