Defense Files New Petition in Ray Guhn Case

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Attorneys for Clinton McCowen, aka Ray Guhn, have filed a petition for a writ of prohibition at the 1st U.S. District Court of Appeals in Tallahassee, asking the appeals court to direct the trial court to cease exercising jurisdiction over the obscenity offenses alleged in the case pending against McCowen.

As stated in the petition, the question the defense asked the appeals court to resolve is “do the state’s various obscenity statutes apply to allegedly obscene materials disseminated solely via the Internet, and, if so, do such statutes violate what has come to be known as the dormant Commerce Clause of … the [U.S.] Constitution?”

McCowen’s attorney, Lawrence Walters, argued in the petition that the court should grant the writ of prohibition because his client “lacks a plain, speedy and adequate remedy at law.” Walters asserted that if the defense’s arguments are correct, then without the grant of the writ, his client would be deprived of his “constitutional right to avoid prosecution under an unconstitutional or inapplicable statute.”

“[S]uffering a three-week jury trial on these charges followed by an appeal would be an inadequate method for securing his constitutional right to be free from an unconstitutional prosecution,” Walters said in the petition.

Walters told XBIZ that the upshot of his argument is that “either which way [the state of Florida] turns, there is a jurisdictional problem with their case.”

“If the appeals court rules that the statute does not apply to Internet-based obscenity, then the trial court lacks jurisdiction to handle the case,” Walters said. “If they rule that the statute does apply to Internet-based materials, then the statute violates the dormant Commerce Clause.”

In the petition, Walters noted that the state itself does not dispute that the materials at issue in the case are entirely Internet-based.

The state’s probable cause affidavit “expressly stated that this case is based on the alleged distribution of allegedly obscene materials over the Internet, and neither that affidavit, nor any other discovery materials suggest that any other type of distribution of allegedly obscene materials is at issue in this case,” the defense stated in its petition.

The defense petition also stated that while the Florida state legislature has amended its child pornography statutes and laws prohibiting the sending of harmful matter to minors such that those laws clearly cover use of the Internet to transmit child porn and harmful matter, the legislature has not amended the state obscenity statute to do the same.

“In short, both as to ‘material harmful to minors’ and ‘child pornography’ the state legislature was extremely clear in indicating that its criminal statutes are intended to apply to some types of Internet transmissions,” Walters said in the petition. “In marked contrast, no such language appears in this very same chapter in the section establishing the prohibition on ‘obscene’ materials.”

The defense petition also noted that other states have tried to extend their obscenity laws to cover Internet-based materials, only to see their amended laws struck down by the courts as violating the dormant Commerce Clause.

“Similar statutes providing sexual content restrictions which expressly apply to materials on Internet websites have been repeatedly and consistently found in violation of the dormant Commerce Clause,” Walters wrote. “All seven of the previously cited cases involving state restrictions of sexual content on Internet websites included, entirely independent of any 1st Amendment discussion, a judicial determination that the challenged statute violated the dormant Commerce Clause.”

If the appeals court finds merit in the defense’s petition, Walters said the court could issue an “order to show cause” that would “bring the trial court’s activity to a screeching halt.” If the court rejects the defense petition, on the other hand, then the trial court will move ahead with the case.

Asked how long it might take to play out in court, Walters said that if the appeals court issued an order to show cause, it wouldn’t much matter to the defense how long it took, since that order would halt the progress of the trial court.

“They are supposed to treat requests for extraordinary relief as a priority,” Walters said. “So we expect it would be a matter of months and not years” for the appeals court to handle the issue, should it grant the defense’s petition.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Michigan Legislators Propose Online Porn Ban

Michigan lawmakers have introduced a bill that would make it illegal to distribute pornography via the internet in the state.

Florida AG Sues Aylo, Segpay Over State AV Law

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed lawsuits against Aylo and Segpay on Monday with the 12th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida for noncompliance with HB3, the state's age verification law.

Colombian Court Sides with Performer Esperanza Goméz Over IG Suspensions

Colombia’s Constitutional Court last week ruled in favor of adult performer Esperanza Gómez in her legal battle against Meta over repeated suspensions of her Instagram account.

Missouri AG Announces Age Verification Rule to Take Effect Nov. 30

Newly appointed Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway announced Friday that the state's recently approved age verification regulation for adult websites will go into effect on Nov. 30.

Aylo, Woodhull Freedom Foundation to Host 'Online Censorship' Event

Aylo and Woodhull Freedom Foundation will co-host a virtual panel addressing online censorship on Sept. 30.

Severe Sex Films Relaunches Site Through YourPaysitePartner

Severe Sex Films has relaunched its official website through YourPaysitePartner (YPP).

Judge Awards Plaintiffs Over $400K in Attorneys Fees in Derek Hay Civil Case

California Superior Court Judge Gail Killefer has awarded former clients of LA Direct Models over $400,000 in attorneys fees and court costs, to be paid by agency founder Derek Hay.

ChickPass Rebrands as 'ChickPass Cinematic Universe'

ChickPass has announced that it has rebranded its network of sites as ChickPass Cinematic Universe.

Brazilian Adult Industry Association ABIPEA Launches

Brazilian Association of the Adult Entertainment Industry and Professionals (ABIPEA) has officially launched its organization.

New Adult Social Media Platform 'Havven' Opens Beta Phase

Havven, a new adult social media platform, has opened its beta phase and will officially launch Oct. 5.

Show More