Home > News > U.S. Appeals Court Halts Enforcement of Mich. Nudity Ban • Bookmark   • Newsletters   • Register Search Options


U.S. Appeals Court Halts Enforcement of Mich. Nudity Ban

U.S. Appeals Court Halts Enforcement of Mich. Nudity Ban
Get XBIZ News
XBIZ Research
Will virtual reality boost the paysite market?
Yes, it will soon
Yes, but in a few years
Out of 179 votes. Results based on votes submitted by members of XBIZ.net social network.
Aug 31, 2007 7:00 AM PDT    Text size: 
DETROIT — The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has granted a preliminary injunction to a club and a dancer who challenged Michigan’s prohibition on nude dancing in establishments that serve alcohol, a decision that appears to have stemmed largely from the state’s mishandling of its legal arguments.

Hamilton’s Bogarts Inc., the company behind the Inkster, Mich., club Bogart’s Lounge, and a dancer named Kathleen Pozlin initiated the challenge to the state law, and moved for a preliminary injunction against its enforcement, arguing that the statute violated the 1st, 4th and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.

In February 2006, U.S. District Judge Julian Abele Cook Jr. denied the motion for a preliminary injunction, finding that they were unlikely to succeed on the merits of their case.

In reversing Cook’s decision, the 6th Circuit enumerated several errors the state made in arguing its case, including use of the wrong legal terminology and reliance on case law that has been rendered obsolete by subsequent U.S. Supreme Court decisions.

“In this argument, the state appears to confuse the doctrines of res judicata and collateral estoppel (issue preclusion),” the court wrote in its ruling, adding that because “collateral estoppel precludes future litigation of one specific issue, and because that is what the state effectively asks us to find, we construe their argument as one for collateral estoppel rather than res judicata, despite the substitution of one term for the other in the state’s brief.”

While the court was able to work around the state’s legal linguistic error, it could not assist the state where their case ran afoul of Supreme Court precedent.

The court noted that in rejecting the plaintiff’s 1st Amendment claims, the state relied on cases such as New York State Authority vs. Bellanca to argue that under the authority granted to states under the 21st Amendment to regulate liquor sales, a state could prohibit nude dancing where liquor is sold.

“Unfortunately for the state, the Supreme Court has entirely abandoned this rationale for upholding regulations that raise 1st Amendment concerns in places where alcohol is sold,” the court wrote.

The court noted that while the state definitely does have the authority to regulate nudity in alcohol-serving establishments as a function of attempting to mitigate negative “secondary effects,” neither the statute nor the state’s legal argument made reference to secondary effects.

“Although liquor consumption may well be a valid factor in a state’s consideration of secondary effects, it is no longer correct to argue that the 21st Amendment provides greater authority to regulate expressive conduct wherever liquor is sold,” the court wrote.

Throughout the nine-page decision, the court provides options the state could have pursued to craft a ban on nudity that could survive legal challenge — and notes repeatedly that the state simply has failed to exercise those options.

“Unfortunately, instead of addressing whether the regulations are content-based or content neutral and articulating any state interest that is furthered by the regulations, the state merely relies on its ‘broad discretion’ under [California vs.] LaRue,” the court wrote.

“We do not doubt that it is within the state’s police power to pass a nudity ban, to regulate places where liquor is sold, and to combat secondary effects that might be related to adult entertainment. But we are left to guess about the governmental interest at stake and how it is advanced by Rules 9 and 11, not to mention the critical question of which standard governs this case.”

Holding that the state had “advanced no relevant governmental interest and made no showing as to how Rules 9 and 11 advance such an interest,” the court determined that Cook had erred in denying the plaintiffs a preliminary injunction, and remanded the case to Cook with instruction to issue the injunction.

In a final admonishment to the state, the court closed its ruling by stating “hopefully the case will be litigated differently after remand.”

According to the Detroit News, Michigan club owners and their attorneys reacted to the rule with cautious optimism, noting that due to the reasoning behind the court’s ruling, the victory could be temporary.

Robert Horvath, attorney for a Detroit club called Chix, said that while some club owners might switch to fully nude dancing once Cook has issued an injunction, he planned to advise his clients against such a transition because the lifting of the ban was likely to be a “short-lived situation,” as the courts are likely to uphold a nudity ban that is better crafted — and better defended in court by the state.

More ways to get XBIZ News:  RSS Feeds  |  E-Newsletters  |  Desktop Widget  |  Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !


Cam World: A Good Grind Reaps Riches

For years, webcam modeling was taboo and considered by many as a dirty and raunchy activity. However, in today’s economy, webcam jobs are being accepted more and more by everyone across the globe.... More »

Cam World: Beauty on Point — Models Talk Tradecraft

Cam girls are the girls that are always on point — with the perfect make-up and perfect skin, the shiny hair and long nails. Given their expertise, I asked some of the girls from Studio 20 if they... More »

Cam World: Camming and Toys Go Hand in Hand

There is nothing more satisfying than pleasure, especially if it is sexual. The size or the presentation of the stimulus does not matter if the sensations and tension the body receives transform the way... More »
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.

Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
Subscribe to XBIZ World magazine, the industry's leading e-commerce trade publication, delivering in-depth coverage of the online, mobile and ancillary digital markets.


XBIZ.net Paysite Meetup

May 04 - May 04
Prague, Czech Republic

Eurowebtainment 2017

May 17 - May 20
Majorca, Spain

XBIZ Retreat

May 30 - Jun 03
Miami, Florida

XBIZ Miami 2017

May 30 - Jun 02
Miami, Florida
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!