Kink.com's Insurer Must Pay Porn HIV Litigation Costs — Judge

Kink.com's Insurer Must Pay Porn HIV Litigation Costs — Judge

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge yesterday told Kink.com’s insurer that it can’t avoid covering litigation costs over performers infected with HIV.

Atain Specialty Insurance Company sued Kink.com CEO Peter Acworth and Armory Studios LLC last year, claiming that he and his studio's property must cover his own legal bills and possible settlements in three suits filed by HIV-infected former performers Cameron Bay, Rod Daily and an unidentified John Doe.

The three plaintiffs all claim they were infected while working for Kink at Armory Studios properties, which are owned by Acworth.

Two of the performers infected — Bay and Daily — said that they were subjected to unprotected sex with members of the public. Doe said he was infected while performing in “Bound in Public.”

Atain attorney GailAnn Stargardter argued during a summary judgment hearing yesterday that the “physical and sexual abuse” exemption in the Armory insurance policy exempts Atain from paying off any court costs and claims.

Stargardtner contended that the Armory was complicit in requiring porn performers to perform without condoms and that her client is not required to defend Acworth or Armory in any lawsuit arising from a sexual act.

U.S. District Judge James Donato disagreed, ruling the insurance policy does not exclude coverage for litigation arising from any sexual act that occurs on the premises.

Donato said that whether the studio took adequate steps to protect actors is irrelevant, because the exclusion only covers sexual acts caused by an omission.

“The presence or absence of HIV safeguards did not cause them to have sex,” said Donato, according to Courthouse News, which covered the hearing at San Francisco federal court yesterday.

Donato said the injury was caused by alleged negligence, not the sexual act.

“How did anything the building owner do cause them to have sex?” Donato asked. “They were paid actors, paid to have sex. There’s no omission you can hang your hat on to deny coverage.”

Kink.com attorney Karen Tynan — one of the key leaders of the campaign to defeat the now-failed, porn-regulating Proposition 60 in California — told XBIZ on Friday that the ruling centered on the fact that Atain tried to use a "sexual abuse exclusion" that was intended for churches and schools.  

“It was an attempt to avoid coverage after enjoying the premiums,” Tynan said. “We are pleased that the judge saw through the bad faith of the insurance company.”

The decision, however, will likely be telegraphed to insurers that closely weigh risks when calculating premiums for film productions.

Even though the case involves a specific insurance contract and unique facts, the decision could be precedential, observed industry attorney Larry Walters.

“Insurance policies tend to use the same definitions and exclusions,” Walters told XBIZ. “So one decision interpreting a specific policy could have broad implications for similar cases, and for the insurance industry in general.”

Tynan offered a number of tips for producers of adult content when it comes to insurance coverage, which is necessary for any business.

“The ‘takeaway’ for producers is this — insurance is important,” Tynan said. “Work closely with your broker to understand your general liability policy, have good safety practices on set, and keep documentation — emails, notes, written policies, etc.”

Recent Attain filing to Rebut Kink

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Octavia Red Stars in Latest From Deeper

Octavia Red stars with Manuel Ferrera in the latest release from Vixen Media Group studio imprint Deeper, titled “She Done Him Wrong.”

Canadian Senator Revives Push for National AV Law

Sen. Julie Miville-Dechêne, whose previous multiple attempts to legislate national age verification requirements all failed, has introduced a new bill that would impose fines of up to $500,000 on adult sites that do not implement age verification for Canadian viewers.

Sarah Arabic, Vicki Chase Topline Dorcel's 'The Next Step'

Sarah Arabic and Vicki Chase star with multi-XMAs winner Seth Gamble in the latest feature from Dorcel, titled “The Next Step.”

FSC Submits Statement to House Committee in Support of FIRM Act

Free Speech Coalition has announced that it submitted a statement to the House Financial Services Committee in support of the Financial Integrity and Regulation Management (FIRM) Act.The announcement follows:

Plaiir Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Plaiir has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Sabien DeMonia to Drop 'Sabien Ass Fuck'

Evil Angel has announced “Sabien Ass Fuck,” the first title from director/performer Sabien DeMonia.

Trump Tariffs Remain in Effect Pending Appeal of Trade Court Ruling

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on Thursday stayed an injunction by the U.S. Court of International Trade, delaying the trade court’s order blocking the Trump administration’s sweeping tariffs, which have significantly impacted the pleasure industry.

FSC Issues Guidance on Kansas Age Verification Suits

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published an advisory article for adult websites operating in Kansas, following several private lawsuits filed under the state's age verification law.

Bree Mills on Directing 'Escape From Camp Conversion' for Adult Time's Girlcore Banner

Bree Mills was out running one day when the title of her next movie came to her: "Escape From Camp Conversion." The chief creative officer of Adult Time had been thinking about how to combine her love for queer cinema and lesbian pulp fiction with the distinct aesthetic of the 1980s.

Ricky's Room Signs Willow Ryder to 1-Year Deal

Ricky’s Room has signed Willow Ryder to a non-exclusive, multi-scene contract for one year.

Show More