File-sharing Lawsuits in 2016 Take Nosedive, Researchers Say

File-sharing Lawsuits in 2016 Take Nosedive, Researchers Say

SAN FRANCISCO — File-sharing litigation appears to have been a “short-lived trend,” according to Lex Machina, a legal research firm operated by Lexis-Nexis.

Lex Machina said that the number of copyright lawsuits in the U.S. over file-sharing have dropped significantly this year — by more than half.

“In the second quarter of 2016, the drop off in the number of new file-sharing cases sharply accelerated, decreasing more than 50 percent over the first quarter (517 cases to 249 cases in the second quarter),” the research firm said.

“This suggests that file-sharing litigation, which had represented the majority of copyright litigation from the fourth quarter in 2014 through the fourth quarter in 2015, may have been a short-lived trend.”

Lex Machina defines file-sharing lawsuits as cases having "John Doe” defendants and accusations based on file-sharing technology such as BitTorrent.

In the past six years, most of the file-sharing suits have been filed by adult copyright holders in typical fashion: They would file complaints against Does and used early discovery mechanisms to determine the identities of the persons it alleged illegally downloaded films.

One in particular — Malibu Media, which operates X-art.com — has filed more than 4,300 infringement lawsuits in federal courts against those who illegally downloaded its films.

But X-art.com’s infringement numbers suddenly stopped. Since April 1, the adult company hasn’t filed any suits against alleged infringers.

Instead, the adult company is currently embroiled in a legal standoff with its former general counsel Keith Lipscomb and his Florida law firm, Lipscomb, Eisenberg & Baker.

X-art.com’s partnership with Lipscomb began to unravel after his firm stopped distributing funds to X-art.com owners Brigham Field and Collette Pelissier Field. In April, Lipscomb said the copyright operation was "winding down" because it was no longer profitable.  

X-art recently filed suit against Lipscomb and his firm in Los Angeles, while Lipscomb has filed his own suit against the adult company at Florida state court.

Another mass copyright infringement filer was the Prenda Law firm, which would set up a number of shell companies that purchased copyrights to adult videos and then seek judicial approval for early discovery mechanisms.

The shell companies would then mail letters threatening to sue unless the individual paid about $4,000 to “settle” the case.

By misusing the subpoena power of the court, a federal appeals court recently said, Prenda Law made millions of dollars from suing thousands of Does across the country.

The Prenda Law firm, no longer in business, dissolved in spectacular fashion and was forced later to defend itself against several sanction awards, which were upheld on appeal.

Things didn’t get better for the three controlling Prenda Law principals. Paul Hansmeier agreed to suspend his law license in Minnesota and is going through bankruptcy proceedings, John Steele faces disciplinary charges in Illinois and Paul Duffy died from heart and alcohol-related conditions. 

Prenda Law's surviving former members continue to be the subject of a federal probe over their trolling operation.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Syren De Mer, Eddie Patrick Cap AEBN's Top Stars for 1st Quarter of 2026

AEBN has revealed its most popular performers in straight and gay theaters for the first quarter of 2026.

Tennessee Bill Would Require Warnings on Adult Stores

The Tennessee Senate has passed a bill requiring adult stores, theaters and other establishments in the state to post warning signs cautioning patrons that they “may be contributing” to sexual assault and human trafficking.

Report: Irish Regulator Seeks 'Industry Input' on AV Compliance

Irish media regulator Coimisiún na Meán (CnaM) will draw on “industry input” to help establish a framework for assessing platforms’ compliance with Ireland’s Online Safety Code and the EU’s Digital Services Act, news organization MLex reports.

'iDealgasmPlus' Launches Through PAYSITE

iDealgasmPlus.com has officially launched through PAYSITE.

Canadian Senate Approves National Age Verification Bill

Canada’s Senate on Wednesday passed bill S-209, the “Protecting Young Persons from Exposure to Pornography Act,” which would require commercial adult websites to verify that Canadian users are at least 18 years old.

Sara Jay Relaunches Site Through PAYSITE

Sara Jay has relaunched her membership site, WydeSyde, through PAYSITE.

European Commission: Age Verification App Ready For Use

The European Commission’s age verification app is now technically ready and will soon be available for EU citizens to use in order to prove their age when accessing online platforms, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen announced Tuesday.

UK House of Commons Moves to Tone Down Porn Amendments

The House of Commons has modified amendments to the U.K.’s pending Crime and Policing Bill, including provisions regulating “step” content, content featuring adults role-playing as minors, and performers’ ability to withdraw consent.

AEBN Reveals Ariel Demure as Top Trans Star for Q1 of 2026

AEBN has named its top trans stars for the first quarter of 2026, with Ariel Demure landing atop the leaderboard.

Final IRS 'No Tax on Tips' Rule Excludes Pornography

The Internal Revenue Service on Monday published final regulations on the “No Tax on Tips” provision included in the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” offering new tax deductions for tip workers but excluding revenue received for “pornographic activity.”

Show More