FSC Denied Injunction in Utah Child Protection Registry Case

SALT LAKE CITY — U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball has refused to issue a temporary injunction that would prohibit the Utah Child Protection Registry site from operating before his court can hear the case in full.

Utah’s registry allows parents and others to register email addresses to which minors have "access," and then prohibits emails from being sent from anywhere in the world to those addresses that advertise "harmful matter" or products or services minors cannot purchase.

Emailers can pay a private company, Unspam Registry Services Inc., to "scrub" their lists at a cost of a 1/2 cent for every name $5 per 1,000 addresses, according to the registry’s rules.

In a 33-page ruling, Kimball said the FSC failed to meet its burden of “clearly and unequivocally establishing each element for the issuance of a preliminary injunction.”

In part, Kimball found that the FSC’s 1st Amendment and Commerce Clause-based arguments did not have a substantial likelihood of success. Under the law, those seeking preliminary injunctive relief must demonstrate that they have a substantial likelihood of success based on the merits of their case.

Adult entertainment attorney Reed Lee told XBIZ rulings on preliminary injunctions don’t always mirror final rulings.

“The judge has to make a prediction based on what he thinks the final outcome will be, but he has to weigh that against the potential harm to the parties,” Lee said. “In this case, I think the judge has simply overlooked some of the points we made.”

FSC Executive Director Diane Duke said the group was weighing its options.

“FSC is not content to let the CPR decision stand,” Duke said. “We have a number of avenues to consider, up to and including a victory in court.”

Duke added that she believes a recent federal court decision declaring the Child Online Protection Act (COPA) unconstitutional helps to buttress the FSC’s case against the Utah Child Protection Registry.

According to Lee, the case now moves into the discovery phase where both sides will work to develop a record of facts. Lee said he believes there is a good chance both sides can agree on the facts, which means that the Judge will simply need to rule on the law.

In the meantime, Lee said adult companies concerned that they may send an email in violation of the Utah law would have to operate with that risk in mind without an injunction.

Although Kimball did deny the FSC’s request for an injunction, he did rule in favor of the trade group by denying the state’s motion to dismiss. Attorneys for Utah had unsuccessfully tried to persuade Kimball that the FSC lacked standing to challenge the law on behalf of the adult entertainment industry.

The case is Free Speech Coalition vs. Shurtleff, No. 2:05-cv-00949.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for September, October

AEBN has published the top search terms for September and October from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

BranditScan Launches Black Friday Creator Promo

BranditScan has launched its annual Black Friday promotion, offering creators a 69% discount for the first month to creators signing up for the DMCA leak protection and takedown anti-piracy subscription service.

Ofcom Proposes Requiring Adult Sites Hosting UGC to Use Hash Matching Tech

U.K. media regulator Ofcom on Monday asked Parliament to approve proposed new codes that would, among other changes, require adult platforms hosting user-generated content to implement hash matching technology in order to detect CSAM.

Flirt4Free Wins Trademark Infringement Case Against Copycat Website

The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has ruled in favor of Flirt4Free in a case against a copycat website using an infringing domain.

Irish PM Affirms Plan for UK-Style Ban on 'Extreme' Content

Ireland’s prime minister on Wednesday confirmed that his government is moving ahead with plans to introduce legislation criminalizing possession and distribution of “extreme” pornography, which he hopes to see passed by early 2027.

UK Parliamentary Group Calls for Outlawing Cam Platforms

The U.K. Parliament’s All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Commercial Sexual Exploitation has published a report in which it calls for banning adult livestreaming platforms.

Ofcom Escalates Sun Social, Superb Convert Investigations

U.K. media regulator Ofcom has ramped up its ongoing Online Safety Act (OSA) compliance investigations into PlayVids/PeekVids operator Sun Social Media and PimpBunny operator Superb Convert.

Centrobill Integrates Apple Pay, Google Pay

Centrobill has added Apple Pay and Google Pay options for merchants.

Judge Preliminarily Approves Pornhub Class Action Settlement

A U.S. District Court judge on Monday granted preliminary approval to a settlement between Aylo and the plaintiffs in two class-action lawsuits over allegations that former Pornhub parent company MindGeek knowingly allowed and profited from CSAM on its sites.

Show More