Home > News > Prenda Law’s Strategy at 9th Circuit Baffles Legal Peers • Bookmark   • Newsletters   • Register Search Options

NEWS STORY

Prenda Law’s Strategy at 9th Circuit Baffles Legal Peers

Prenda Law’s Strategy at 9th Circuit Baffles Legal Peers
Get XBIZ News
May 6, 2015 2:05 PM PDT    Text size: 

PASADENA, Calif. — After three appellate judges ripped into Prenda Law’s “operation” at a court hearing Monday, the notorious law firm’s counsel continued moving full steam ahead, claiming to the panel that its principals weren’t part of a “crooked extortion” scheme, as one judge described it.

Prenda Law, which disbanded shortly after U.S. District Judge Otis Wright accused it of operating a "porno-trolling collective" and handed out steep contempt sanctions in May 2013, now awaits a ruling that most legal experts say won’t favor the firm' former partners.

The “operation,” as Judge Harry Pregerson of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals put it on Monday, involved Prenda Law principals purchasing a number of adult film copyrights, seeding a bit torrent network with films and waiting for the infringing porn fans to take the bait.

Prenda Law attorneys John Steele, Paul Duffy and Paul Hansmeier later were able to convince a number of federal judges to subpoena the records of the ISPs and name infringers with their exact addresses.

Thousands of legal demand letters asked the unwitting targets to cough up $3,400 for the copyright infringement offenses, but lawsuits were nil to rare.

And, Pregerson noted, the letters kept on going out despite the subpoenas ordered quashed.

"They used our court system for illegal purposes to extort money; they used our discovery system,” said Pregerson, calling Prenda Law’s sole litigation work an “ingenious, crooked, extortionate operation.”

The scheme began to unravel when Prenda Law ended up in front of Wright, the federal judge, who found evidence of forgery involving the copyright signatory for the porn films. That signatory, Alan Cooper, was the caretaker of a rural cabin owned by Steele.

Wright asked Prenda Law attorneys to explain the firm’s method of operation in the copyright cases, and they all plead the fifth, which not only triggered $81,000 in civil sanctions but possible criminal sanctions, including incarceration.

On appeal, it didn’t go well for Prenda Law on Monday.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals — Judges Pregerson, Jacqueline Hong-Ngoc Nguyen and Richard Tallman — heard the firm’s appellate lawyer, Daniel Voelker of Chicago, attempt to focus on “prodecural flaws” in Wright’s courtroom.

But the panel stuck to their guns, as well as their deep-seated knowledge of the case, and demanded that Voelker address the accusations of misconduct Wright had focused on, including why the firm kept on sending out letters to fingered infringers after he had quashed subpoena orders.

The panel was particularly baffled that Prenda Law and its principals, through Voelker’s oral arguments, was seeking to have criminal contempt sanctions remanded to Wright's court for further procedural hearings, given that the maximum penalty for federal criminal contempt is life imprisonment.

"Is that they want, even if they're looking at a potential life in prison?" Tallman asked. 

"They want their day in court," Voelker said.

"This is going to be written about for years and years. … I don't know where this is going to end up,” Pregerson said. “If they really want to have a trial on this, with all protections of a criminal case — burden of proof, and a prosecutor, and all the rest of it — you sure they want that it?"

"They want their day in court," Voelker repeated.

Attorney Leonard J. French, an Allentown, Pa., litigator who’s been following the proceedings, said that two of the 9th Circuit judges referred to additional criminal investigation and “opening Pandora's Box if the case is remanded for further hearing.”

“The allegations that Prenda is a true copyright troll might be trumped by whatever is waiting inside that box,” French told XBIZ. “Prenda seemed to continue their 'full steam ahead' approach, with their attorney hammering the point that, when criminal sanctions are involved, additional due process must be followed, and that wasn't done here. 

“So, it appears the judges may remand for a full hearing on the issues not heard when Prenda took the fifth. Why in the world Prenda would think this is a good idea, I don't know.” 

Another attorney who has been following the case, Jeffery Lewis, an appellate law specialist with Rolling Hills Estates, Calif.-based Broedlow Lewis LLP, said the hearing, which was live streamed and available on YouTube, captured moments of amazement.

“Did you see when Prenda’s attorney argued there was no evidence of extortion in the appellate record? Judge Pregerson almost fell out of his chair,” Lewis said.

Lewis told XBIZ that he believes it’s likely that the “compensation” portion of the sanctions award, without any doubling, will be affirmed. 

Wright’s original sanction was at $81,000; however its bond in the proceedings, about $250,000, would go to defense attorney Morgan Pietz and a John Doe client named in a lawsuit that was dismissed by Prenda Law.

“The remainder of the award, doubled by Judge Wright, as a punitive sanction will likely be overturned,” Lewis said. “The panel left open the possibility that Prenda’s attorneys could face a criminal trial for contempt with the possibility of prison time. [It’s] theoretically possible, but not likely.”

The 9th Circuit panel on Monday did not indicate when they would decide the case.

A video of Monday's proceedings can be viewed here at 59:45.

More ways to get XBIZ News:  RSS Feeds  |  E-Newsletters  |  Desktop Widget  |  Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !

PROFILES & BIOS

Cam World: Jim Austin Puts Stripchat / xHamsterLive on the Cutting Edge

Meet Jim Austin, head of business development for Stripchat and xHamsterLive. Austin helps run the two free online communities where amateur models — women, men, couples and transgender folk —... More »

Crave’s Jack Morocco Brings Fresh Perspective to Channel Manager Role

Jack Morocco must be in the right career. They’ve been hit on by Nina Hartley and already had to fend off Ron Jeremy, all in their short one-and-a-half years with San Francisco boutique outfit Crave.... More »

Cam World: Cam Star of Month BlazeFyre Loves to Be a Pleaser

Webcam model BlazeFyre certainly is looking forward to a fruitful 2017. She just moved into new digs this past month, and is eagerly anticipating another banner year as a Chaturbate web model. The naturally... More »
XBIZ NEWSLETTERS
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.






POPULAR PRODUCTS & SERVICES
Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
Access the latest issues of the industry's leading trade publications in digital form. View online or download for offline viewing.

UPCOMING EVENTS

EXXXOTICA Denver

Mar 31 - Apr 02
Denver, CO.

Eurowebtainment 2017

May 17 - May 20
Majorca, Spain

XBIZ Retreat

May 30 - Jun 03
Miami, Florida

XBIZ Miami 2017

May 30 - Jun 02
Miami, Florida
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!