Scarlett Fay Gets 'Back in the Saddle' With Mainstream Role

LOS ANGELES — After three years of laying low, former XXX Lindsay Lohan impersonator Scarlett Fay has returned to the scene swinging — snagging a substantial mainstream role in a “noir” baseball film and resuming boy-girl shoots.

“I definitely think it's time to get back in the saddle,” Fay told XBIZ, reminiscing about the excitement of high-budget features and parodies, like "Hustler’s Untrue Hollywood Stories: Lindsay Lohan” and “Lindsay Goes to Jail,” which shunted her into the mainstream gossip whirlwind of TMZ and E!

Fay’s revamped saddle is varied and extends beyond the sexual: she has signed on to play a supporting role in the partially Kickstarter-funded film “High and Outside: a Baseball Noir” starring Geoffrey Lewis, Eddie Jemison, David Yow and Phil Donlon.

“High and Outside” follows Phil’s (Donlon) fraught quest to become a professional baseball player and “the desperate measures” he takes to achieve the dream. Fay plays Angie, a stripper who she says “doesn't exactly have it all together” and influences Phil for the worse.  

Fay said, “I was just happy to be a part of this movie, but the best part is knowing that I won't be the porn star in the background playing a stripper. I have plenty of dialogue and I really am a big part of the movie. [Director Evald Johnson] actually put a scene together for me and Geoffrey Lewis. I was incredibly nervous — Geoffrey is a Hollywood legend.”

The film, based on Johnson’s actual experience as the son of Major Leaguer Tim Johnson, raised $47,386 on Kickstarter (it’s goal was $45,000). The remainder of the budget was supplied by the filmmakers.   

But Fay maintains that she “loves this industry” and isn’t about to leave it for Hollywood: Fans of the other kind of saddle-riding can see Fay in Hustler’s upcoming “This Ain’t Game of Thrones XXX,” for which she recently shot her first post boy-girl-hiatus scene with Ryan Driller who she said was “an absolute doll to work with.” The erotic parody is slated to release in early 2014.

Outside of acting, erotic and otherwise, Fay said she is in talks with publishers about potentially publishing a comedic book about her experiences working as a stripper.

In addition to her notorious Li-Loh performances, Fay has had a rich adult career, and has appeared on PlayboyTV’s "BadAss" seasons 1 and 2, co- hosted for Playboy’s "Beach House" and has starred in films for companies such as Wicked, Vivid and Hustler.    

Fay is currently a free agent and has been booking her own projects for the last three years. For bookings and other inquiries, contact her directly at ScarlettFayBookings@gmail.com.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Jim Powers on Shooting Fast, Staying Weird and Never Phoning It In

The Santa Ana winds are blowing as we drive through the gate of Tommy’s Funhouse, the legendary mountaintop porn house in Newbury Park, California. Inside, we find director Jim Powers in the middle of a typical shoot day.

Eris Jolie Leads Latest From TransAngels

Eris Jolie stars with Yhivi and Kimmy Kimm in the latest release from TransAngels, titled "Bend It Like a Baddie."

Brittany Andrews, Little Puck Front Latest From Swappz

Brittany Andrews and Little Puck star in the latest release from Swappz.

Andi Avalon, Lexi Lore Front Latest From Pervz

Andi Avalon and Lexi Lore star with Mike Mancini in the latest release from Pervz’s “PervTherapy” series.

Christy Love Stars in New Release From Evil Angel

Christy Love stars with director Richard Mann in a new release from Evil Angel.

Lulu Chu, Thea Summers Headline Latest 'Lesbian Sex'

Lulu Chu and Thea Summers topline the 29th volume of "Lesbian Sex" from Girlfriends Films.

Penny Barber, Haley Spades Star in Latest From Brazzers

2025 XMAs MILF Performer of the Year Penny Barber stars with Haley Spades in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "Slutty Cheerleader Caught Mid-Plot."

Dan Dangler Is Hustler's 'Cover Honey' for March

Dan Dangler is the Cover Honey for the March issue of Hustler Magazine and appears in a 14-page centerfold spread shot by ThisYearsModel.com.

Shalina Devine Leads Dorcel's 'Open Space'

Shalina Devine headlines the latest release from Dorcel, titled “Open Space.”

Show More