Home > News > U.S. Judge Tosses 'My Little Panties 2' BitTorrent Suit • Bookmark   • Newsletters   • Register Search Options

NEWS STORY

U.S. Judge Tosses 'My Little Panties 2' BitTorrent Suit

U.S. Judge Tosses 'My Little Panties 2' BitTorrent Suit
Get XBIZ News
May 19, 2012 12:00 PM PDT    Text size: 

NEW YORK — Another mass porn BitTorrent piracy suit has bitten the dust.

U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon of New York this week dismissed all but one of 245 John Does suspected of trading Digital Sin's "My Little Panties 2" because she ruled the suit's joinder was improper and geolocation techniques used in identifying the Does named in the suit were faulty.

McMahon's ruling was notable because she additionally laid forth rules of conduct for further litigation by Digital Sin and its counsel, Mike Meier, in connection with litigating further against the Does over "My Little Panties 2."

McMahon in her decision said that she didn't need to write another lengthy opinion discussing why plaintiff's theory is wrong. Rather, she said she incorporated reasoning by a number of judges in Northern California and New York who have rejected other mass BitTorrent joinder cases.

"Nothing in the complaint negates the inference that the downloads by the various defendants were discrete and separate acts that took place at different times; indeed the complaint alleges that separate defendants shared access to a file containing a pornographic film in separate and isolated incidents over  the course of 59 days," she wrote.

"In other words what we have here is 245 separate and discrete transactions in which 245 individuals used the same method to access a file via the Internet — no concerted action whatsoever, and no series of related occurrences — at least not related in any way except the method that was allegedly used to violate the law."  

McMahon said that it had been no accident that Digital Sin and Meier had not sought to bring the suit to class action status (because the rules for certification could not be met, she said) and that the only economy that litigating these cases as a single action would achieve is an economy to plaintiff  — "the economy of not having pay separate filing fee for each action."

Personal jurisdiction was another problem for McMahon in the Digital Sin suit because IP locator reports on the alleged copyright violations were never offered to the court. She called the oversight "troubling" because plaintiffs counsel averred that he only "personally conducted a random batch test of the purported locations of the IP addresses" of the Does.

As a result of joinder and geolocation issues, McMahon dismissed the case, with the exception of Doe No. 1, "because plaintiff has not paid the filing fee that is statutorily required to bring these 244 separate lawsuits."

The federal judge noted in her order that "litigation abuse has been a hallmark" over purported downloading of "My Little Panties 2." She said that there are currently three separate "My Little Panties 2" swarm cases pending before three different judges.

McMahon cautioned Meier about judge shopping and imposed "going forward" rules if he refiled against any of the severed defendants.

"Lest plaintiffs counsel think he can simply put cases against the severed and dismissed John Doe defendants into the wheel for assignment to yet another judge, I remind him of Local Civil Rule 1.6(a) [which requires the plaintiff attorney to bring the existence of potentially related cases to the attention of the court].”

One day after the McMahon's order severing 244 Does, Meier filed papers to sever Doe No. 1.

Meier said in his dismissal notice that that Doe No. 1 used a mobile device as he was traveling through New York and is outside jurisdiction of the court.

More ways to get XBIZ News:  RSS Feeds  |  E-Newsletters  |  Desktop Widget  |  Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !

LEGAL PERSPECTIVES

Dissecting an $11.9M Affiliate Marketing Judgment

The Federal Trade Commission scored another major win in early October when the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court ruling, requiring LeadClick Media LLC to pay an $11.9 million award. The... More »

Legal Protection for Amateur Shoots

Any adult industry professional who creates video content with actual first-time amateurs will come to an early knowledge that later performer regret is commonplace. Recognized performers who regularly... More »

Legal Options to Address Pirated Cam Performances

Many webcam performers have experienced a new trend in online piracy — the illegal recording and publication of live webcam performances. The “business model” is disturbingly simple:... More »
XBIZ NEWSLETTERS
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.






POPULAR PRODUCTS & SERVICES
Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
Subscribe to XBIZ World magazine, the industry's leading e-commerce trade publication, delivering in-depth coverage of the online, mobile and ancillary digital markets.

UPCOMING EVENTS

XBIZ 2017

Jan 09 - Jan 13
Hollywood, CA

XBIZ Awards 2017

Jan 12 - Jan 12
Los Angeles, CA

ANME Founders Show

Jan 14 - Jan 15
Los Angeles Marriott Burbank Airport

Everything To Do With Sex Show

Jan 20 - Jan 22
Montréal, Québec
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!