Stagliano Attorney: Challenge Everything

LOS ANGELES — U.S District Judge Richard Leon filed a memorandum opinion last week, explaining in further detail the reasoning behind his rulings in the John Stagliano obscenity trial.

The 11-page brief summarized the various motions and arguments made by the defendants and plaintiffs. In his conclusion, Leon stated “the defendants took a particularly aggressive position regarding the procedural approach of the trial of this case,” a statement defense attorney Allan Gelbard takes as a compliment.

Gelbard told XBIZ that in an obscenity trial, the key is to challenge everything.

“Challenge everything you can. You never know when a small issue can turn into a larger issue later,” he said.

Though the team’s aggressiveness helped Stagliano secure a win, Gelbard says he disagreed with most of Leon’s rulings, especially when he disallowed the testimony of defense expert witnesses, Prof. Constance Penley and Dr. Lawrence Sank.

In June, Leon held a Daubert hearing to elicit testimony from the prospective expert witnesses about their qualifications, principles and methodologies. He found that the reasoning of the witnesses were not sufficiently reliable to qualify them as experts in this case.

Leon said that Sank’s testimony “did not convince me; however, that he had any greater insight into the community standards of the district relating to a particular work’s prurient appeal or offensiveness than the average juror would have had.

“If anything, his opinion would have been distorted and potentially misleading to the jury because it would have been based entirely on his interaction with people who come to him for treatment thinking that they have a psychological problem or a particular sexual problem and are willing to speak openly about it.”

The judge said that to be reliable an opinion on scientific merit must be grounded in scientific knowledge.

Speaking of Penley, who teaches film studies at UC Santa Barbara, Leon said, “because Penley was not particularly clear on whether art is just a subjective matter of taste or whether there is in fact a meaningful line separating serious art from lesser art, I did not find her putative approach to evaluating the serious artistic value of a work, which is subjective and notably lacking in detail, to be a particularly reliable or helpful guide for the jury.”

Gelbard disagreed saying that the two expert witnesses were qualified to give expert testimony.

In fact, Gelbard said most of Leon’s rulings made it difficult to mount a proper defense.

“I think what he was doing was trying to prevent people from being able to defend adequately,” he said.

The final piece of advice he offers for anyone involved in an obscenity case, “make sure you have a lawyer who knows how to handle these cases.”

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

XBIZ 2027 Host Hotel Sold Out, Nearby Room Block Added

As preparations continue for XBIZ 2027, the event's official host hotel, JW Marriott L.A. LIVE, has now completely sold out.

Little Puck Talks Twisted Fantasies and New Creative Frontiers

“I'm the girl who gives you weird boners.” Ask Little Puck how she would describe herself in one sentence to someone unfamiliar with her work, and she doesn’t disappoint. It's a characterization that doubles as a mission statement for one of the industry's most acclaimed cosplay creators.

Jessi Rae Makes Her Tushy Debut

Jessi Rae has made her debut for Vixen Media Group studio imprint Tushy alongside Alberto Blanco.

Aylo Defeats Indiana Lawsuit Over VPN Use to Bypass Age Verification

A Marion Superior Court judge on Wednesday dismissed Indiana’s lawsuit alleging that Aylo violated the state’s age verification law by failing to prevent access by users who employ VPNs and similar means to avoid geolocation.

'Swing Nation' Hosts Lacy and Dan Star With Serenity Cox in WIFEY Return

Lacy and Dan, hosts of the "Swing Nation" lifestyle podcast, star alongside Serenity Cox and Anton Harden in their return to Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

Lauren Phillips, Cali Sweets Front New 'Buttman' Release

Lauren Phillips and Cali Sweets star with director Glenn King in the latest release featuring Evil Angel studio honcho John Stagliano's iconic Buttman character.The scene opens with Buttman concerned about King's recent unreliability, as he's been missing deadlines for submitting videos.

Amy Nosferatu Leads Latest From TGirls.xxx

Amy Nosferatu stars with Jason Leescott in a release from Grooby paysite TGirls.xxx, titled "The Tattoo Parlour."

Reptyle to Debut Cross-Site Cosplay Series 'Live Action Hentai'

Reptyle is premiering the new limited cosplay series "Live Action Hentai" on studio imprints Family Strokes, TeamSkeet, Freeuse, and Pervz.

Cheerleader Kait, Isa Bella Topline Latest Volume of 'Sorority Girls' From Sweetheart Video

Cheerleader Kait and Isa Bella headline the fourth volume of "Sorority Girls," from Mile High Media studio imprint Sweetheart Video.

Show More