N.Y. Court Gives a Merry X-mas to Adult Businesses

ALBANY, N.Y. — Adult entertainment companies have been given another chance to fight a New York City law that keeps them out of most neighborhoods.

Thursday’s New York Court of Appeals decision effectively blocks the city’s bid to close or move more than 100 strip clubs, adult movie theaters and video stores.

Several venues that include adult cabarets and retailers that sell adult material sued the city over a 2001 amendment to a 1995 zoning law that banned all adult entertainment activity from neighborhoods outside certain industrial areas. Plaintiffs claimed their free speech rights were violated.

The businesses operated under the “60/40” rule, which provided that a business could not be called an adult establishment if less than 40 percent of its floor space or inventory was devoted to adult content.

But the Court of Appeals ruled, 4-3, to send the case back to a lower court, deciding that the city needs to show that the so-called “60/40” businesses still display a “predominant, ongoing focus on sexually explicit materials or activities" to justify strengthening the 1995 ordinance.

If not, Judge Susan Phillips Read said, “plaintiffs will prevail” at trial.

In 2001, Mayor Rudolph Giuliani proposed an amendment to the law to curb what he saw as a loophole allowing sex shops to continue operating in zones where they should have been excluded. The shops did this, the Giuliani administration argued, by rearranging their floor space and stocking a token amount of nonpornographic items to avoid being tagged as a sex store.

In the case, New York City argued that an amendment to a 1995 law simply closed a loophole and did not create a new law.

New York officials also contended that the amendment would help mitigate secondary effects they claimed the businesses had on their neighborhoods, such as lower property values, increased amounts of trash and higher crime rates.

The businesses sued and won their case in Supreme Court. That ruling was later overturned by an appellate court.

Attorney Martin Mehler, representing the Pussycat Lounge — a rock club that also includes an adjacent adult cabaret — said the decision bodes well for his client and the other plaintiffs.

"Since the law went into effect, we've adhered to the mandates of the city," he said. "There is no more crime near our place, no trash, no lowering of property values. Nothing has happened to mandate the city's actions. They have to come up with more than they have come up with" to justify the 2001 amendment.”

The consolidated case is Peoples Theatres of N.Y. vs. City of New York and Ten’s Cabaret vs. City of New York, No. 181.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

'Groove Thing' Sets Kickstarter Funding Record for Insertable Pleasure Product

Groove Thing, an insertable pleasure product that plays audio, has set a funding record on Kickstarter.

Nalpac/Entrenue, Ohdoki Sign Distro Deal for 'The Handy'

Nalpac/Entrenue has inked an exclusive U.S. distribution deal with Ohdoki Products for The Handy.

Onahole Debuts New 'Miss Boss Cup' Stroker

Pleasure brand Onahole has introduced its new Miss Boss Cup stroker.

ProDx Health Introduces 'Trust 1' HPV Test

ProDx Health has introduced its new Trust 1 Home Collection Kit for HPV testing.

Eye of Love Debuts 'Pheromone Roll-On Duo' From Bloom Line

Eye of Love has introduced the Pheromone Roll-On Duo fragrance set from its Bloom collection.

Full Circle Releases 'Grinders' Collection

Pleasure brand Full Circle has debuted its new Grinders collection of discreet vibrators.

Doc Johnson, Polynesian Pleasures Ink Distro Deal

Pleasure brand Polynesian Pleasures has signed a deal with Doc Johnson for global distribution.

Sydney Screams, Creature Feature Toys & Tailends Studios Launch Limited Partnership

Sydney Screams, Creature Feature Toys, and Tailends Studios have launched a one-month campaign to produce customizable dildos, with some proceeds benefiting SWAID Collective.

Federal Appeals Court Vacates FTC 'Click to Cancel' Rule Pending Review

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit on Tuesday vacated the Federal Trade Commission’s “click-to-cancel” rule aimed at making it easier for consumers to cancel online subscriptions, pending further review.

Sexpo Australia Founder Launches SexEx

Sexpo Australia founder David Ross has launched his new adult lifestyle expo, SexEx.

Show More