Ariz. Supreme Court Reverses Decision in Adult Bookstore Case

PHOENIX — The Arizona Supreme Court has overturned the dismissal of charges against two adult bookstore owners who were prosecuted for violating a state law that restricts their business hours.

In its opinion in State of Arizona vs. Stummer and Lumm, written by Vice Chief Justice Rebecca White Berch, the high court also published a multi-pronged test that it came up with to allow lower courts to determine whether the state law violates the First Amendment guarantee to free speech.

Hubert August Stummer and Dennis Allen Lumm were originally charged for violating an Arizona law that “forbids adult bookstores from remaining open during certain early morning hours,” according to documents. Under that law, Arizona Revised Statutes 13-1422 (A), adult bookstores are required to be closed for business from 1 a.m. to 8 a.m. Monday through Saturday, and from 1 p.m. to noon on Sunday.

Stummer and Lumm were convicted in Maricopa County Superior Court. They appealed in 2007 and won on argument that another court found the Arizona law unconstitutional.

Writing in her appeal, Justice Berch said the high court justices considered whether adult businesses caused “increased prostitution and sexually oriented litter in the surrounding communities.”

To help decide the case, the Supreme Court set up a three-pronged test that to guide the trial court. To decide whether the hour restrictions are constitutional under Arizona law, the lower court should consider “evidence of the significance of the infringement of speech, the effectiveness of the statute in reducing negative secondary effects, the nexus between the ends sought and the means employed, or the availability of alternative measures,” Berch wrote.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

CORRECTION: Pornhub to Remain Live in Ohio, Despite AV Law

Pornhub parent company Aylo will not block access to its websites in Ohio, despite new state age verification rules that came into effect Sept. 30.

Orion Unveils 6 New Styles From 'Abierta Fina' Line

Orion Wholesale has introduced six new styles from its Abierta Fina collection.

Full Circle Debuts Wand Vibe Collection

Full Circle has introduced six new vibrating wands.

Blush Introduces 'Daydream' Dildo From Avant Line

Blush has debuted the Daydream dildo from its Avant Collection.

Oh Collective Debuts 'Date Night Bonbons' Gift Set

Oh Collective has introduced its new Date Night Bonbons gift set.

Honey Play Box Launches AI Companion

Honey Play Box has launched its AI Companion.

Liberator Names Genevieve Lariviere Global Sales Director

Liberator has appointed Genevieve Lariviere as its new global sales director.

Judge Dismisses Some Claims in 'Children of Pornhub' Trafficking Suit

A United States district judge on Friday dismissed some but not all claims against Aylo in a long-running case involving CSAM allegations featured in the influential 2020 New York Times article “The Children of Pornhub.”

Pjur, Dreamlove Launch 30th Anniversary Campaign

Pjur and Dreamlove have launched a POS campaign to mark the lubricant brand’s 30th anniversary.

Pornhub Shuts Down Access in Ohio Over Age Verification

Aylo began geoblocking Pornhub across the state of Ohio on Tuesday, as the state’s age verification law goes into effect.

Show More