NEWS STORY
Recent Convictions Challenge Miller Test Definitions

45.22% |
45.22% |
9.57% |
The Paul Little (Max Hardcore) and Karen Fletcher (RedRose.com) convictions, well known within the adult industry, have also caught the attention of mainstream media. An article posted on PC World addresses the complexity of the issue and its influence on webmasters and viewers.
Max Hardcore's recent 46-month jail term and fine, as well as Karen Fletcher's probation were achieved by the DOJ by using a traditional interpretation of the 1973 Miller v. California precedent. That ruling, which states that obscenity charges must pass a three-point test, has made previous, successful obscenity convictions difficult for the courts.
One point of that test requires that the material in question must be "the average person, applying contemporary community standards would find that the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest."
The definition of "community" in that point is now under question when the creator of material and the consumer of the product are linked only by electronic means.
Community standards would, by definition, include anyone who would have access to the questionable material. In reality, the Internet community would be defined as global.
"With a website, you can't block traffic from another location," said Jeffrey Douglas, Little's defense lawyer.
Douglas is filing an appeal of both the conviction and sentence in the Hardcore case next week.
"This appeal will be of central importance to every adult website in the world," he said.
Hardcore's sentence has troubled many in the adult industry. The implications of Karen Fletcher's conviction, however, have been cited as having the potential to be far more chilling. Her erotic writing, posted at RedRose.com has led the 56-year old to five years of probation, including six months of being stripped of her computer. Her violation of the obscenity law was stated as "using an interactive computer service to distribute obscene materials." Although there were no pictures, the text was deemed to depict sexual molestation and violence that included children.
As previously reported in XBIZ, prosecution of literary obscenity has proven to be much more difficult than explicit images. The defense of allegedly obscene literary content, however, is often more successful when considering another Miller Test requirements: that "the work, taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value."
Writing has a — or attempts to create — linear, concise thought. Eric Goldman, director of the High Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University School of Law told PC World "it's almost impossible for text to be judged obscene."
"The idea of a contemporary community standard of obscenity is an unfounded fantasy by the judges," Douglas told XBIZ. "Either we establish an Internet community standard, or we start over from scratch and sit down and try to define obscenity properly."
See all current articles in > adult industry news
Related Articles
RSS Feeds | E-Newsletters | Desktop Widget | Mobile
XBIZ Newswire > Adult industry news service for the media
XBIZ Premiere > Adult industry magazine for the retail market
WEB / TECH NEWS
John Stagliano Reveals New Vampire Web Series
Moniker, SnapNames Sold to KeyDrive
VideoSecrets Signs On as 1st Sponsor of Miss FreeOnes 2012
Kink.com Offering ‘V-Day Heart-On’ Armory Tours
Flirt4Free Celebrates Valentines Day With Holiday Promo
EroAdvertising to Launch Invideo Player Ads Module
VIDEO NEWS
ALTA Trade Group, Ideal Image Management Clash Over Licensing
CineKink Film Festival to Screen Brittany Andrews Documentary
West Coast Unveils 'Black Romance Color of Love'
Ron Jeremy Spied Shooting Horror Film
Tommy Gunn Launches Signature Line of Underwear
Video: Jenna Haze Retires From Performing
NOVELTY NEWS
Nasstoys Now Distributed by Pink Cherry
HPPPA Launches Toy Line, Taps ECN for Exclusive Distribution
Entrenue Brings Lovehoney’s Rock Box to U.S. Market
JOPEN Announces Intensity Insider Winner
Practice Safe Policy Launches Romney Condoms
French Court to Decide Whether Sex Toys Are Porn
RETAIL NEWS
Alabama’s Pleasures Store Hosting 2nd Annual Guns for Toys Event
Playboy Kicks Off Super Bowl With 'Carnival Mystique'
The Tranny Awards Moves to Hollywood, Calif.
Jimmy Flynt Opens New Store in Kentucky
Hustler Hollywood Store, Website Undergo Transformation
Italian Porn Stars Face Off in Mayoral Race
BUSINESS ANALYSIS
Traffic: Taking a Look at the Stats
Getting By in a ‘Gimme Free’ World
Search for Quality Traffic
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
add free content to your website.
with your mobile device.
|
There Goes The Neighborhood
GonZo
|
|
Producers, What would you want to see in a clip site?
Varian Gray
|
|
|
New @ Xbiz
VinnyWTS
|
|
New Affiliate Rep and New at Xbiz
Nawid Company
|
|
|
Newbie here on XBIZ
VinnyWTS
|
|
Barcelona, we re coming! Barcelona summit roll-call
SafeCharge EddieK
|
|
|
are xxx already domains being used?
Kelli Roberts
|
|
|
Highest Paid Pornstars
Vendzilla
|
|
Post your twitter account here
NaughtyRob
|
|
Who else is looking forward to the Phoenix Forum?
TeamSkeet
|
FIND PRODUCTS & SERVICES

UPCOMING EVENTS





All News / Editorial
































