opinion

Republicans Save US Jobs

Since George W. Bush was elected, hundreds of thousands of American jobs have flowed overseas – where labor costs are lower. On Tuesday, May 24, 2005, the federal government took a stand to help stop cheap foreign labor from competing on an uneven playing field with our local workers. What industry was protected? Automobile factory workers? No. Textile workers? No. Software developers? Wrong again. So who was it? Adult industry actors and actresses are the beneficiary of this governmental largesse.

Yes, that's right. The party of "moral values" and its Attorney General who stated that prosecuting obscenity was his number one priority has issued a new regulation that makes it very difficult (if not impossible) for US-based producers of erotic content to use foreign talent. While hundreds of thousands of Americans are losing their jobs to outsourcing to the Third World, erotic talent is receiving a protectionist gift from the federal government.

The new regulations define "Picture Identification Card."  But they do not define "identification document."

In light of the new regulations implementing 18 USC § 2257, there is a lot of confusion in the industry as to what identification requirements are truly required, and how they will affect producers who wish to use foreign talent. Upon first blush, the regulations appeared to be quite onerous for these producers. Upon additional examination, they appear to be even worse for stateside producers.

One opinion circulating is that the new regulations require either a foreign passport or a specified "picture identification card." While this may be one possible interpretation, it appears that the true requirement is that both are necessary.

If the "either/or" theory were correct, it would lead to a far more reasonable result.  The alternative theory leads to a very unreasonable result.  Accordingly, the author recognizes that the entire industry would much prefer the "either/or" theory to be correct.  Nevertheless, what we want to be true and what is true are often unconnected.

The "either/or" position is based upon the fact that "identification document" referenced in the new regulations is different than "Picture Identification Card" and that the regulations provide that either one or the other is required.  It is true that the two terms are different and mandate the use of two different kinds of documentation.  However, it is an incorrect conclusion that only one or the other is required.

The "either/or" theory is based on the second sentence in §75.2(a)(1). However, that theory only passes muster if the first sentence in that section is ignored.

The first sentence in §75.2(a)(1) of the new regulations states that any producer of sexually explicit content must create and maintain records containing "[t]he legal name and date of birth of each performer, obtained by the producer's examination of a picture identification card." (emphasis added).  Therefore, according to this sentence, a "picture identification card" is strictly required.  Parenthetically, this sentence is new, and was not contained in the proposed version of the regulations published in June, 2004.

The second sentence in §75.2(1) (and the sentence upon which the "either/or" theory relies) states: "For any performer portrayed in such a depiction made after July 3, 1995, the records shall also include a legible copy of the identification document examined and, if that document does not contain a recent and recognizable picture of the performer, a legible copy of a picture identification card." (emphasis added).

To further illustrate the issue and to demonstrate the confusing language in the new regulations, we should turn our attention to the definitions of these two terms.  The new regulations define "Picture Identification Card."  But they do not define "identification document." (that term is defined in the statute).

Picture Identification Card is defined by naming a laundry list of U.S. Identification documents such as a passport or a green card, or a driver's license issued by any state. See §75.1(b).  However, this section allows for foreign equivalents as long as the talent and the producer are both located outside the United States. 

This leaves us searching for a definition of "identification document." Fortunately, we can find this definition in 18 U.S.C. § 1028(d), the identification fraud statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1028.  Unfortunately, while 18 U.S.C. § 1028(d), defines "identification document," it also limits its definition to "this section and section 1028A."

Therefore, it would appear the definition of "identification document" that is contained in the Identification Fraud statute at 18 U.S.C. § 1028(d) is limited to that section and its companion section (1028A).  However, §2257(h)(2) contains the following: "'identification document' has the meaning given that term in section 1028(d) of this title."

This is certainly somewhat confusing, as we can travel in circles by looking at 1028, which says that its definition only applies to itself, but then look at 2257, which says that it is importing this definition, which (by definition) is limited to only Section 1028.  Ultimately, the balance of the analysis is likely to tip in favor of the 1028 definition being properly imported into 2257.  Accordingly, we have our definitions of Picture Identification Card and Identification Document – although there is a weak argument against the importation of the 1028 definition into 2257.

The comments to the new regulations further illustrate why there is so much confusion on this point currently in the industry.

At Page 29616 of the Federal Register, in the comments discussing the new 2257 regulations, 18 USC § 1028 is discussed explicitly.

"One commenter commented regarding a minor drafting error in which s75.2(a)(1) of the proposed rule incorrectly referenced the definition of an identification document in 18 USC 1028.  The department has eliminated entirely the reference to 18 USC 1028, which is redundant in light of the final rule's defined term picture identification card."

If we examine the proposed regulations and the final regulations, it appears that the intent was to delete any reference to 18 U.S.C. § 1028(d).  It also appears that the regulations might have intended to do away with the 1028 definition.  This is unclear, and ultimately the regulations cannot change the fact that 2257 mandates the use of that definition. The regulations cannot subtract from the statute, although they may add to it, so long as the Department does not exceed its authority given by Congress.  Given the comments, it appears that the Justice Department may have been improperly attempting to merge the terms Picture Identification Card and Identification Document. Nevertheless, this is far from certain, and may not be clarified until the courts address the issue.

As mentioned above, the result that the industry would like to see is more logical than what the regulations seem to create. Accordingly, a court may eventually agree with the interpretation developed in this article and dispense with it under the "absurd result doctrine."

Allowing the use of foreign-issued ID only when the producer and talent are outside the United States is certainly unwise, as it will cause great difficulty for the industry, drive much money out of the economy, and ultimately mean that the new regulations will serve as the only steps that the Bush administration has ever taken to stop American jobs from being lost to cheaper foreign workers. Nevertheless, a bad result from bad law does not trip the wire to activate the absurd result doctrine – and the threshold for the employment of this doctrine is quite high.

In conclusion it appears that a picture identification card, as defined in the regulations, is strictly required to be examined by the producer, and this definition does create difficulty for American producers using foreign talent (whether on US soil or abroad).  Although there are alternative theories to interpret the rest of the regulations, the more conservative position is that a legible copy of the identification document (as defined in section 1028) must be kept, but if it does not contain a recent and recognizable picture, then a legible copy of the picture identification card must also be kept with the required records.

Marc J. Randazza, Esq. is a Las Vegas based First Amendment attorney. Nothing contained in this article constitutes legal advice. Please consult your personal attorney for information on specific legal issues. Mr. Randazza can be reached at www.randazza.com.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Automation Eliminates the Month-End Chase for Retail Reports

On Jan. 3, 2021, I walked into our flagship store in Pleasant Hill to replace the point-of-sale system, the software stores use to ring up sales, track inventory and manage day-to-day transactions. It was my first job at Secrets. The plan was two weeks per store: install the system, enter the inventory, write the training manual, train the manager and staff, then drive to the next one.

Zondre Watson ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Help Merchants Avoid Onboarding Delays

Adding a new acquiring partner, whether directly through a bank or through a payment facilitator, can mean an onboarding process that takes up to two months.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Why Better Sizing Can Help Pleasure Brands Reach More Customers

In the sexual health industry, we must be ready to problem-solve around every corner, especially in retail. You never know who will walk through your doors or what they might need or want that day, not to mention curveballs such as disabilities, neurodivergence, trauma responses, and, of course, body image sensitivities.

Mersy Love ·
opinion

How Layered Fraud Controls Can Stop Card Testing Before Chargebacks Hit

You suddenly have 400 new $1 trial signups. Sales are up, the approval rate looks great and, at first glance, the numbers seem worth celebrating.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA: Barnaby's Amy Carnegie Draws on Retail Roots to Shape Product Development

In 2012, Amy Carnegie was pursuing a master’s degree in forensic psychology and looking for a part-time job close to home when she discovered Good Vibrations’ newly opened Oakland location. The store was on the same bus route she took to school, making it a convenient option. She didn't anticipate the position would lead to a nearly 15-year career, during which she would rise through the ranks to become head of buying and product development for Good Vibrations, Babeland and Camouflage.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
opinion

Falcon/NakedSword Makes Every Body Count in 'Deeper by the Dozen'

Double trouble is on the menu in NakedSword’s “Deeper by the Dozen,” an all-sex buffet where personal space is scarce and temptation is plentiful. Trading scripted drama for a fresh batch of bare buns, the studio serves up two gangbangs with exclusive Jaxx Cody and “Trailer Trash Boys” regular Ian Sterling as the main course.

Christian Cintron ·
opinion

What Retailers Should Know About Pheromones and Attraction

A woman stands at your counter. She dabs a drop of something clear and nearly odorless on her wrist, brings it to her nose and something in her posture changes before she even leaves the store. A few feet away, a man turns a small bottle over in his hand, reading the label twice and wondering whether it might help him feel noticed again by a longtime partner.

Susan Bratton ·
opinion

How Retailers Can Turn AI-Assisted Reporting Into a Scheduled Workflow

If you have been following this series, you know I have been climbing a ladder. First, I asked an AI model to do a task. Then I got tired of explaining the task every time, so I wrote a skill, a reusable set of instructions, and put it in a project folder with everything the task needed.

Zondre Watson ·
opinion

Retailer Tips for Making Trade Show Travel Pay Off

When sales slow, retailers understandably start looking for ways to tighten the budget. Every expense gets another look, and travel and trade show attendance can quickly end up on the list of things to cut.

Rin Musick ·
profile

BranditScan's Aerie Saunders on Fostering Creator Knowledge, Confidence and Community

Aerie Saunders is firmly in her season. When she sits down with XBIZ, a fall-scented WoodWick candle burns in the background, pumpkins decorate her desk and the first signs of spooky season are already on display. Not that Saunders waits until autumn to embrace the macabre.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More