opinion

An Industry On The Brink

It seems like only yesterday since I returned from the Phoenix Forum — that annual gathering where many of the online adult industry's best and brightest meet to discuss the state of the industry and the issues that affect it. While I was there, I got a chance to talk to many wonderful people and even made some new friends.

I also took the pulse of the event's attendees and paid special attention to the overall feel and tone of those who I observed and interacted with. As such, I have come to the conclusion that most people have finally gotten the message that this is a serious business where you have to do the right thing.

While it's encouraging to see and hear adult business owners taking on a greater sense of personal responsibility for their actions, it is quite frightening that there is still so much resistance among certain individuals when the subject of "doing the right thing" comes up.

As an example, I witnessed an exchange between an owner of a thumbnail gallery post (TGP) and one of the top attorneys in the adult entertainment business.

This experienced lawyer seemed of the opinion that an American webmaster would have to be insane to be running a traditional, free, hardcore, thumbs-based TGP site, given our current political climate. Of course, the TGP owner disagreed — a stance that could cost him dearly – particularly in light of the as yet to be defined, but nonetheless enacted – changes to the 2257 federal record keeping requirements.

Perhaps the biggest story of the year and one which may redefine the perception and scope of activities typically considered to be "content production" – the new 2257 requirements may pigeonhole webmasters as "producers." While we in the business consider producers to be "the guys with the cameras," the fact that we "produce webpages that feature adult content" could put us in the same category, at least as far as record keeping requirements go.

Sadly, the vast majority of us are not in compliance with this law and for many, there is no easy – or possible – way to comply.

It's not too late, however, but time is short,; with as little as 30 days before the law goes into effect. Adult businesses need to get their houses in order and become fully compliant with not only the letter, but the spirit of the law – rather than hoping that court action and the efforts of groups such as the Free Speech Coalition will somehow save the day.

Accepting responsibility for the content you distribute — whether in print, online, on video or beyond is the right thing to do and it is part of what attorney Greg Piccionelli describes as becoming "a hardened target," which is less attractive for prosecutors looking for easy pickings.

Beyond legal responsibilities, we as an industry also face human ones. It's been about a year now since the last major HIV scare hit the adult industry, temporarily halting production through a widespread, self-imposed moratorium, signaling an increase in responsibility while bringing about stricter safety policies and production guidelines for many producers. The adult industry has since recovered, but is it really any safer?

XBiz recently examined some of the complex issues surrounding this ongoing problem, as well as the challenges still to be faced in dealing with it. Surprisingly, despite the fact that lives are at risk, some within our industry simply do not give a damn; choosing to place profits over all other concerns. Doubtless some of these same individuals, as well as those with similar mindsets, will proffer a thousand reasons why the new 2257 regulations won't apply to them, or conjure schemes which they unwisely believe will shield them from their legal and moral responsibilities.

While most webmasters do not deal with many of the issues surrounding content production, such as the above mentioned problems with HIV transmittal, we all deal with the distribution of adult content – which carries with it the responsibility of keeping minors out of and away from it – a responsibility many of us who are lacking adequate safeguards may soon be called to account for, facing stiff penalties over violation of the very cut-and-dried 2257 law.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

Ricci Levy on Standing Up for the Right to Be Heard

When Ricci Levy speaks about human rights, she does not use detached, academic language. She speaks with urgency, emotion and the kind of passion that immediately makes it clear just how deeply personal this work is for her.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Lessons From Decades of Building the Adult Internet

After my first year of college, I needed a job. So I did what people did back then: I opened the newspaper and started scanning the classifieds. One listing stood out: “Image Librarian.” I had no idea what that meant, but I applied, and got the job.

Tanguy ·
opinion

How to Build a Cross-Border Payment Strategy

Pull up your analytics and you’ll likely find that international traffic is already on your site. Some of those visitors convert, but a lot more bounced at checkout — and a meaningful chunk tried to pay but were declined.

Joe Fredricks ·
opinion

The KPIs That Keep Payment Processing Humming While You're Away

I always look forward to the summer as my kids are home and I can plan little trips with them to reconnect and have some fun. If you’re like me, however, you probably never go on vacation without your laptop, so you can check in or lurk in the background to make sure all systems remain go.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

What Utah's SB 73 Means for Compliance Requirements

Utah has once again positioned itself at the center of the national battle over online age verification and adult-content regulation.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
profile

Clips4Sale's Christy on Backing Creators and Fueling Growth

Understanding the industry from within goes beyond data. For Christy, Manager of Creator Experience at Clips4Sale, that insight is shaped by front-line conversations and years spent listening not just to trends, but to people.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Breaking Down AI-Powered Moderation and Platform Safety

Adult platforms, including content sites, cam services and dating apps, consistently face a range of high-risk challenges. These include verifying consent, particularly for user-uploaded content, addressing nonconsensual material such as leaks and so-called revenge porn, and ensuring effective age verification and protection for minors. At the same time, platforms must manage content moderation at scale while addressing payment fraud, scams, harassment and user abuse.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

How to Optimize Subscription Billing for Compliance and Stability

The Federal Trade Commission’s “click to cancel” rule is coming back around. Last year, a federal appeals court vacated the FTC’s Negative Option Rule, aimed at addressing deceptive or unfair practices and making it easier for consumers to cancel online subscriptions.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Key Strategies for Streamlining Payment Processing Approval

Why is it taking so long to get my account approved? It's frustrating for everyone involved, but it's all part of the process. Over the past year, timelines have stretched to 60 days or more for merchants to complete onboarding, from internal compliance review to banking partner approval and final card brand registration.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

What to Know About Alabama's Regulatory Push on Adult Content

Over the past two years, Alabama has quietly but aggressively transformed itself into one of the most restrictive and unfriendly jurisdictions for the adult entertainment industry. Through the enactment of House Bill 164 and related enforcement mechanisms, the state has layered taxation, compliance burdens and content restrictions in a way that goes far beyond traditional regulation.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
Show More