opinion

U.S. Obscenity Laws: 1

Editor's note: Observers of the Washington scene will have noticed by now that certain elements within the federal government are pushing for a reinvigorated assault on the adult entertainment industry; including the redefinition, and prosecution of, federal obscenity laws. To better understand where this is all going, it's important to understand where it's starting from. Here's a two part look at the often confusing statutes, their roots, and examples of the results of their application.

"The line between protected expression and punishable obscenity must be drawn at the limits of a community's tolerance rather than in accordance with the dangerous standards of propriety and taste."*

It was obvious to the generation of patriots that founded the American Republic on these shores that the authority and power of government should be mistrusted, challenged and limited because, unless the scope of governmental power is held under control, it will expand, eroding personal and social liberty until absolute government is the result.

The founders trusted democratic governments no more than monarchies; the Bill of Rights — and in particular, the First Amendment, protecting freedom of expression, association and religion and prohibiting a state religion — is largely a counter-majoritarian instrument, meaning that many of its provisions protect the liberty of individuals from the power of majorities that have seized control of government.

It seemed to the Founders to be a cornerstone-bedrock principle that individual liberty was a natural right of persons, that a good measure of such liberty promoted the success of a society, that the power of government was antagonistic toward individual liberty, and that individual rights, including expressive rights, must be enduringly protected from government for reasons important both to individuals and society as well.

The word "Liberty," appearing on all U.S. coins, represents the collective historical judgment of this society that the freedoms of its members must be protected even from a democratic government whose officers are elected by this society itself, and perhaps most especially from a government that claims good intentions, because "the road to hell is paved with good intentions."

But the protections of the Bill of Rights — indeed the words of the First Amendment itself — are nothing more than dried ink on parchment until or unless they are enforced in a court of law.

The confusing and thorny patchwork of conflicting issues and principles and cynical rationalizations that make up obscenity law has largely come about, in my opinion, because the development of obscenity law is an aberration, a deviation from the traditional foundations of American law regarding expression.

Insofar as "community standards" work in part to establish the boundary between that expression which is protected by the Constitution and which works may be criminally proscribed, the First Amendment and its counter-majoritarian protections for individuals have become significantly attenuated in the context of erotic speech.

The 1956 holding in Roth vs. United States determined that some speech was simply outside the protection of the First Amendment — including obscene matter.

In taking this position, the Supreme Court looked at history a bit and noted the existence of colonial and early state criminal laws concerning libel and blasphemy and profanity, including those utterances which mocked or satirized sermons.

In Part 2 of our look at U.S. Obscenity Laws, we'll examine lust, prurience, and finding value in erotica. Stay tuned!

J.D. Obenberger is an attorney at J.D Obenberger and Associates based in Chicago.

*RED BLUFF DRIVE-IN INC. VS. VANCE, 648 F.2D 1020, 1029 (5TH CIR.1981), CERT. DENIED SUB NOM, THEATRES WEST INC. VS. HOLMES, 455 U.S. 913, 102 S.CT. 1264, 71 L.ED.2D 453 (1982)

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Consent Verification Could Shape the Next Wave of Platform Regulation

Five years ago, age verification wasn’t a priority for most online adult platforms. While some markets had laws in place, enforcement was fragmented, and many platforms still relied on users to self-declare their dates of birth. Today, regulators worldwide are mandating stronger age-assurance measures, with detailed technical standards and greater scrutiny of how platforms implement them.

Andy Lulham ·
opinion

How Adult Platforms Can Prepare for California's AB 1705 Requirements

California’s AB 1705 takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, giving adult website operators a short runway to prepare. Signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 30, the law creates new obligations involving uploader verification, age and consent certifications, record retention and content already displayed on covered websites.

Corey Silverstein ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Help Merchants Avoid Onboarding Delays

Adding a new acquiring partner, whether directly through a bank or through a payment facilitator, can mean an onboarding process that takes up to two months.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Layered Fraud Controls Can Stop Card Testing Before Chargebacks Hit

You suddenly have 400 new $1 trial signups. Sales are up, the approval rate looks great and, at first glance, the numbers seem worth celebrating.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Falcon/NakedSword Makes Every Body Count in 'Deeper by the Dozen'

Double trouble is on the menu in NakedSword’s “Deeper by the Dozen,” an all-sex buffet where personal space is scarce and temptation is plentiful. Trading scripted drama for a fresh batch of bare buns, the studio serves up two gangbangs with exclusive Jaxx Cody and “Trailer Trash Boys” regular Ian Sterling as the main course.

Christian Cintron ·
profile

BranditScan's Aerie Saunders on Fostering Creator Knowledge, Confidence and Community

Aerie Saunders is firmly in her season. When she sits down with XBIZ, a fall-scented WoodWick candle burns in the background, pumpkins decorate her desk and the first signs of spooky season are already on display. Not that Saunders waits until autumn to embrace the macabre.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

What Mastercard's Scam Monitoring Program Means for Adult Merchants

Mastercard's Scam Merchant Monitoring Program (SMMP) has introduced a new, investigation-led framework that works very differently from the ratio-based chargeback programs the industry has relied on for years. It applies to card-not-present merchants globally, and Mastercard's guidance on business models warranting closer attention includes adult content and dating platforms, along with subscription services, digital goods and forex.

Len Garcia ·
opinion

Why the Right Merchant Category Code Matters for NSFW AI Businesses

You explained exactly what your NSFW AI business does to your payment processor and they seemed to get it. The underwriting process felt thorough and exhausting, but it was well worth it because you began processing.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How Local Payments Can Expand Access and Reduce Friction at Checkout

Global adult platforms often enter new markets with a familiar assumption: If their checkout accepts major cards, they're ready for local customers. In reality, payment habits vary widely by country. Dutch consumers use iDEAL for online shopping, BLIK is a leading e-commerce payment method in Poland, and India's UPI handles billions of transactions each month.

Mitch Platt ·
opinion

How Detailed Receipts Build Consumer Trust and Reduce Chargeback

When was the last time you bought something online? Chances are you looked for the confirmation almost immediately. Did the transaction go through? Does it show what you bought? Were you charged correctly? And if there's a problem, who can you contact?

Cathy Beardsley ·
Show More