opinion

The Importance of Patents in the Sex Tech Industry

The Importance of Patents in the Sex Tech Industry

The sex tech industry has achieved a remarkable amount of progress in the last decade. Innovation is occurring everywhere, including in the shapes of vibrators, the way their motors function, incorporation of haptics, and the whole new terrain of VR. The only way for a company to protect its work is to file for patents and understand how to use them to their business’ advantage.

People in adult business sometimes dismiss patents because of the industry’s difficult history in dealing with several non-practicing entities, aka “patent trolls.” This issue is coming to light again because Tzu Technologies, Inc., the owner of infamous patent known in the industry as “The Teledildonics Patent,” recently sued sex toy powerhouse LELO for infringement. LELO is next on a long list of companies that have been sued in relation to that patent.

Patents allow a company to reap the benefits of their innovations. The term of protection helps the innovator to keep competition out.

A non-practicing entity is a company that owns a patent, but does not create a product. The term, “patent troll,” was coined over time by people who believe it to be in bad conscience for such company to sue third parties for patent infringement while producing no covered product of its own.

The Teledildonics Patent (U.S. Patent No. 6,368,268), titled: “Method and Device for Interactive Virtual Control of Sexual Aids Using Digital Computer Networks,” was issued on April 9, 2002. The patent has very broad claims, enabling it to encompass much of the field of remote control sex toy technology. It expires in August 2018.

Tzu acquired the rights to the patent in 2015 without since developing any product of its own. That same year, Tzu sued seven companies for infringement, bringing it to be known as a patent troll in the industry. The defendants included six small burgeoning sex toy companies and Kickstarter, the crowdfunding platform, for its role in facilitating pre-orders in one of the products. On Oct. 2, 2015, the case against Kickstarter was dropped. In 2016, two of the defendants were held liable for approximately $50,000 in damages each, and the cases against the remaining defendants were dismissed based on undisclosed settlements.

Things were quiet on that front until recently, when on July 18, Tzu filed a complaint against LELO, asserting that their product, IDA, infringes on the patent. At the time of submission of this article, LELO has not yet responded to the suit.

This is an example of a patent, among many others, that has left some in the adult industry “sour” towards the patent system. However, as a patent attorney, I promise you that there is a lot that is “sweet” in the system if you know how to capture it. Patents are drivers of technology and business, and deliver many advantages to the owner.

Patents Incentivize Innovation

The U.S. patent system finds its roots in the Constitution. Specifically, Article I, section 8, states:

“Congress shall have power ... To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.”

Therefore, creating a patent system was one of the first things our forefathers did when establishing the U.S. They recognized the importance of such a system. Patents create an incentive for innovation in a “give and take” deal. An inventor provides all information it knows about the invention in the patent application. This is eventually published, and increases the base of human knowledge on which others can build. In exchange, the government grants the inventor 20 years of exclusive use to the invention. Countries around the world have patent systems of their own with slightly different rules, but mostly of the same spirit.

Patents Increase Profits

Patents allow a company to reap the benefits of their innovations. The term of protection helps the innovator to keep competition out. During the lifetime of a patent, the owner can sue third parties for infringement, as well as stop importation of knock-offs at the border. Without a patent, anyone who learned of an idea from an inventor could produce and sell it without the inventor having any recourse. This means that the inventor’s R&D dollars would not be recoverable, much less significant profits. With competition kept at bay, an innovator can build a business, and enjoy the profits that come with a product that is the “first and only” of its kind.

Patents Facilitate Licensing, Collaboration and Partnership

Patents can facilitate collaboration. Take a look at LELO and Standard Innovation. Standard Innovation had sued LELO for infringement of U.S. Patent No. 7,931,605 (as well as two Canadian patents) for its C-shaped vibrator. LELO had released a C-shaped vibrator called “Tiana.” In response, Standard Innovation had sued for damages, an injunction and attempted to stop importation at the U.S. border. LELO, in a brilliant strategy, purchased U.S. patent No. 7,749,178, covering an inductively charging massager. It was this move that facilitated a settlement announced in February of 2016 where the parties cross-licensed their IP to one another. Standard Innovation licensed the C-shaped vibrator patent to LELO, and LELO licensed the inductive charging massager to Standard Innovation.

Patents Enable the Raising of Capital and Certain Exit Strategies

Investors want to see patents, period. Buyers of companies want to see patents, period. Buyers of patents want to see patents, period. All of these entities know the value of a patent. Accordingly, if a company is looking to raise capital for a product launch, applying for a patent should be on the original business plan. This will significantly increase the company’s chance of obtaining investment capital. Execution on that plan, including obtaining a patent, will position the company for buy out out at a later time if the management so desires.

Hopefully, at this point, I’ve convinced you that patents are valuable tools. So, now you’re going to need to know what qualifies for a patent. A patent can be granted on any technology that is new, non obvious and useful. “New” means that the product or services have never been published before. “Non obvious” requires that the invention not be obvious in light of what has come before it. I know that this sounds subjective, and unfortunately, it is. Finally, the usefulness requirement has a low threshold. It simply means that the invention should do what the patent application says it’s going to do. If it’s a vibrator that hits some spot of the body differently from others, then it should, in fact, function that way.

Patents can mean big bucks to a business. It’s important to appreciate their worth. I am happy to see many players in the sex tech space have been filing for patents recently. Still, however, I also see a lot that is left on the table. In such a competitive market, companies should be reviewing their products prior to launch to determine if it would make sense to protect the technology. Although there is certainly a chunky initial investment in applying for a patent, it can pay off in leaps and bounds later on. And, bigger [profit] is better, right?

Maxine Lynn is an intellectual property attorney with the law firm of Keohane & D’Alessandro, PLLC, having offices in Chicago and Albany, New York. She focuses her practice on prosecution of patents for technology, trademarks for business brands, and copyrights for creative materials. Through her company, Unzipped Media, Inc., she publishes the UNZIPPED Sex Tech & the Law blog and Sex Tech Patent INDEXXX bulletin at SexTechLaw.com. Lynn is also an inventor, having one issued patent of her own on a sex toy, and several others still pending. Disclaimer: The content of this article constitutes general information and is not legal advice. If you would like legal advice from Maxine Lynn, an attorney-client relationship must be formed by signing a letter of engagement with her law firm.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

trends

Meet the 2024 Class of Up-and-Coming Pleasure Brands to Watch

With each new year that rolls in, new pleasure products brands emerge, and 2024 is no exception. Already this year, a slew of new brands are rapidly gaining traction and recognition via social media, among retailers and distributors — and most importantly, end consumers.

profile

WIA Profile: Sarah Franson

When you do what you love, they say, you’ll never work a day in your life — and when your job involves educating the masses about sex toys, it’s hard not to love what you do.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Popsi Lingerie CEO Sam Golshan Discusses Brand's Growth, Mission

Lingerie: a sexy French word for an alluring little something to spark things up in the bedroom, teasingly wear out to clubs, dress up in to celebrate a special occasion or just wear under everyday clothes to feel excited and desirable.

Kim Airs ·
profile

Honey Play Box's Joreail Armstrong Reflects on Company's Growth

Today, Armstrong serves as business development manager for boutique sex toy brand Honey Play Box, but he began his role there as a one-man marketing department, assisting CEO Shirley Wang with nearly every aspect of launching the brand.

Sofia Barrett-Ibarria ·
opinion

How Awareness Revolutionized Materials Used in Pleasure Products

Today’s manufacturers and consumers are material-savvy, giving rise to pleasure products that are safe to use, beautiful to look at, high-quality and even environmentally responsible.

Eric Lee ·
opinion

How Sex-Ed Lays the Groundwork for Well-Informed Shopping

We often do some research before making purchases, whether by delving into a company’s background, exploring specific products or simply making sure we understand how to use something before we buy it.

Nathan Hammerle ·
opinion

A Look at How Customer Demographics of Full-Size Sex Dolls Have Evolved

For a long time, sex dolls were dismissed as cheap novelties used by lonely heterosexual men. This was especially true of early, inflatable versions, which became the butt of jokes in pop culture. However, things have changed dramatically.

Rebecca Weinberg ·
opinion

Why Getting Back to In-Person Events Is Imperative for Pleasure Biz

Even before COVID-19, consumers were already increasingly shopping online. During the pandemic, that trend naturally skyrocketed, and many of us store owners and suppliers became accustomed to leaning back and managing nearly all of our business from behind a screen.

Sean Quinn ·
opinion

The Continuous Journey of Legal Compliance in Adult

The adult entertainment industry is teeming with opportunity but is also fraught with challenges, from anticipating consumer behavior to keeping up with technological innovation. The most labyrinthine of all challenges, however, is the world of legal compliance.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

What Pleasure Brands Need to Know About Celebrity Endorsements

The right celebrity endorsement could skyrocket your brand into profitable relevance. The wrong one could send your brand crashing down into obscurity. While the allure of celebrity endorsements is obvious, less obvious are the risks that come with handing over the responsibility for your brand’s reputation to a third party.

Kathryn Byberg ·
Show More