opinion

A Pound of Flesh

2007 will bring some prosecution efforts against the adult industry but fewer than expected when George W. Bush was re-elected in 2004.

Several years ago, word began to leak out of a concerted effort to re-ignite obscenity prosecutions against the adult industry by the Justice Department.

The Religious Right began demanding its "pound of flesh," after the Ashcroft-led Department of Justice proved to be a disappointment to their censorship agenda.

The re-election of George W. Bush was accompanied by the appointment of a new U.S. attorney general, Alberto Gonzalez, who promptly pledged to make prosecution of adult websites a high priority.

Riding high on his re-election, with plenty of political capital to spend, Bush's agenda seemed unstoppable in 2005. However, life has a way of laying waste to the best-laid plans.

Extreme Associates
The first high-profile prosecution — against Extreme Associates – was stopped dead in its tracks by a courageous decision from U.S. District Court Judge Lancaster in the Western District of Pennsylvania. Although the decision was reversed on appeal, and the prosecution resumed, much of the wind has been taken out of the sails of the Justice Department in this particular case.

Instead of showing the Religious Right that the Bush administration is serious about obscenity prosecution against the adult industry, the Extreme Associates case has now merely provided a pulpit for Rob Black to criticize and humiliate the Justice Department's censorship efforts.

Then there's this little problem in the Middle East, which Bush can't seem to solve, no matter how many guns he sends over to that part of the world. The difficulties encountered in Iraq and Afghanistan have been distracting to a Justice Department that had hoped to move on to more "red meat" issues for the fundamentalist movement, by this point.

Although Congress was successful in passing amendments to Section 2257, and some inspections have occurred, the FBI seems to be treating this issue more as a regulatory effort, as opposed to a law enforcement matter.

Certainly, some adult companies will be prosecuted for 2257 violations in the coming months, however the combination of the Free Speech Coalition's continued injunction protecting secondary producers from certain records keeping obligations, along with the seemingly lackluster vigor with which the investigating agents are enforcing the law, might result in less intimidation than hoped for by the administration.

The Justice Department's most recent effort against SlaveSpace.com, in New York City, proved to be another loss at least on the obscenity issues. Try as they might, they just cannot seem to get this thing off the ground.

Although existing prosecutions in Florida and Pennsylvania may set important precedent for years to come, new cases may be fewer than expected. The shift to Democratic control in Congress hasn't helped things much either.

Since the Democrats now control the agenda, it is unlikely that we will see the introduction of additional legislation focused on doing harm to the adult industry, in particular.

Child protection measures are always popular regardless of which party is in control, however the Democrats do not need to pander to the right-wing fundamentalists when setting the agenda, which can only be helpful for the adult industry.

In sum, I believe the industry will enjoy a temporary reprieve from its anticipated death sentence, presumed to be in store only a few years ago.

This hiatus hopefully will provide the opportunity for the adult industry to become politically motivated and engaged in the 2008 presidential election, in an effort to secure its own destiny for the years to come. The time is now.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Consent Verification Could Shape the Next Wave of Platform Regulation

Five years ago, age verification wasn’t a priority for most online adult platforms. While some markets had laws in place, enforcement was fragmented, and many platforms still relied on users to self-declare their dates of birth. Today, regulators worldwide are mandating stronger age-assurance measures, with detailed technical standards and greater scrutiny of how platforms implement them.

Andy Lulham ·
opinion

How Adult Platforms Can Prepare for California's AB 1705 Requirements

California’s AB 1705 takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, giving adult website operators a short runway to prepare. Signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 30, the law creates new obligations involving uploader verification, age and consent certifications, record retention and content already displayed on covered websites.

Corey Silverstein ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Help Merchants Avoid Onboarding Delays

Adding a new acquiring partner, whether directly through a bank or through a payment facilitator, can mean an onboarding process that takes up to two months.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Layered Fraud Controls Can Stop Card Testing Before Chargebacks Hit

You suddenly have 400 new $1 trial signups. Sales are up, the approval rate looks great and, at first glance, the numbers seem worth celebrating.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

BranditScan's Aerie Saunders on Fostering Creator Knowledge, Confidence and Community

Aerie Saunders is firmly in her season. When she sits down with XBIZ, a fall-scented WoodWick candle burns in the background, pumpkins decorate her desk and the first signs of spooky season are already on display. Not that Saunders waits until autumn to embrace the macabre.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

What Mastercard's Scam Monitoring Program Means for Adult Merchants

Mastercard's Scam Merchant Monitoring Program (SMMP) has introduced a new, investigation-led framework that works very differently from the ratio-based chargeback programs the industry has relied on for years. It applies to card-not-present merchants globally, and Mastercard's guidance on business models warranting closer attention includes adult content and dating platforms, along with subscription services, digital goods and forex.

Len Garcia ·
opinion

Why the Right Merchant Category Code Matters for NSFW AI Businesses

You explained exactly what your NSFW AI business does to your payment processor and they seemed to get it. The underwriting process felt thorough and exhausting, but it was well worth it because you began processing.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How Local Payments Can Expand Access and Reduce Friction at Checkout

Global adult platforms often enter new markets with a familiar assumption: If their checkout accepts major cards, they're ready for local customers. In reality, payment habits vary widely by country. Dutch consumers use iDEAL for online shopping, BLIK is a leading e-commerce payment method in Poland, and India's UPI handles billions of transactions each month.

Mitch Platt ·
opinion

How Detailed Receipts Build Consumer Trust and Reduce Chargeback

When was the last time you bought something online? Chances are you looked for the confirmation almost immediately. Did the transaction go through? Does it show what you bought? Were you charged correctly? And if there's a problem, who can you contact?

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

What Adult Platforms Should Know About the EU AI Act

The European Union's Artificial Intelligence Act is now largely in force, creating new obligations for adult platforms using AI for content creation, performer verification, age estimation, moderation and other functions.

Corey Silverstein ·
Show More