opinion

How Deep Is Your Link?

Germany’s highest court, the Bundesgerichtshof, has ruled that the practice of “deep linking” is not illegal. The ruling, which was passed down on July 17th, was over a case in which Verlagsgruppe Handelsblatt, the German newspaper company, had brought suit against Paperboy, a news search engine, for unauthorized deep linking to their articles.

Plumbing the Depths
For those unfamiliar with the term, “Deep Linking” refers to the practice of linking directly to the content you wish to, rather than to the host site’s index or “home” page. The controversy is not without merits on both sides, since content publishers wish to focus traffic on their all-important (and sponsor-laden) entry pages, and not some back-alley page lacking in prime revenue generating capability.

Beyond the main economic concerns, changing infrastructure and directory trees can lead to excessive “document not found” (404) errors, and force publishers to make the choice of either the ongoing chore of providing updated document pointers, etc. or of having users who are unable to find the content they seek - potentially leaving them with a lowered opinion of the publisher, plus the reduction in traffic (and subsequently, income) that often comes as a result.

Both of these problems, as well as a few more, can easily be mitigated by limiting access to a designated “front door” where an up to date “Articles” link could be found (along with some lucrative advertising).

Deep linking proponents, however, assert that what they are doing is merely providing the most direct access to the content possible, streamlining Net overhead while improving the end-user experience. Many also point out the ease of preventing deep linking through technical means (using .htaccess files on *nix server systems, being an example of a simple deep linking prevention method). Another factor that proponents recognize is the additional traffic that goes to the linked resource from the directories that index them, and the revenue generated by the publisher from this abundant ‘free’ traffic.

The German View
The plaintiff, Verlagsgruppe Handelsblatt, makes individual articles for which it owns the copyright publicly accessible from their Websites over the Internet. It was their opinion that Paperboy's inclusion of their site’s materials into its search listings violated their copyright, and constituted adverse competition.

Paperboy's position that the plaintiff's work was not unfairly exploited, and that their news search service offers a substantial benefit to the public by providing a multiplicity of sources of information - including news articles whose source is not hidden, but which a lawful public access to is merely facilitated, was upheld by the court.

Attempting to prevent a climate in which “…the possibilities of the hyperlink technology remained unused,” the Bundesgerichtshof ruling declared that maintaining the public interest in a well-working Internet should take precedence over a newspaper company‘s commercial interests - regardless of whether the publisher’s advertising is bypassed or not.

Stating that if someone uses the Internet to promote their offers, then they must also accept its restrictions, which result from the common interest in the operability of the Internet, including the fact that users can access any resource directly by typing the URL for it, and that a site’s use of deep linking is but a simplified alternative for entering the URL manually.

Here in the states, a lot of litigation and legislation is being evolved over the issue of deep linking, and the results can affect nearly all of us. While the German case involved news articles, consider the American case which involved thumbnail images displayed as part of search results that linked to the full-size image, rather than to the site’s homepage. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled this fair use under copyright law.

If that is fair use, then would a search engine that listed accessible jpegs on your gallery pages and then displayed thumbnails for each, so that surfers could go straight to the image without ever seeing any of YOUR ads, but the search engine’s ads, be fair to YOU? Have an opinion? Share it below! ~ Stephen

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Adult Platforms Can Prepare for California's AB 1705 Requirements

California’s AB 1705 takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, giving adult website operators a short runway to prepare. Signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 30, the law creates new obligations involving uploader verification, age and consent certifications, record retention and content already displayed on covered websites.

Corey Silverstein ·
opinion

Eight Steps to Help Merchants Avoid Onboarding Delays

Adding a new acquiring partner, whether directly through a bank or through a payment facilitator, can mean an onboarding process that takes up to two months.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Layered Fraud Controls Can Stop Card Testing Before Chargebacks Hit

You suddenly have 400 new $1 trial signups. Sales are up, the approval rate looks great and, at first glance, the numbers seem worth celebrating.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

BranditScan's Aerie Saunders on Fostering Creator Knowledge, Confidence and Community

Aerie Saunders is firmly in her season. When she sits down with XBIZ, a fall-scented WoodWick candle burns in the background, pumpkins decorate her desk and the first signs of spooky season are already on display. Not that Saunders waits until autumn to embrace the macabre.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

What Mastercard's Scam Monitoring Program Means for Adult Merchants

Mastercard's Scam Merchant Monitoring Program (SMMP) has introduced a new, investigation-led framework that works very differently from the ratio-based chargeback programs the industry has relied on for years. It applies to card-not-present merchants globally, and Mastercard's guidance on business models warranting closer attention includes adult content and dating platforms, along with subscription services, digital goods and forex.

Len Garcia ·
opinion

Why the Right Merchant Category Code Matters for NSFW AI Businesses

You explained exactly what your NSFW AI business does to your payment processor and they seemed to get it. The underwriting process felt thorough and exhausting, but it was well worth it because you began processing.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How Local Payments Can Expand Access and Reduce Friction at Checkout

Global adult platforms often enter new markets with a familiar assumption: If their checkout accepts major cards, they're ready for local customers. In reality, payment habits vary widely by country. Dutch consumers use iDEAL for online shopping, BLIK is a leading e-commerce payment method in Poland, and India's UPI handles billions of transactions each month.

Mitch Platt ·
opinion

How Detailed Receipts Build Consumer Trust and Reduce Chargeback

When was the last time you bought something online? Chances are you looked for the confirmation almost immediately. Did the transaction go through? Does it show what you bought? Were you charged correctly? And if there's a problem, who can you contact?

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

What Adult Platforms Should Know About the EU AI Act

The European Union's Artificial Intelligence Act is now largely in force, creating new obligations for adult platforms using AI for content creation, performer verification, age estimation, moderation and other functions.

Corey Silverstein ·
profile

Verifymy's Emma Robert-Tissot on Putting People at the Heart of Online Safety

Warm, friendly and always happy to help, Emma Robert-Tissot has a gift for making even the most complex corners of online safety feel approachable.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More