opinion

Unintended Consequences

Yesterday, XBIZ News reported on Sen. John McCain’s newly proposed legislation, the Stop the Online Exploitation of Our Children Act – which if enacted would result in some very burdensome and unintended consequences for both webmasters as well as for the Department of Justice.

While it’s too early to speculate on many of the “final” aspects of the legislative initiative that would require webmasters to report potentially illegal images or face prosecution and fines of up to $300,000, the burden that this would impose isn’t difficult to speculate on.

The problem arises due to the nature of the images being covered, which include those that depict children as well as those which are “obscene.” While blatant examples of child pornography are easy to identify and should be reported, even trained professionals have difficulty determining whether a “young looking” model is 18 or older. Even more problematic is the issue of obscenity, which is legally vague by definition – a definition which is in part based upon community standards, which vary by jurisdiction.

Because nearly all “sexually explicit” imagery is deemed obscene in one jurisdiction or another, responsible operators will face a dilemma; should they report “everything” to be on “the safe side” – and is that side really safe, when in reality what they are actually doing is telling the government that there’s potentially obscene material on their website?

For example, we run a small TGP/MGP that accepts open submissions from webmasters, using text links in order to avoid any ‘2257 issues. While the descriptions are filtered by our software to eliminate references to child pornography using the ASACP-provided “banned words” list, no further review is performed on these submitted galleries. We do, however, provide a link next to each listing allowing visitors to easily report galleries which may contain illegal material.

Although this site is designed to be as automated as possible, I do perform random spot checks from time to time and some of the material that I find is well beyond anything that I would personally feel comfortable in publishing. Because some of this material may be considered obscene in some jurisdictions, if this law is enacted, I’d have to report it and keep records for six months. The recordkeeping isn’t necessarily too bothersome, as I could “easily” maintain a six-month archive of our listings; but that is the “easy” part.

Because I cannot afford the time that it would take to manually check every submission – submissions which could be changed after my initial review – I have a problem with only two real solutions: either close down the site or report everything. Since the site is one of the primary feeders for our paysite, I won’t close it. I also don’t want to debate whether or not the German pissing videos I may not consider to be obscene really are, in front of a jury in Salt Lake City. So, my solution would be to mirror submissions straight to DOJ and let them decide, which would not only overwhelm them (especially if all domestic TGPs and MGPs did this); but put the kiss of death on my submissions and traffic flow.

While I’m certain that the supporters of such legislation would welcome the closing of yet another adult website, I’m not going to make it that easy for them: I’ll do my best to comply with the law and if that means that DOJ gets a daily automated email from me containing hundreds of links to porn galleries that could contain obscene material, then so be it. Perhaps they’ll consider these unintended consequences and make some intelligent recommendations concerning the details of this proposed legislation that would allow the realistic compliance of webmasters and serve the greater good and intention of the law.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

What France's New Law Means for Age Verification Worldwide

When France implemented its Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law on April 11, it marked a pivotal moment in the ongoing global debate surrounding online safety and access to adult content.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

How Adult Retailers Can Enhance Sales With Supplements

The supplement industry is big business. In 2024, Future Market Insights estimated it to be valued at $74.3 billion, and other market research firms anticipate that number will grow to upwards of $170 billion in just 10 years.

Rick Magana ·
opinion

From Tariffs to Trends: Staying Resilient in a Shaky Online Adult Market

Whenever I check in with clients these days, I encounter the same concerns. For many, business has not quite bounced back after the typical post-holiday-season slowdown. Instead, consumers have been holding back due to the economic uncertainty around the Trump administration’s new tariffs and their impact on prices.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Why It's Time the Pleasure Industry Got Serious About IPX Waterproof Ratings

As someone who regularly communicates with manufacturers, retailers and consumers, I’ve seen how this ambiguity can do a disservice to both the customers who use these products and the businesses that sell them.

Alicia Sinclair Rosen ·
opinion

Optimizing Payment Strategies for High Ticket Sales

Payment processing for more expensive items, such as those exceeding $1,000 per order, can create unique challenges. For adult businesses, those challenges are magnified. Increased fraud risk, elevated chargeback ratios and heavier scrutiny from banks and processors are only the beginning.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Tips for Sexual Wellness Brands to Win Over Gen Z This Summer

As summer rolls around, the excitement in the air is palpable, especially for one particular demographic: Gen Z. College and university classes are over, vacations are booked and it’s time to let loose.

Naima Karp ·
opinion

The Barcelona Job: A Diamond Heist Drenched in Sweat and Seduction

In a city famed for its architecture and allure, something far more seductive is about to go down. The priceless NakedSword Diamond is nestled deep within a heavily fortified Barcelona museum, and master thief Sir Peter has his eye on the prize.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

Celebrating the LGBTQ+ Community With Inclusive Packaging Design

Pride Month is a time of visibility, joy and self-expression. In the pleasure industry, projecting that energy can start with something as simple as a box. Market research shows that 72% of U.S. consumers say product packaging influences their purchasing decisions.

Matthew Spindler ·
profile

Sara Loverays on Tapping Her Goddess Energy

When Sara Loverays first turned on her webcam, she didn’t know it would change her life — or unlock a side of herself she’d been waiting to set free. What began as a way to make extra cash between travel physical therapy contracts soon became her full-time passion, a platform for self-discovery, and a ticket to building her own brand based on sensuality, self-discovery and “goddess energy.”

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Pettus Ashley

Pettus Ashley brings her A game to the world of authentic adult branding, flitting between airports as the American face of U.K. brand Bathmate. As a company brand ambassador, Ashley personifies Bathmate’s dedication to the retail world, showering staff with equal amounts of appreciation and sales education.

Women In Adult ·
Show More