opinion

Oooooooopstube.com

XBIZ and AVN ran a story recently about Titan Media suing AEBN and Webnovas for copyright infringement.

The website names that might be more familiar in this lawsuit go by the names of Xtube.com (Webnovas) and Pornotube.com (AEBN). Veoh.com (backed by Time Warner) also is named in a previous lawsuit.

These social-sharing websites allow users to upload video clips that other users can view.

There is no review or validation process with the submitted videos, so copyrighted material can and does appear.

Google’s own video offerings have so many copyright materials listed (see search for Futurama).

These websites make their revenue through advertising banners. A Titan video clip on one of these sites could be classified as being “gay content,” and therefore gay-related banners and offerings would show up -- potentially ad banners for the paysites of the companies running the sharing site.

These companies benefit from the eyeball views of stolen material.

The defense that most companies have in this space is to bring out the DMCA. The DMCA provides safe harbor for Internet service providers by saying that if a copyright holder finds their content being used, the website must take it down in a “reasonable period of time.”

Companies who use the DMCA defense will claim they have no way to validate or verify the thousands of videos they receive.

This brings up many interesting related angles, like why does an adult paysite have to do all the 2257 compliance and yet another website can show sexually explicit content with no 2257 compliance?

But the nature of this lawsuit is about copyright infringement as a civil case, whereas 2257 is a federal issue.

Titan Media has been successful in winning copyright infringement cases and settlements against companies like Hustler who have been found to be using their content.

I asked Gill Sperlein (general counsel for Titan) what outcome they are seeking in their lawsuits. He replied, "Titan simply seeks to be compensated for the unauthorized use of its content and to ensure that such use stops. I doubt this can be achieved without a final ruling on the legality of the business model."

The implications of a victory for Titan may require that these sharing communities have to validate video from the copyright owner, which would be extremely burdensome and almost impossible, and may end up shaping the business model.

These websites would have to somehow verify who the copyright owner is (which does goes toward the 2257 issue), which would essentially reduce a significant amount of video content, also crippling the company in the logistics of doing the verifications.

Many big companies like Time Warner jumped into these sharing networks and now have to evaluate the implications of copyright owners rights.

In his new age where “information wants to be free,” we must all realize that information can be expensive, both in licensing and litigation as the young Wld West web meets the rights of copyright owners.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

Sophia Locke Talks Second Acts and Self-Love

Sophia Locke has the kind of presence that instantly makes you want to lean in. She’s confident, effortlessly glamorous and exudes sincerity. Chatting with her feels like catching up over lattes with your best friend — who happens to casually drop that she’s filming three Adult Time features next month.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

The Hidden Cost of Letting Retail Define Pleasure Brands

Not long ago, spotting vibrators and lubricants at a national chain like Target or CVS might have raised eyebrows. Now, it’s almost expected.

Rin Musick ·
profile

Reese Rideout Looks Back on a Career Written in Stardust

With his sculpted features and leading-man charisma, Reese Rideout looks like he would be at home in a Marvel blockbuster — or at least a stylish slasher flick where he plays the crafty guy who makes it all the way to the final act.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Kelsey Harris

At sister distribution brands Nalpac and Entrenue, one woman is in charge of leading customers in the right direction: Director of Sales Kelsey Harris. Since Michigan-based Nalpac took the reins of Arizona’s Entrenue, Harris has led both sales teams from her home base in Oakland County, Michigan.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

How AI Helps Creators Focus More on Creating

Being a content creator today is about a lot more than just content. It’s about marketing, scheduling, analytics and writing — a lot of writing. Whether it’s sexy captions, subscriber newsletters or the perfect social post, words matter.

Megan Stokes ·
opinion

The Art of Faceless Brand Building

When I first began working as a content creator on streaming platforms, I made a conscious choice to take an unconventional path. I decided I would always keep part of my face off-camera: I don’t show my eyes. Instead, I rely on a smile, a gesture and the overall atmosphere.

Pussylovekate ·
opinion

Rebranding Sexual Wellness Through a Self-Care Approach

As most of us in the industry already know, sexual wellness remains the black sheep of self-care. Discussions about wellness glorify meditation apps, skincare routines and workout regimens — but mention masturbation or using a sex toy, and most people shy away from the topic.

Hail Groo ·
profile

WIA Profile: Leah Koons

If you’ve been to an industry event lately, odds are you’ve heard Leah Koons even before you’ve seen her. As Fansly’s director of marketing, Koons helps steer one of the fastest-growing creator platforms on the web.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

Why Sex Toy Innovation Isn't What Shoppers Want Right Now

During my first year in the industry, the luxury vibrator on shelves was LELO’s Gigi, priced at $109. It was made with high-quality silicone, boasted an ergonomic design, a travel lock and a warranty. Soon after, Je Joue released its first product, SaSi, which employed “rolling ball” movements to simulate oral sex.

Sarah Tomchesson ·
opinion

What France's New Law Means for Age Verification Worldwide

When France implemented its Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law on April 11, it marked a pivotal moment in the ongoing global debate surrounding online safety and access to adult content.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
Show More