educational

Adverse Effects or All An Act?

In 1986 in the small town of Renton, Washington, adult motion picture theaters faced a monumental challenge: the Mayor of this city of 32,000 suggested to Renton City Council members that it enact a zoning ordinance to deal with adult entertainment venues.

Their response? A prohibition against adult theaters operating within 1000 feet of any residential zone, single or multiple family dwelling, church, park or school. After considerable legal haggling, the result was a determination that the ordinance was a valid response to "dangerous" problems created by adult theaters and "satisfies the dictates of the First Amendment." But How?

Time, Place, Manner Regulation
Constitutional law dictates that "content-neutral" time, place, manner regulations are acceptable only if they are "designed to serve a substantial governmental interest" without unreasonably limiting alternative avenues of communication. (475 U.S. 41, 46-47). More simply put, the District Court found that the City Council's "predominate concerns" were with the secondary effects of adult theaters, and not with the content of adult films themselves. Even if "a motivating factor" in enacting the ordinance was to restrict respondents' exercise of First Amendment rights the ordinance would be invalid, apparently no matter how small a part this motivating factor may have played in the City Council's decision. 748 F.2d, at 537

Substantial Government Interest
The Court found that a city's interest in preserving the quality of life in the city was proper. In fact, it is proper for Renton to regulate adult theaters by dispersing them in the outskirts of the city. Since Renton did not summarily ban adult theaters from operating, the Renton City Ordinance was considered valid. So it's not surprising that when the ACE Miami Adult Legal Conference assembled in March of this year, discussion surrounding the future difficulties facing adult business owners centered around this pivotal secondary effects case.

According to Brad Shafer, a veteran First Amendment lawyer, "secondary effects is now the doctrine that the Supreme Court and the federal courts and state courts around the country now utilize as a basis to regulate any type of adult business and any type of regulation." However, this type of reasoning is flawed for a number of reasons.

In Flanigan Enterprises, Inc. v. Fulton County, an ordinance was enacted which prohibited the sale of alcohol in nude dance clubs. According to Steve Youngelson, the attorney for Flanigan Enterprises, Inc., the case revolved around the secondary effects studies the county conducted before enacting these ordinances. Police and Department of Planning officials studied alcohol consumption in dance clubs as they related to property value and crimes in the surrounding areas. What is problematic is that Fulton County relied on Los Angeles and San Antonio based studies completed in the 1970's.

The result? They were unable to find any correlation between the two. So, in order to substantiate the claim that there really did exist a secondary detrimental effect, the county looked elsewhere, effectively abandoning the results of their own studies. Using studies conducted in Los Angeles and San Antonio, cities which found a detrimental correlation. What is problematic is that Fulton County relied on Los Angeles and San Antonio based studies completed in the 1970's. While Renton suggests that if a county does not have it's own studies, it may use those of other cities in similarly situated areas, the difficulty arises in finding any similarity between these two cities nearly three decades apart. Reasonable? Stretching it.

Although the Supreme Court has ultimately decided that legislatures may reasonably rely upon these studies, the reasonableness of these studies needs to be reconsidered. Until we reach a time when the Court can admit these studies are flawed, adult businesses and their owners must maintain a vigilante watch on the legal maneuverings of police and prosecutors on a rampage.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

To Cloud or Not to Cloud, That Is the Question

Let’s be honest. It just sounds way cooler to say your business is “in the cloud,” right? Buzzwords make everything sound chic and relevant. In fact, someone uninformed might even assume that any hosting that is not in the cloud is inferior. So what’s the truth?

Brad Mitchell ·
opinion

Upcoming Visa Price Changes to Registration, Transaction Fees

Visa is updating its fee structure. Effective April 1, both the card brand’s initial nonrefundable application fee and annual renewal fee will increase from $500 to $950. Visa is also introducing a fee of 10 cents for each transaction, and 10 basis points — 0.1% — on the payment volume of certain merchant accounts.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Unpacking the New Digital Services Act

Do you hear the word “regulation” and get nervous? When it comes to the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA), you shouldn’t worry. If you’re complying with the most up-to-date card brand regulations, you can breathe a sigh of relief.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

The Perils of Relying on ChatGPT for Legal Advice

It surprised me how many people admitted that they had used ChatGPT or similar services either to draft legal documents or to provide legal advice. “Surprised” is probably an understatement of my reaction to learning about this, as “horrified” more accurately describes my emotional response.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Free Agent Auteur: Casey Calvert Expands Her Directing Horizon

Now, having brought that highly-awarded polyamory trilogy to a close, Calvert is concluding the exclusive Lust Cinema directing chapter of her career and charting a new course out into open creative waters as a free agent.

Alejandro Freixes ·
profile

WIA Profile: Holly Randall

If you’re one of the many regular listeners to Holly Randall’s celebrated podcast, you are already familiar with her charming intro spiel: “Hi, I’m Holly Randall and welcome to my podcast, ‘Holly Randall Unfiltered.’ This is the show about sex, the adult industry and the people in it.

Women In Adult ·
trends

What's Hot Now: Leading Content Players on Trending Genres, Monetization Strategies

The juggernaut creator economy hurtles along, fueled by ever-ascendant demand for personality-based authenticity and intimacy — yet any reports of the demise of the traditional paysite are greatly exaggerated.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

An Ethical Approach to Global Tech Staffing

One thing my 24-year career as a technologist working to support the online adult entertainment industry has taught me about is the power of global staffing. Without a doubt, I have achieved significantly more business success as a direct result of hiring abroad.

Brad Mitchell ·
opinion

Finding the Right Payment Partner

Whenever I am talking with businesses that are just getting started, one particular question comes up a lot: “How do I get a merchant account?” It’s a simple question, but it has a complicated answer.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

The Taxman Cometh for Every Business

February may be the month of romance, but it is also a time when we need to think about something that inspires very little love: taxes. April is not far away, and the taxman is always waiting. This year, federal and most state income taxes are due Monday, April 15.

Cathy Beardsley ·
Show More