opinion

Combating Piracy

Recently, XBIZ World Magazine asked several industry players "Which do you think will be most effective in combating content piracy — taking legal action against pirates, a technological solution, or some combination of both?"

Here's what they had to say:

Who steals content in the first place? My opinion is that there are three kinds of people who do this: aware, unaware and arrogant. The aware know they are stealing but believe "everyone's doing it" or "who cares." The unaware believe ignorance is bliss. The final is the most dangerous in that he/she won't even acknowledge piracy is wrong and refuse to change even if they get caught. To combat this problem you first need to change the attitudes of those who steal. Currently we are faced with a new batch of webmasters/owners who simply weren't taught proper business ethics and learned on the street that you take what you need without care of anyone else's feelings or stuff.

— Robert "TheLegacy" Warren, Vice President of Operations, SexDateCash

I believe the current challenges of piracy and copyright infringement derive from a larger issue. The online adult industry has no governing body. Therefore, nobody feels an obligation to respect copyrights, just as nobody feels obligated to provide accurate financial reporting. There is no single solution, as the Internet's global nature does not permit copyright law to be enforced effectively. Engaging an entire industry to work together to stop piracy is utopian thinking. Advancements in the private sector will likely provide a solution that is applicable for our needs before coordinating a unanimous "buy in" between those who produce content.

— SilverCash Albert, Vice President of Business Development, SilverCash.com

Well, there will always be these bottom feeders in any business, and legal and technological strikes against them are a good start. I have been thinking about tube sites — there is good and bad here. I think the good is obvious, but the bad is not paying attention to the content or the file sizes or who they are in the first place. This is a major problem. If they are the new MGPs, they need to be responsible for at least what is uploaded to their network. Monetizing a tube site is not easy. I think the more you give away the less you sell, so as a company we see a shake-up soon of many of these sites going bye-bye.

— Mike Hawk, Co-Founder, SmashBucks.com

A technical solution won't work because it only takes one 12-year-old cracker to break the encryption and then share it everywhere. The answer, unfortunately, is legal action. You have to target the money flow — hosting providers, domain registrars, advertising companies, sponsor programs, etc. If you cut off the money flow, or the operational aspects of the site, then it will go back underground, where people traded for free amongst collectors. Content providers should watermark their content visibly with their URL, because some aspect of viral [marketing] could come their way, as well as using invisible watermarks to allow the programmatic searching of their content. Some are still trying to come up with DRM-like systems that involve the requirement for the user to download a player. It's not going to work; DRM failed.

— Brandon Shalton, Founder, T3Report.com

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

How Adult Businesses Can Navigate Global Compliance Demands

The internet has made the world feel small. Case in point: Adult websites based in the U.S. are now getting letters from regulators demanding compliance with foreign laws, even if they don’t operate in those countries. Meanwhile, some U.S. website operators dealing with the patchwork of state-level age verification laws have considered incorporating offshore in the hopes of avoiding these new obligations — but even operators with no physical presence in the U.S. have been sued or threatened with claims for not following state AV laws.

Larry Walters ·
opinion

Top Tips for Bulletproof Creator Management Contracts

The creator management business is booming. Every week, it seems, a new agency emerges, promising to turn creators into stars, automate their fan interactions or triple their revenue through “secret” social strategies. The reality? Many of these agencies are operating with contracts that wouldn’t survive a single serious dispute — if they even have contracts at all.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Sustainable Revenue Without Opt-Out Cross-Sales

Over the past year, we’ve seen growing pushback from acquirers on merchants using opt-out cross-sales — also known as negative option offers. This has been especially noticeable in the U.S. In fact, one of our acquirers now declines new merchants during onboarding if an opt-out flow is detected. Existing merchants submitting new URLs with opt-out cross-sales are being asked to remove them.

Cathy Beardsley ·
trends

How to Handle Payment Disputes Without Sacrificing Trust

You can run the best-managed and most compliant website out there, but that still doesn’t completely shield you from the risks tied to payment disputes. Buyer’s remorse, an unclear billing description or even a simple misunderstanding can lead a customer to dispute a transaction. Accumulate enough disputes, and both your reputation and revenue could be at risk.

Jonathan Corona ·
trends

WIA Profile: Taylor Moore

With a 70-person team and a growing slate of tools for content creators, the Teasy Agency has developed a reputation for putting talent first. That commitment owes a lot to co-founder Taylor Moore’s own experiences as a cam model.

Jackie Backman ·
profile

WIA Profile: Cathy Turns Creator Platform Experience Into a Model-First Playbook

As both a model and industry executive, Cathy lives in two worlds at once. “Since I do both things, I can act as the liaison between the model community and the rest of the SextPanther team,” she tells XBIZ.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

From Compliance to Confidence: The Future of Safety in Adult Platforms

In numerous countries and U.S. states, laws now require platforms to prevent minors from accessing age-inappropriate material. But the need for safeguarding doesn’t end with age verification. Today’s online landscape also places adult companies at uniquely high risk for inadvertently facilitating exploitation, abuse or reputational harm, or of being accused of doing so.

Andy Lulham ·
opinion

What Adult Businesses Need to Know About Florida's Age Verification Law

The rise and proliferation of age verification laws has changed the landscape for the online adult industry. A recent and compelling example is the state of Florida, where Attorney General James Uthmeier has filed multiple complaints against major platforms as well as affiliates accused of violating the state’s AV law.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Maintaining Brand Trust in the Face of Negative Press

Over the last year, several of our merchants have found themselves caught up in litigation over compliance with state age verification laws. Recently, Segpay itself was pulled into the spotlight, facing scrutiny over Florida’s AV statute, HB 3. These stories inevitably get picked up by both industry and mainstream news outlets.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How to Switch Payment Processors Without Disrupting Business

For many merchants, the idea of switching payment processors can feel pretty overwhelming. That’s understandable. After all, downtime can stall sales, recurring subscriptions can suddenly fail, or compliance gaps can put accounts at risk. Operating in a high-risk sector like the adult industry can further amplify the stress of transition.

Jonathan Corona ·
Show More