opinion

2257 or Piracy?

Recently, XBIZ World magazine asked several industry players, "If you had the power to eliminate one of the following from existence, would you do away with 2257 record-keeping regulations, or content piracy?"

Here's what they had to say:

This is a tough one! But I would have to say piracy. With piracy, everyone is getting hurt. Not only are studios losing out on sales, but customers are getting inferior product. Most importantly, bit-torrent sites do not require age verification to watch the movies they are offering illegally, so kids can download the movies. They also allow anyone to upload video. How do we know the people in those videos are of age or consenting since bit-torrents have no documentation. Right now, I view piracy as a bigger threat to the industry and other people's perception of the industry.
— Megan Stokes, VP of Sales, Shane's World

Even with Google joining in on torrent searches, I'm not sure we will ever see the day that content piracy is reduced to the point where it is not an issue. Let us not forget that one of the oldest — and still most efficient — methods for the end-user to download content is email newsgroups. Users do not require additional software, only an email client. All in all, if I had to pick one thing to eliminate, my vote is for content piracy as it is truly a global phenomenon with no end in sight. The impact of 2257 record-keeping regulations, on the other hand, is at this time restricted to the U.S. and does not affect the wider industry to the same degree.
— Paul Armstrong, Director of Business Development, AdultRental.com

Content piracy is hands-down the most pressing issue in our industry right now. It does not take a genius to realize that if there is quality, easily accessible content available, Internet savvy people are going to download it instead of paying for a membership. We need to adapt our business models and marketing strategies in order to keep moving forward. If we can't stop content piracy — and the odds are not in our favor — we must learn to acclimatize or we are doomed to be grabbing at an ever-shrinking piece of the pie.
— Brad, Affiliate Manager, AdultLounge.com

I would definitely eliminate content piracy because of the financial burden that it places on the industry. On the other hand, 2257 record-keeping is extremely useful and necessary because it forces us to police ourselves. The people who are engaging in content piracy are disrespecting the industry and are nothing but thieves.
— Holly Ruprecht, Affiliate Manager, Epoch

Content piracy. 2257 is a bit of a pain in the ass but ultimately it protects the producers and that's important. They can't be held accountable for people faking IDs, but they can be held accountable for not even asking. But with content piracy, any numbty with a computer now can take a DVD, throw it in their hard drive, rip it and put it up online. At Maleflixxx, we don't do downloads; we're very much against downloads. We use full DRM protection. We actually had three of our guys stay home one day and try and hack our streams and after eight or nine hours, they only got a few seconds. We know we're secure. We also worked with industry studios and helped start the Global Anti-Piracy Association (GAPA). It just shows you where our priorities are. The industry is really coming out to support it.
— Mary Gillis, Product/Marketing Manager, Maleflixxx/Sureflix Distribution

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

Manifesting Creator Success Through Action and Intention

As we enter a new year, it’s the perfect time to channel your erotic life-force energy toward your goals — and sex magic offers a powerful way to do so.

Domina Doll ·
opinion

A Creator's Guide to Starting the Year With Strong Financial Habits

Every January brings that familiar rush of new ideas and big goals. Creators feel ready to overhaul their content, commit to new posting schedules and jump on fresh opportunities.

Megan Stokes ·
profile

Jak Knife on Turning Collaboration and Consistency Into a Billion Views

What started as a private experiment between two curious lovers has grown into one of the most-watched creator catalogs on Pornhub. Today, with more than a billion views and counting, Jak Knife ranks among the top 20 performers on the site. It’s a milestone he reached not through overnight virality or manufactured hype, but through consistency, collaboration—and a willingness to make it weird.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

Pornnhub's Jade Talks Trust and Community

If you’ve ever interacted with Jade at Pornhub, you already know one thing to be true: Whether you’re coordinating an event, confirming deliverables or simply trying to get an answer quickly, things move more smoothly when she’s involved. Emails get answered. Details are confirmed. Deadlines don’t drift. And through it all, her tone remains warm, friendly and grounded.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Outlook 2026: Industry Execs Weigh In on Strategy, Monetization and Risk

The adult industry enters 2026 at a moment of concentrated change. Over the past year, the sector’s evolution has accelerated. Creators have become full-scale businesses, managing branding, compliance, distribution and community under intensifying competition. Studios and platforms are refining production and business models in response to pressures ranging from regulatory mandates to shifting consumer preferences.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

How Platforms Can Tap AI to Moderate Content at Scale

Every day, billions of posts, images and videos are uploaded to platforms like Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and X. As social media has grown, so has the amount of content that must be reviewed — including hate speech, misinformation, deepfakes, violent material and coordinated manipulation campaigns.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

What DSA and GDPR Enforcement Means for Adult Platforms

Adult platforms have never been more visible to regulators than they are right now. For years, the industry operated in a gray zone: enormous traffic, massive data volume and minimal oversight. Those days are over.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Making the Case for Network Tokens in Recurring Billing

A declined transaction isn’t just a technical error; it’s lost revenue you fought hard to earn. But here’s some good news for adult merchants: The same technology that helps the world’s largest subscription services smoothly process millions of monthly subscriptions is now available to you as well.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Navigating Age Verification Laws Without Disrupting Revenue

With age verification laws now firmly in place across multiple markets, merchants are asking practical questions: How is this affecting traffic? What happens during onboarding? Which approaches are proving workable in real payment flows?

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Adult Businesses Can Navigate Global Compliance Demands

The internet has made the world feel small. Case in point: Adult websites based in the U.S. are now getting letters from regulators demanding compliance with foreign laws, even if they don’t operate in those countries. Meanwhile, some U.S. website operators dealing with the patchwork of state-level age verification laws have considered incorporating offshore in the hopes of avoiding these new obligations — but even operators with no physical presence in the U.S. have been sued or threatened with claims for not following state AV laws.

Larry Walters ·
Show More