educational

Laughable Litigation

While XBIZ reports on a lot of industry and Internet legal stories, more than a few have given us pause. While we by no means consider the merits of each case, we thought our readers might enjoy the top 10 cases that made us ask, "What were they thinking?"

Porn on Lockdown
Convicted murderer Ernest Tope filed a class-action suit against the state of Indiana on behalf of 20,000 inmates demanding the right to get porn in prison. The civil rights suit challenges a state prison policy that bans prisoners from receiving magazines such as Playboy and Penthouse. Tope, who is seeking reversal of the policy and attorneys fees, said he was miffed that he could not receive his copy of Easyriders, a motorcycle magazine that features partial female nudity.

Dial 1-900-SEX-COMP
A Florida phone sex operator won a workers compensation claim after she developed carpal tunnel syndrome in both hands while masturbating as often as seven times per day. Steven Slootsky, who represented the unidentified woman, said he didn't know if the claim was the first of its kind, but he did confess that it was "out of the ordinary." According to Slootsky, his client was told to do "whatever it takes to keep the person on the phone as long as possible."

The Marriage Penalty
An Emeryville, Calif., lawyer who is separated from his wife, but not quite divorced, has filed suit against eHarmony, alleging that the dating site's "unmarried only" policy abridges his civil rights. John Claassen filed the suit for $12,000 after eHarmony refused to help him find his match.

"I think ultimately California civil rights laws leave those sorts of choices to the individual rather than to business establishments," he said. "Any user can decide who they're looking for, and if they want to make a choice based on marital status, I don't see why they can't do that."

Don't Be Afriended
The California Supreme Court ruled unanimously that obscene speech is not always workplace harassment. The justices agreed with Warner Bros. Television Productions that explicit comments in staff meetings during the production of "Friends" TV scripts were part of the creative process and, therefore, the studio and its writers could not be sued for workplace harassment.

Banks To Doc Johnson: 'Keep Your Hands Off My Ass'
Adult star Briana Banks filed a federal lawsuit against Doc Johnson Enterprises, claiming the sex toy manufacturer struck a deal to use molds and reproductions of her genitals for two products and then made 12 products. According to the suit filed in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh, Banks claims the defendant made 10 unauthorized products from the molds, including the Briana 3 Hole Doll, the Briana Harness, Briana's Adventure Kit, Briana's Blazing Anal Butt Plug Adult Toy, Briana's Ten Inch Dong and others.

The Growing Pill Problem
An herbal supplement distributor that marketed penis enlargement pills over the Internet was named in a proposed class-action suit. Michael Coluzzi, a New Jersey man who initiated the legal action, said that he experienced "no increase" after taking the Alzare herbal supplement for two weeks. In court documents, Coluzzi said he joined "thousands of individuals" who have been "victimized by a scheme to defraud and obtain money through the unfair, deceptive and fraudulent marketing and selling of Alzare."

I Work Alone
A Beaver County (Pa.) employee who was fired for accessing adult websites from his office filed a federal lawsuit against the county, claiming that their policies on computer use and his eventual firing violated his 1st and 14th Amendment rights. Thompson, who represented himself, lost the case. "During the period from August 2002 through January 2003, Thompson devoted roughly 20 percent of each work day and almost 30 percent of his total work time online to visiting adult websites," the court said.

Alabama: Sex Not A Toy
A federal appeals court upheld a 1998 Alabama law banning the sale of sex toys in the state. The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Alabama could police the sale of adult novelties that include "any device designed or marketed as useful primarily for the stimulation of human genital organs." The court said that Alabama's sex-toy laws do not affect the use of condoms and Viagra or similar drugs, nor does it apply to sex toys prescribed by a physician.

Tom Cruise is Not Gay
Tom Cruise filed a $100 million lawsuit against gay porn star Kyle Bradford, whose real name is Chad Slater. Through his attorney, Cruise vehemently denied allegations that he was gay. "Cruise is a great respecter of homosexual rights, but he's not gay, and he's ready to prove this in court," his lawyer said.

The 'Star Wars' Viral Kid Strikes Back
Ghyslain Raza, aka the Star Wars Kid, whose viral of him wielding a light saber spread like wildfire on the Internet, reached a settlement with the families of three schoolyard bullies who put the movie online. A month after going online in 2003, the video had 1.1 million U.S. downloads. Raza said classmates and total strangers would shout his name and reference "Star Wars" whenever they saw him, forcing him to leave school for a private tutor.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

The ABCs of POS Systems for Adult Store Owners

What point-of-sale system is best for your adult business? Figuring that out can be frustrating, since the numerous options and acronyms don’t easily translate into a clear checklist of features and benefits you can weigh.

Sean Quinn ·
profile

Hayley Davies: From New Zealand Math Nerd to Fast-Rising Adult Star

Growing up, New Zealander Hayley Davies was a proud nerd who participated in mathematics competitions against students from much higher grades. Her good looks turned out to be a kind of secret weapon, causing peers to underestimate her intellectual acumen.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

How Pleasure Brands Can Leverage Strategic PR Amid Mainstream Media Layoffs

Thanks to the mainstreaming of intimacy products, pleasure brands can now gain broad exposure in all kinds of publications, from Cosmo to Allure to Good Housekeeping. Unfortunately, the economic uncertainty dominating the world and challenging businesses has hit the media sector particularly hard.

Kathryn Byberg ·
profile

WIA Profile: Ruth Arceo

In the beginning, all Ruth Arceo knew was that she dreamed of being a buyer — but when the opportunity presented itself for a career in the adult world, she found she’d struck it rich. Arceo is the lucky lady who gets to pick and choose how to line the shelves at The Pleasure Chest in West Hollywood, California.

Women In Adult ·
profile

CalExotics Founder and CEO Susan Colvin Reflects on Brand's 30-Year Legacy

Thirty years ago, back when there were only hard plastic sex toys in tan and black, Susan Colvin had a vision of what sex toys could be. And so she set out to create her own company, California Exotic Novelties, which for three decades has been a pioneer, continually reimagining and expanding the pleasure products market.

Kim Airs ·
opinion

How to Sell Shoppers on Water-Friendly Toys

From soothing self-care in the bath to the invigorating spray of a shower, water can introduce new dimensions of pleasure, unlock unique sensations and provide a sensual backdrop for intimate exploration.

Carly S. ·
profile

WIA Profile: Inka Winter

Award-winning erotic filmmaker and ForPlay Films founder Inka Winter knows what she wants her films to be, and what she doesn’t want them to be. She seeks to depict sexuality that is mindful, based in human connection and trauma-informed.

Women In Adult ·
profile

'Traffic Captain' Andy Wullmer Braves the High Seas as Spirited Exec

Wullmer networked and hobnobbed, gaining expertise in everything from ecommerce to SEO and traffic, making connections and over time rising through the ranks of several companies to become CEO of the mobile business arm of TrafficPartner.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

Why BDSM Furniture and Sex Machines Make an Ideal Match

For BDSM enthusiasts and curious newbies alike, a big part of the fun is discovering and exploring exciting new sensations and scenarios. One way to level up is by combining or layering pleasures you already enjoy, and one surefire way to do that is with BDSM furniture.

Rebecca Weinberg ·
opinion

To Cloud or Not to Cloud, That Is the Question

Let’s be honest. It just sounds way cooler to say your business is “in the cloud,” right? Buzzwords make everything sound chic and relevant. In fact, someone uninformed might even assume that any hosting that is not in the cloud is inferior. So what’s the truth?

Brad Mitchell ·
Show More