opinion

The Value of Nothing

There's an old saying that "the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence," and it serves as a cautionary tale by using the example of cattle that become trapped after getting their head stuck in a fence while trying to graze on what always seems to be the ripest rewards — waiting there, ever so slightly beyond their reach — if only they could stick their heads out just a little bit more...

This pursuit of "something better than you have" can often lead you down the path of the unwary cow, causing unexpected and problematic issues to suddenly be reveled in the wake of "solving" other problems, or acquiring new "solutions."

For example, shifting business models among adult websites are seeing traditionally free access properties turning to paid content models, while some formerly premium websites are battling dwindling subscriber bases by adopting free access / ad supported business models — with varying degrees of success.

Things are much the same in the mainstream world, where a solution to one problem can pave the way for a host of other dilemmas.

For example, stymied by a drop in newspaper circulation due to readers' preference for reading free news online, New York's Newsday turned its Newsday.com into a paysite — a seemingly "perfect" solution that transferred yesterday's familiar paid circulation model to the medium that consumer's desired.

I can imagine the enthusiastic agreement around the board room as this pay-to-play decision was made: "That's great — we'll give the people what they want and charge them just like they're used to paying for our regular paper."

Three months later, the site has reportedly only subscribed 35 members and has seen a 50 percent drop in traffic. While not all traffic is good traffic, 35 subscribers is nothing for a "major" publisher to boast about — although print issue subscribers as well as premium cable TV subscribers receive free access to the website.

News of the stunningly low subscriber number came out during recent union contract negotiations and shocked stakeholders on all sides of the equation, including some staff members who were dismayed over the brand's seemingly drastic drop in prominence — with nothing to show for it.

"People were expecting it to make money," a Newsday staffer who was at the union meeting was reported as saying. "If it's not, why are we doing it?"

"Why are we doing it?" — The question is as complicated as it is simple, and while there can be value in running a loss leader, for most online adult operators, the bottom line must be the bottom line. If your current operation is making money — even if it's not as much money as you would like — think long and hard about the possible implications of making drastic changes for what could be little to no reward. Otherwise, you risk being caught by the head while trying to eat grass that really is no greener than your own.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

Joey Mills Harnesses Demon Twink Energy Into Industry Staying Power

On the surface, Joey Mills might seem like one of gay porn’s quentessential bad boys. He plays a snarky scamp seducing stepdads as a Men.com exclusive and leans into villainy on the Daddy TV reality show “X-Rated: NYC." And yet, despite being a highly recognizable face in the industry, he comes across as grounded, affable and self-aware in a way you might not expect

Christian Cintron ·
opinion

How to Pivot Platforms Without Disrupting Your Income

As a creator, you must inevitably navigate the constantly changing terms of service, regulations and financial systems of various platforms. Those platforms host your content at their own discretion, so deplatforming is always a possibility.

Sara Star ·
profile

Julie Stewart on Leading Sportsheets While Honoring Its Family Roots

When Sportsheets founder Tom Stewart retired at the start of 2020, he left the company in the capable hands of his sister, Julie Stewart. Since taking over as CEO, she has guided Sportsheets through an era of transformation, resilience and renewed purpose.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
opinion

Creator Tips for Making the Most of Adult Industry Expos

Showing up to industry expos is one of the smartest moves a creator can make. If it’s your first time going and the idea makes your stomach flip a little, don’t worry. Preshow jitters are perfectly normal. But if you’re serious about building real momentum, throw those doubts and worries out the window and pack your bags.

FrenchAva ·
profile

Tracy Eagle Soars as Co-Boss of Betty's Toy Box

They say sisterhood is powerful. For proof, you need look no further than Tracy and Carolyn Eagle, two sisters who have built not just one but three online retail brands together.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

How to Draw in and Retain High-Spending Fans

One of the biggest misconceptions in the creator economy is that follower count determines revenue. Many creators assume the path to higher earnings is simply more traffic, subscribers and views. In reality, it’s common to see a tiny fraction of fans responsible for the majority of spending.

Alex Lirette ·
profile

Essence Protection Brings Specialized Coverage to Adult Retail

For adult businesses, swimming against the mainstream current makes it hard to find an insurance company that can keep up. One company is aiming to change that.

Colleen Godin ·
opinion

Balancing Growth and Audience Loyalty as a Creator

When creators who have been around a while feel the pull to explore something new, a quiet fear often creeps in: What if growth and evolution end up costing me the audience I worked so hard to build?

Megan Stokes ·
opinion

How Retailers Can Get the Most Out of Trade Shows

Trade shows offer something that catalogs and online browsing can’t match. Seeing, touching and discussing products in person gives you a better sense of how they might perform in your store.

Rin Musick ·
profile

NakedBakers on Stirring Up Flavor, Fantasy, and a Winning Moment

When NakedBakers heard her name announced as Female Streamer of the Year at the 2026 XMAs, she froze for an instant, caught between disbelief and pure joy.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More