Vivid Appeals Denial of TRO With 9th Circuit

LOS ANGELES — Vivid Entertainment yesterday filed an appeal over U.S. District Judge Dean Pregerson's denial of a temporary restraining order in the studio's suit against enforcement of Measure B, which requires the use of condoms in the production of adult movies in Los Angeles County.

Vivid, along with co-plaintiffs Kayden Kross and Logan Pierce, filed their appeal with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, presenting three questions for an appeals court panel to weigh:

  • Whether the district court erred by substantially editing definitions and substantive provisions to preserve portions of  Measure B, which had been passed as a ballot initiative to target adult films, after the court preliminarily enjoined most of the ordinance as a prior restraint?
  • Whether the district court erred in refusing to preliminarily enjoin Measure B in full based on evidence submitted by the AIDS Healthcare Foundation (named as Intervenors in the suit) "who lack Article III standing but were allowed to remain as parties below even after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Hollingsworth vs. Perry?"
  • Whether the district court erred in refusing to preliminarily restrain Measure B in full after finding that the adult film productions at issue are protected by the First Amendment and that Measure B imposes a prior restraint?

Vivid attorneys said in court documents that Pregerson erred by failing to preliminarily enjoin Measure B in its entirety.

"The court held that Measure B regulates activity protected by the First Amendment and that appellants are likely to succeed on claims that it imposes a  prior restraint, vests county officials with excessive discretion, creates unconstitutional search authority, and imposes unconstitutional permit fees. Yet it nevertheless declined to enjoin a remaining portion of the law — but only after rewriting both its definitions and intended scope," Vivid attorneys wrote.

"Such judicial lawmaking is not the proper  domain of a district court. These errors were compounded by allowing [the AHF] to become parties to the case, and to remain so even after the [U.S.] Supreme Court overruled circuit authority relied upon, and were exacerbated by reliance on AHF’s arguments to support partial denial of preliminary injunctive relief.

"After finding most of Measure B constitutionally suspect, the district court should have enjoined its operation pending a final ruling on the merits. The irreparable injury that the court found supported enjoining Measure B’s principal provisions will still result from operation of the portions that the court rewrote to preserve. The balance of equities and public interest thus fall in appellants’ favor, and Measure B’s condom-use mandate and remaining permit requirements must be preliminarily enjoined." 

In a separate filing yesterday, Vivid attorneys asked the 9th Circuit to take judicial notice of a letter issued in December by Los Angeles County Public Health Director Jonathan   Fielding directed to adult film producers, as well as a report issued by Fielding's office called "Los Angeles County Five-Year Comprehensive HIV Plan (2013-2017)."

Judicial notice is a rule in the law of evidence that allows a fact to be introduced into evidence if the fact is so notorious or well known, or so authoritatively attested, that it cannot reasonably be doubted.

Related:  

Copyright © 2023 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Corey Silverstein to Host New 'Legal Impact' Webinar on A.I.

Corey Silverstein will be speaking at the XBIZ online legal panel “Porn & A.I.: Legal & Community Implications,” on October 10, at 4 p.m. (EDT).

Blake Blossom, Skye Blue Topline 'Lesbian Superstars 3' From Lesbian X

Blake Blossom and Skye Blue headline "Lesbian Superstars 3," from XEmpire studio brand Lesbian X.

Callie Brooks Is October's 'MYLF of the Month'

Callie Brooks has been named MYLF of the Month for October, with a new baseball-themed spotlight scene opposite Matty Iceee.

Octavia Red Is Nubiles' 'Fantasy of the Month' for October

Nubiles has selected Octavia Red as its Fantasy of the Month for October, spotlighting her in a scene with Will Pounder.

Woodhull's Mandy Salley Joins This Week's #SexTalkTuesday

Woodhull Freedom Foundation COO Mandy Salley will serve as special guest moderator on the X-based chat show #SexTalkTuesday, where she will lead a discussion on the censorship of sexual freedom, tomorrow at 5 p.m. PDT.

Chanel Camryn Is Nubiles' 'Flavor of the Month' for October

Nubiles has selected Chanel Camryn as its Flavor of the Month for October and spotlighted her in a 'Barbie' parody scene with Tyler Cruise.

Penthouse Names Roxy Shaw October's 'Pet of the Month'

Penthouse Magazine has named model and artist Roxy Shaw as Pet of the Month for September.

North Dakota Republican Calls for Total Criminalization of Adult Content

A North Dakota Republican lawmaker took to Twitter over the weekend to call for the total criminalization of adult content and for all politicians to submit to “the Gospel of Jesus Christ.”

April Olsen Is Twistys' October 'Treat of the Month'

April Olsen is Twistys' Treat of the Month for October and will be highlighted online throughout the month.

TEAs Reveal 2024 Dates

Organizers of the Trans Erotica Awards (TEAs) have set the dates for the 2024 event, which will take place March 8-10 at the Avalon in Hollywood.

Show More