Negligence Claims Dismissed in Porn Piracy Case

NEW YORK — Corbin Fisher's high-profile suit against a pair of roommates sued for allegedly trading porn online was dismissed this week.

In the original suit filed at U.S. District Court in New York, Corbin Fisher charged that defendants Cary Tabora and Schulyer Whetstone, both roommates and named in another now-dismissed porn BitTorrent piracy suit involving some 840 infringements, were responsible for infringement for poaching and trading "Corbin Fisher's Down on the Farm" through a BitTorrent network, or at least one of them is.

Corbin Fisher, in its complaint, said that Tabora spoke with its attorneys and admitted that it was Whetstone who was the party who illegally and distributed the movie.

"In fact, Tabora stated emphatically, 'I was negligent' in allowing Whetstone to use his [Wi-Fi] Internet connection to illegally pirate content, and that he was aware that it would eventually cause legal problems for him," the suit said.

But U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan said that Corbin Fisher's state law negligence claim was preempted by federal copyright law and can't be brought. Kaplan pointed to Section 301 of the Copyright Act, which allows preemption with respect to other laws.

Other claims were dismissed because the title of the film in the complaint, "Corbin Fisher's Down on the Farm," didn't match the title in the copyright registration, "Corbin Fisher Amateur College Men Down on the Farm."

But Kaplan did allow Corbin Fisher the opportunity to amend direct and contributory infringement claims no later than July 25.

The case gained notoriety after the Electronic Frontier Foundation took sides, filing a friend-of-the-court brief for the defendants.

EFF postulated that if Corbin Fisher was successful in the case, Wi-Fi providers could be held responsible for users' behavior and public access to the Internet would be sharply reduced because of liability fears.

Corbin Fisher, however, said at the time that the EFF is trying to "re-frame" the case as a wholesale opposition to Wi-Fi copyright negligence claims in commercial environments.

Mitch Stoltz, a staff attorney at the EFF who worked on the amicus brief, told XBIZ "the EFF is very happy with this result," noting that the judge signaled that Corbin Fisher "is likely to lose the copyright claim against Cary Tabora if it re-files the case, because simply providing an Internet connection for a housemate isn't enough to make Tabora liable for the housemate's illegal downloading, even if he knew about it."

Corbin Fisher counsel Marc Randazza did not respond to queries whether he would retry the case as regards to the copyright claims.

View dismissal order

Related:  

Copyright © 2023 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Conservative AGs Send Letter to Aylo About Supposed Moderation 'Loophole'

South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson, along with 25 other attorneys general largely from Republican-controlled states, sent an open letter to Pornhub parent company Aylo on Friday demanding explanations about a supposed “loophole” that allowed users to post CSAM.

FSC Calls on North Carolina Governor to Veto Age-Verification Bill

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has sent a letter to North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper, asking him to veto House Bill 8, to which a Republican legislator attached a copycat age-verification amendment.

Stalker Ex-Boyfriend Convicted of Murdering Pineapple Support Therapist Amie Harwick

The ex-boyfriend of slain Pineapple Support therapist Dr. Amie Harwick was convicted Thursday of first-degree murder for her February 2020 death.

Leading Free Speech Groups File Brief Blasting Texas' Age Verification and Mandatory Labeling Law

Several leading free-speech groups, led by the ACLU, urged the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit on Thursday to block the Texas age verification law that requires adult websites to post anti-porn propaganda, contending that this violates the First Amendment.

Pre-Nom Period for 2024 XBIZ Awards Ends Saturday

The deadline for pre-nomination entries for the 2024 XBIZ Awards, the adult industry's biggest night, is Saturday at midnight, PDT.

Erolabs Launches Adult Mobile Game 'Star Lusts'

Adult game studio Erolabs has released the first six chapters of its latest mobile title, "Star Lusts."

French Government Report Urges Criminalization of Adult Industry

A sensationalistic report released this week by a French government office is urging immediate state censorship and broad criminalization of the adult industry in France and worldwide.

North Carolina Group Backing Age Verification Bill Admits Law Is Actually 'Anti-Pornography'

A North Carolina religious conservative group backing just-passed age verification legislation, which a Republican state senator snuck into an unrelated bill last week, has admitted the copycat amendment is in fact an “anti-pornography provision.”

JuicyAds Introduces 'Adsistant AutoBid' Tool

JuicyAds has launched its new Adsistant AutoBid tool, which allows advertisers to move an advertiser's bid up and down to maintain a specific bid position.

FSC Sets Calendar for Upcoming Board of Directors Election

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has set the calendar for its November election for Board of Directors.

Show More