Porn Copyright Trolling Law Firm Loses $230K Sanction Appeal

Porn Copyright Trolling Law Firm Loses $230K Sanction Appeal

PASADENA, Calif. — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday upheld more than $230,000 in sanctions against the attorneys who for years operated the porn copyright trolling law firm Prenda Law.

Attorneys John Steele and Paul Hansmeier, as well as the deceased lawyer Paul Duffy, created a “scheme,” the 9th Circuit said in its 12-page decision, that started to unravel when they faced U.S. District Judge Otis Wright, who levied sanctions against them in 2013.

Friday’s decision defends Wright's sanction and didn’t move forward the argument that the Prenda Law attorneys' due process rights were violated. Prenda Law’s appellate attorney last year sought for the sanctions to be tossed or, alternatively, a separate hearing on the sanctions to be held.

The 9th Circuit, in its description of Prenda Law’s method of operation, said the attorneys filed mass lawsuits against thousands of defendants, accusing them of illegally downloading porn movies.

“The Prenda principals, through their law firm, Prenda Law Inc., set up a number of shell companies, including Ingenuity 13 LLC and AF Holdings LLC, which purchased copyrights to pornographic movies,” the 9th Circuit wrote. “When one of those movies was illegally downloaded, the shell company (via Prenda Law or a local attorney hired by Prenda Law) filed a complaint against John Doe in federal or state court for copyright infringement and used early discovery mechanisms to determine the identities of the persons it alleged illegally downloaded the film.”

The court said that the shell company would then mail the typical John Does a letter threatening to sue unless the individual paid roughly $4,000 to “settle” the case.

“Out of embarrassment and for economic reasons, many John Does settled, regardless of whether they, or another family member, friend, or guest, infringed the copyright. When the John Does settled, Prenda Law would voluntarily dismiss the case; Prenda Law never litigated a single copyright infringement case through to a merits judgment.

By misusing the subpoena power of the court, the court said, Prenda Law made millions of dollars from suing hundreds to thousands of John Does across the country.

Things started to unravel for the law firm after courts nationwide started catching on to the its real business of copyright trolling, the court said.

"Prenda principals were found contradicting themselves, evading questioning and possibly committing identity theft and fraud on the courts," the 9th Circuit said.

Before Steele, Hansmeier and Duffy’s hearing was allowed to proceed with the appeal of sanctions, Wright ordered that the firm pay two bonds totaling more than $230,000.

The first bond consisted of the full $81,000 sanction, multiplied by 125 percent to account for interest. The second bond was $135,000, the estimated legal costs of John Doe’s defense attorney, Morgan Pietz.

The 9th Circuit on Friday held that the three Prenda lawyers, despite their arguments to the contrary, received due process for civil sanctions requiring notice, an opportunity to be heard and a finding of bad faith.

“[I]t was not an abuse of discretion for Judge Wright to find that the Prenda principals were indeed the leaders and decision-makers behind Prenda Law’s national trolling scheme,” the 9th Circuit said.

Further, "They have lied to other courts about their ability to pay sanctions. They also failed to pay their own attorney’s fees in this case."

A 2015 video of oral arguments in the appeal before the 9th Circuit can be accessed here.

View Friday's ruling

Related:  

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Justices Alito, Thomas Invoke Victorian-Era Morality Law, Raising Censorship Concerns

Several national publications reported this week on widespread concern among Free Speech advocates after U.S. Supreme Court Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas repeatedly invoked during a hearing the infamous segregation-era law the Comstock Act, which was the cornerstone of U.S. censorship of sexual material from the 1870s until the 1970s.

Skinfluential Management's FansFuel Acquires Fanwire

Creator stats and affiliate marketing platform FansFuel has acquired creator account management tool Fanwire.

Nebraska AV Bill Moves Forward Despite Privacy, Free Speech Concerns

Nebraska’s unicameral Legislature has given first-round approval to LB 1092, the state’s version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists.

AEBN Celebrates 25th Anniversary

The Adult Entertainment Broadcast Network (AEBN) is celebrating its 25th year in business this week.

Performers in Meta Blacklisting Lawsuit Seek to Preserve Antitrust Claims

Adult Performance Artists Guild board officers Alana Evans, Kelly Pierce and Ruby have informed a California court that, although they want to drop their lawsuit claiming that Meta conspired with OnlyFans to blacklist rival premium fan platforms’ talent, they may still pursue antitrust claims in the future.

FSC, Co-Plaintiffs to Ask US Supreme Court to Review Constitutionality of Texas Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) and its co-plaintiffs in the challenge to Texas’ controversial age verification law have petitioned the United States Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit to stay its recent decision upholding the law, because they intend to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to review the law’s constitutionality.

FSC Vows to Fight Florida Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has issued a statement vowing to continue fighting Florida’s new age verification law, which was signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis on Monday as part of a comprehensive bill targeting minors’ use of social media.

Kansas Republican Aims to Create New Bureaucracy to 'Investigate' Porn Websites

Republican state legislators succeeded Monday in moving forward Kansas’ version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists, despite serious concerns raised by House Democrats about the cost of establishing a new bureaucracy tasked with investigating websites for pornographic content.

SK Intertainment Launches 'Skinfluential Management' Agency, FansFuel Joint Venture

Mr. Skin/Mr. Man parent company SK Intertainment has launched new creator agency Skinfluential Management, as well as a new joint venture with Showbizz Media's creator stats and affiliate marketing platform, FansFuel.

Industry Attorney, Free Speech Champion Clyde DeWitt Passes Away at 75

Noted industry attorney Clyde DeWitt passed away on Friday in Las Vegas at 75, according to friends and colleagues.

Show More