Prosecution Must Prove Age in Child Porn Cases, Judge Says

MINNEAPOLIS — It is the responsibility of prosecutors, not defense, to prove age in suspected child porn cases, a Hennepin County judge ruled in Minnesota today.

The ruling overturns a state law that was found to put the burden in child porn suits on the defense to prove whether or not a person depicted in a pornographic image is a minor.

The ruling stems from a case involving Donald D. Schoen of Minneapolis, who was charged in May with six counts of child porn possession. Schoen’s attorney, Jeff Dean, had argued that Minnesota’s child porn law was unconstitutional because the law required judges be the ones to decide whether evidence proved the person depicted was a minor.

Because the “age proof” decision was left to a judge, and not to a jury, Dean argued that the law deprived a defendant of their right to a jury trial.

District Judge Stephen Swanson agreed, originally striking down Minnesota’s entire child pornography statute on the grounds that it was unconstitutional, but returning this week with his eyes just on the burden-of-proof issue, leaving the rest of the law in place.

Swanson’s ruling is just the latest in the complicated arena of child pornography; one in which uniform federal guidelines have yet to be ironed out and where laws can vary greatly from state to state.

“This is a really complicated issue,” ASACP Executive Director Joan Irvine told XBiz. “Proving age is often really difficult. First of all, let’s remember that the majority of child porn out there today isn’t originating from the U.S. A lot of it is coming from Russia and other Eastern European countries. So my question there is, ‘How do you prove that kid’s age when you have no way of getting a hold of them?’”

Irvine said the result is often bringing in doctors and forensic experts to study suspected photographs, who go through a complicated set of study to determine whether the image in fact features a child.

“But we all know what some of these sites do to make the people look young,” Irvine said. “Photoshop and everything else.”

The result. Irvine said, is that proving child porn cases can be very difficult except in cases of extreme youth, such as those involving toddlers and babies.

Of course, in many states, including California, simply viewing child pornography is not illegal. Instead, someone has to actively download or in some way seek out possession of the images to open up possible prosecution.

“But how do you charge them?” Bob Branford, a St. Paul attorney familiar with the Schoen case, told XBiz. “Do we charge per image, per download, per scene, per copy or some other method? Just like in obscenity cases, nobody has really hammered these out yet. Frankly I doubt we ever will.”

In May, a Michigan court tried to sort out whether the act of burning downloaded images to a disc should be considered production of child porn, a crime that carries a much harsher penalty than the one for simple possession, even if the defendant never intended to distribute the images. That case is still ongoing.

Three years ago the Supreme Court declared unconstitutional the Child Pornography Prevention Act of 1996, which made it a crime to spread "virtual" child pornography on the Internet. The court said the law's definition of virtual child porn was too broad.

Several attempts were made by Congress to pass follow-up laws, all of which failed.

States from Kentucky to Vermont and Georgia to Massachusetts have vowed to tighten restrictions on child porn lately, and federal prosecutors have obtained more than 1,066 convictions on child pornography charges in federal courts during this fiscal year, a threefold increase from the past seven years, according to U.S. Attorneys.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Nebraska Legislature Passes Republican's Age Verification Bill With No Votes Against It

Nebraska’s unicameral legislature has passed the state’s version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists.

Performers in Meta Blacklisting Lawsuit Seek to Preserve Antitrust Claims

Adult Performance Artists Guild board officers Alana Evans, Kelly Pierce and Ruby have informed a California court that, although they want to drop their lawsuit claiming that Meta conspired with OnlyFans to blacklist rival premium fan platforms’ talent, they may still have antitrust claims that they may pursue in the future.

FSC, Co-Plaintiffs to Ask US Supreme Court to Review Constitutionality of Texas Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) and its co-plaintiffs in the challenge to Texas’ controversial age verification law have filed a petition before the United States Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit asking to stay its recent upholding the law because they intend to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to review the law’s constitutionality.

FSC Vows to Fight Florida Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) issued a statement vowing to continue fighting Florida’s age verification law, which was signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis on Monday as part of a comprehensive bill targeting minors’ use of social media.

Kansas Republican Aims to Create New Bureaucracy to 'Investigate' Porn Websites

Republican state legislators succeeded Monday in moving forward Kansas’ version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists, despite serious concerns raised by House Democrats about the cost of establishing a new bureaucracy tasked with investigating websites for pornographic content.

Industry Attorney, Free Speech Champion Clyde DeWitt Passes Away at 75

Noted industry attorney Clyde DeWitt passed away on Friday in Las Vegas at 75, according to friends and colleagues.

Texas AG Ken Paxton Sues Chaturbate, xHamster Over Controversial Age Verification Law

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed lawsuits on Tuesday against the parent companies of Chaturbate and xHamster, claiming that the sites are not complying with the state’s controversial age verification law, HB 1181.

GirlsDoPorn's Michael Pratt Extradited From Spain, Pleads 'Not Guilty'

Former GirlsDoPorn owner Michael Pratt made his first appearance in federal court Tuesday following his extradition from Spain Monday night, according to a statement released by the Department of Justice.

Missouri Republican Behind FOSTA-SESTA Renews Attack on OnlyFans

Rep. Ann Wagner, the Missouri Republican legislator who was the original architect of FOSTA-SESTA, has renewed her call for federal action against OnlyFans.

Idaho Legislature Passes Republican Age Verification Bill With Full Democratic Support

The Idaho legislature has passed the state’s version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists.

Show More