NEWS STORY
Court Upholds Message Board Anonymity
The ruling stems from a case involving a popular financial forum where stock trading, corporate behavior and other finance-related issues were discussed, often by users hiding behind pseudonyms or "screen names" to protect their true identity.
In Jan. 2006, Lisa Krinsky, former president, chairman of the board, and chief operating officer of SFBC International, a Florida-based drug company, sued 10 "Doe" defendants in a Florida court, alleging that the defendants had made "defamatory remarks" about her on Yahoo! message boards and other sites, using screen names to conceal their identities.
Krinsky subpoenaed Yahoo! in an attempt to discover the identity of the pseudonymous posters – a move which was unsuccessfully contested by defendant "Doe 6" who then subsequently appealed the judgment, contending that he had a First Amendment right to speak anonymously on the Internet.
The defendant's appeal has been successful, with the Sixth Appellate Court opining that "Under the circumstances presented, we agree with Doe 6 that his identity should be protected and therefore reverse the order."
During the litigation, all 10 defendants were accused of intentional interference with a "contractual and/or business employment relationship" between Krinsky and SFBC, with nine of the defendants being accused of libel "based on false and misleading Internet statements imputing dishonesty, fraud, improper professional conduct, and criminal activity to plaintiff."
According to records of the messages posted on Yahoo!'s SFBC message board, Doe 6, who used the screen name "Senor_Pinche_Wey," called former SFBC vice president of legal affairs Jerry 'Lew' Seifer a "mega scum bag" and a "cockroach."
On Dec. 30, 2005, Doe 6 also posted "Jerry 'Lew' Seifer's New Year's resolutions," which included the following statement: "I will reciprocate felatoin [sic] with Lisa [Krinsky] even though she has fat thighs, a fake medical degree, 'queefs' and has poor feminine hygiene."
Krinsky served a subpoena on the custodian of records at Yahoo! which notified Doe 6 that it would comply with the subpoena in 15 days unless a motion to quash or other legal objection was filed.
Doe 6 then moved in superior court to quash the subpoena on the grounds that the plaintiff had failed to state a claim sufficient to overcome his First Amendment rights for either defamation or interference with a contractual or business relationship, and that the plaintiff's request for injunctive relief was an invalid prior restraint.
The court agreed.
The full opinion of the appellate court can be found here.
See all current articles in > adult industry news
Related Articles
XBIZ RSS | XBIZ Newsletters | XBIZ Desktop News | XBIZ Mobile
WEB / TECH NEWS
Webmasterchecks Launches New Affiliate Program
Brookland Bros. Entertainment Open Online Store
U.K.’s Lucid Entertainment Launches Social-networking Site ConnexionWeb
Las Vegas Swingers Ranch Opens This Weekend With Website Shoot
Spamhaus Project Wants Microsoft to Better Police Scammers
ASACP Name Invoked in Online Scams
VIDEO NEWS
Hustler Hollywood Sets 10th Anniversary Celebration
Hot Desert Knights Terminates Distribution Agreement With All Boys Distribution
Black Scorpion Signs Distro Deal With Lucom
Treasure Island Releases ‘Plantin’ Seed 3’
Video Secrets Announces Thanksgiving Contest
AVN Awards Nominations Announced
NOVELTY NEWS
OhMiBod Renames Vibrator Line to Avoid Confusion
California Exotic Novelties Releases The Zone
Head O State Dildo Sells Out, New Shipment on the Way
XBIZ Announces Stellar Seminar, Events Lineup for 2009 Conference
Teeze, Adult Store Buyer Magazines Merging
VIDEO: Vivid’s Hirsch, AEBN’s Coffman Face Off Over Piracy
PROFILES & BIOS
WIA Profile: Karen Stagliano
MobileNOBO Brings Video to Mobile
12 Clicks Cash Clicks with Cross-Sells
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
add free content to your website.
with your mobile device.

FIND PRODUCTS & SERVICES


UPCOMING EVENTS












