Home > News > 9th Circuit May Stay YouTube Takedown Decision • Bookmark   • Newsletters   • Register Search Options


9th Circuit May Stay YouTube Takedown Decision

9th Circuit May Stay YouTube Takedown Decision
Get XBIZ News
Mar 10, 2014 2:15 PM PDT    Text size: 

SAN FRANCISCO — The full 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will decide whether to stay a panel’s decision that requires YouTube to take down clips from the anti-Islamic film “Innocence of Muslims."

The original 9th Circuit ruling, made in late February, has implications for the adult entertainment because it gives with wide latitude a strong tool for performers who claim "actor's remorse," according to industry attorney Marc Randazza in an analysis for XBIZ.

Last week, the court’s en banc coordinator said an unidentified active judge of the court had requested en banc review of the panel’s denial of a stay.

Randazza, when reached on Monday about the court's decision to meet en banc over the case, said that the 9th Circuit's original ruling was the "right result but for all the wrong reasons" and that the decision to go the full panel was "interesting."

"I would think that the ruling ultimately would be reversed over this brand new interpretation by the court," Randazza told XBIZ.

The 9th Circuit found that Cindy Lee Garcia had created an original work in her performance, “Innocence of Muslims," and that she retained copyrightable rights because she did not execute a valid model release transferring them to the film’s creator.

The 9th Circuit also found that film producers typically have an implied license in the performance of actors appearing in their creations, but that the film’s creator far exceeded that license in this case.

"Under the Copyright Act, it is novel — though not unprecedented — for the court to find a performer has copyright rights in his or her performance," Randazza said in the analysis of the decision. "An actor’s performance contains originality and may be preserved in a fixed form, satisfying the standards for copyrightability under the Copyright Act ."

Garcia, an actress who answered a casting call for a role in a film to be titled “Desert Warrior,” was paid $500 for her part. She said she thought the film was about the life of a typical Egyptian 2,000 years ago but later was shocked to find out the film was a short anti-Islamic video called “Innocence of Muslims” streaming on YouTube.

In the video, she was portrayed as making anti-Muslim statements.  Later, according to court records, an Egyptian cleric issued a fatwa, calling for actors and production crew involved in the video to be killed.

Garcia repeatedly ordered Google and subsidiary YouTube to take down the video, but Google repeatedly declined.

Garcia later sued Google and YouTube, arguing that her performance in the film was copyrightable and that copyright interest entitled her to demand that YouTube pull the film.

A federal court denied Garcia’s request, so she took the case to the 9th Circuit where a three-judge panel sided with her last month.

The 9th Circuit panel held that she had a sufficient copyright right in her performance, despite the fact that she only appeared in the film for a few seconds, to remove the film from circulation.

On Monday, it wasn't determined when the full panel would hear Garcia's appeal.

More ways to get XBIZ News:  RSS Feeds  |  E-Newsletters  |  Desktop Widget  |  Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !


Cam World: Q&A With Studio 20’s Andra Chirnogeanu

One of the blue-ribbon studios in the cam biz is Studio 20, which is now a global brand, with locations on both sides of the Atlantic — from Romania to Hollywood, Calif. Of course, with every strong... More »

Cam World: Model of Month Jenny Blighe Is Red-Hot

Have you found out about MyFreeCams sensation Jenny Blighe, the fiery Arkansas redhead? For the past four years, Blighe’s been camming on an almost-daily basis on MyFreeCams, building a loyal fan... More »

Justin Sayne Leather Expands Team, Gears Up for Eventful 2017

When Justin Sayne looks back on 2016, he will likely remember it as a year in which his Arizona-based company, Justin Sayne Leather, grew by leaps and bounds. Important new hires joined the company, Sayne... More »
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.

Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
Access the latest issues of the industry's leading trade publications in digital form. View online or download for offline viewing.


The European Summit

Mar 04 - Mar 07
Barcelona-Sitges, Spain

The TEA Show

Mar 05 - Mar 06
Hollywood, CA

Phoenix Forum 2017

Mar 23 - Mar 26
Tempe, Arizona


Mar 31 - Apr 02
Denver, CO.
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!