Home > News > Perfect 10 Sues Visa/MasterCard • Bookmark   • Newsletters   • Register Search Options

NEWS STORY

Perfect 10 Sues Visa/MasterCard

Get XBIZ News
XBIZ Research
Will Google uphold its commitment to 'Freedom of Expression' when it comes to organic adult search results?
Yes
  32.77%
No
  67.23%
Out of 177 votes. Results based on votes submitted by members of XBIZ.net social network.
Wednesday, Jan 28, 2004    Text size: 
BEVERLY HILLS, Calif. – After taking a loss of more than $29 million to copyright infringement over the past six years and $8 million in legal fees, the owner of Perfect 10, Inc., Norman Zada, is waging a war against the two largest and most successful credit card companies in the world.

Zada filed papers in the U.S. District Court for Northern California this week against Visa International, First Data Corp., Cardservice International, MasterCard International, and Humboldt Bank.

Perfect 10 gained industry notoriety for its 2002 preliminary injunction against Cybernet Ventures, Inc., the owners of Adult Verification Service Adult Check, for featuring more than 10,000 copyrighted Perfect 10 images in the Adult Check family of websites. And while Perfect 10 won the suit for an undisclosed amount of money, admittedly, it was only the tip of the iceberg.

Zada's complaint against the two credit card behemoths and the banks that process their transactions is that they are facilitating and profiting from the illegal use of copyrighted material on adult entertainment websites. The complaint states that Visa and MasterCard have made large sums of money from the sale of pirated adult content and should be held liable for any related copyright violation.

Out of an estimated 6,500 hundred images, Zada claims that his content has been infringed upon more than 20,000 times, which at a penalty of $1,000 per image, could result in a settlement of $20 million.

A former money manager and Stanford University and Columbia University professor, Zada entered the online adult entertainment space in 1997 when very few companies were doing anything similar. Perfect 10 holds copyrighted images of nude and topless women who have not been surgically enhanced and makes that content available on a subscription basis through the Perfect 10 website and a quarterly magazine.

However, according to Zada, Perfect 10 has sustained significant operating losses since its inception due to the continuous theft of its content. After pumping most of his capital into producing quality content, Zada says he didn't realize webmasters were going to steal his images faster than he could produce them.

Zada's beef is that his stolen content, combined with the hoards of unauthorized celebrity content on the web, makes it impossible for the legitimate players to compete.

"It's not just the theft of our images that have killed us, it's the theft of other people's images," said Zada. "We can't possibly compete when we are paying for our content and our competition is not."

Zada and his lawyers started filing lawsuits against individual websites, which proved instantly difficult because of the concealed identities of many webmasters.

Then Zada went after Cybernet, won the case based on contributory and vicarious copyright infringement, and managed to deliver a stern warning to many other AVS sites guilty of the same type of indirect infringement.

But according to Zada, many of the webmasters who had been dealing in Perfect 10 and stolen celebrity content moved their sites to certain processors or third party billing companies like iBill, CCBill, and Paycom that indirectly, and often unknowingly, make a percentage profit off websites that feature unauthorized material.

Zada's lawsuit against Paycom was dismissed in 2002 and his litigation against the two remaining processors continues, but according to Zada, even if his company prevails, there are still other billing companies out there profiting in the same way.

"At that point we had to go to the top," Zada told XBiz. "We had been complaining to Visa/MasterCard for a long time. We've given them lists of adult sites that are using stolen content and committing fraud. We've informed them of many things, but to the best of what we can tell, they just changed their rules and basically said no more new celebrity websites, but you can keep working with the ones you have."

According to Zada, Visa and MasterCard also process billing for password hacking sites that advertise stolen passwords, some belonging to Perfect 10, that have been hacked off other computers.

"It would be a monstrous gamble for them [Visa/MasterCard] to actually allow this case to go to trial," Zada told XBiz. "They will either try to dismiss the case or dismiss it on a summary judgment."

But either way, Zada believes that the case will set a precedent for many other copyright holders to sue the two credit card companies on similar grounds.

"It's a very strong case," he told XBiz. "Massive damages, very unfair competition; it is definitely not a good case for them. I am more interested in seeing them stop processing payments for sites that don't own their content than anything else."

Additionally, Zada says that the lawsuit could have an adverse affect on search engines and paid search results that often link to sites that feature stolen content.

"The ramifications of this suit go beyond Visa and MasterCard to Google, Yahoo, and to all the sites that have been advertising stolen content," he told XBiz. "Paid search results create liability that is much more extensive for the search engines than people realize."

The Perfect 10 lawsuit was filed on Wednesday of this week in San Francisco, where Visa is headquartered.

Visa and MasterCard were not available for comment at the time of this printing.

More ways to get XBIZ News:  RSS Feeds  |  E-Newsletters  |  Desktop Widget  |  Mobile
Looking for porn star news and behind-the-scene videos? Check out XFANZ.com !

LEGAL PERSPECTIVES

Alternative Currency; Is Regulation in Store?

Hardly a day goes by without some headline referring to developments in legal status or use of alternative currency such as bitcoin. At times it seems the virtual currency is nearly taking over the Internet.... More »

Legal Reality: Cliff Notes on 2257

Unlike producers of nonsexual content, adult content producers must comply with a complex and burdensome set of federal criminal regulations known as the 2257 regulations. For those who are not familiar... More »

Rights From Performers: Minor Role, Big Impact

A recent federal appeals court ruling has underscored, once again, why it is so important for content producers to properly acquire intellectual property rights from persons providing creative contributions... More »
XBIZ NEWSLETTERS
Stay informed of the latest industry developments. Get XBIZ newsletters delivered to your inbox. Subscribe today!
Enter email address:

* To manage existing subscriptions click here.






POPULAR PRODUCTS & SERVICES
Submit your press release to
multiple news outlets with 1 click.
Subscribe to RSS news feeds or
add free content to your website.
Access XBIZ news and articles
with your mobile device.
Subscribe to XBIZ Premiere magazine, the industry's leading adult retail trade publications, delivering the most timely and comprehensive business news and information to producers and retailers of adult products.

UPCOMING EVENTS

EXXXOTICA Chicago

Jul 11 - Jul 13
Chicago, Illinois

ANME Show

Jul 12 - Jul 14
Burbank, California

Sexpo

Aug 01 - Aug 03
Sydney, Australia

QWEBEC Expo Montreal

Aug 15 - Aug 17
Montreal, Canada
Everyday thousands of business professionals browse XBIZ's industry directory for quality products and services. Not listed yet? Your company could be losing potential new business. Submit your company today!
Use XBIZ RSS feeds to stay informed of the latest industry developments or as a content syndication tool for your website!