profile

Spike Speaks Out

Editor’s note: Shortly after a recent XBiz story about Acacia’s proceedings against Webmasters, I was contacted by Spike Goldberg, CEO of HomeGrown Video – and one of Acacia’s most vocal opponents – who wanted a forum to address statements made by Acacia. In the interests of fair and balanced journalism, and providing our readers with as many viewpoints as possible, I agreed. Here is Spike’s response to this issue of concern to all in our industry ~ Stephen

While Mr. Berman’s most recent interview in XBiz is simply more of the same — trying to convince businesses in our industry to pay Acacia regardless of whether they infringe Acacia’s patents and regardless of whether those patents are valid and enforceable — given the confusion that his statements have created among some, I thought it worthwhile to make a few comments and to provide an update regarding the pending litigation.

Berman’s latest tactic appears to be to convince affiliates to stop doing business with sponsors who have not taken a license from Acacia.  His motives are obvious, to try to take business away from those who have decided to challenge Acacia’s licensing plans.  His comments that "In most cases, if the sponsor licenses from Acacia, the affiliate will be covered" and "In order to avoid liability for patent infringement, it is in the best interest of affiliates to send traffic to sponsors that have licenses with Acacia" are misleading at best and are even inconsistent with other statements Berman makes in the same interview.  For example, under Berman’s view of things, if a webmaster provides previews or offers its own content, it will need a license from Acacia regardless of where it sends its traffic.  This is why Berman stated that, “if a webmaster has their own audio/video content that is accessed from their site, then plain and simply they need a license, whether they are a free site or a paysite and regardless of whether they send traffic to other Acacia licensees or not.”

It appears that in Berman’s mind anyone at all involved in the sale of video or audio files over the Internet needs to pay Acacia, regardless of whether their website has such files or not.  Of course, Berman simply ignores the fact that Acacia’s patents cover very specific systems and methods for the creation of those files and that few, if any, in our industry use those systems and methods. 

I understand that Acacia has contacted more than one thousand companies in our industry, including those who make little if any profit from their websites.  It is hard for me to believe that Acacia will file suit against hundreds or thousands of companies that make a few hundred or a few thousand dollars through their Internet businesses, but ultimately that is up to Acacia’s shareholders to decide.  Because my company is involved in this litigation and because of my involvement in the IMPA, I have been asked by many of these companies what they should do if contacted by Acacia.  In addition to contacting a qualified patent attorney you may wish to consider asking Acacia to explain, in writing, precisely what it is that your company does that infringes the claims of Acacia’s patents.  Given that Acacia is asking you to pay for property rights it allegedly owns, shouldn’t you be entitled to know exactly what that property is and how it is that Acacia believes you are using it?  I leave you to decide whether to accept or reject any effort by Acacia to tell you that transmitting audio or video files over a network like the Internet, or sending traffic to websites that do so, is covered by its patents.  That technology was well known before the filing date of the patents that Acacia purchased.  Ask Acacia for copies of the file histories for its patents and the cited prior art and you will see for yourself that the gentlemen Acacia bought its patents from were forced to narrow their claims substantially to get around even the prior art that the Patent Office found.   

At the end of the day you may come to the same conclusion that I and others in our industry have reached — that Acacia’s licensing program is not based on legitimate claims of patent infringement.  Instead, it relies on the fact that patent litigation is expensive and that for most, it is simply easier to pay than it is to fight.  If caving into this sort of get rich quick scheme does not bother you, then you should write Acacia a check.  If it does, or if you are not sure who is right in this fight, then you should do your homework.  Read the patents, the file histories, the prior art, and talk with others who have studied the issues, and most importantly talk with a qualified patent attorney. 

When I look at these documents, and when I read Berman’s ever shifting comments about what Acacia’s patents cover, his inconsistent comments about who needs a license, and when I hear the complaints from companies that decided to pay Acacia, I become even more convinced that my decision to fight this battle was justified. 

Turning now to the litigation, we have recently learned that the pending cases have been reassigned to a new judge, Judge James Ware from the Northern District of California.  Judge Ware will be holding a hearing on Nov. 7 to discuss the case and to put in place a plan to efficiently resolve the issues of infringement and validity of these patents.  I look forward to Acacia’s allegations being put to the test before this well respected judge.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

To Cloud or Not to Cloud, That Is the Question

Let’s be honest. It just sounds way cooler to say your business is “in the cloud,” right? Buzzwords make everything sound chic and relevant. In fact, someone uninformed might even assume that any hosting that is not in the cloud is inferior. So what’s the truth?

Brad Mitchell ·
opinion

Upcoming Visa Price Changes to Registration, Transaction Fees

Visa is updating its fee structure. Effective April 1, both the card brand’s initial nonrefundable application fee and annual renewal fee will increase from $500 to $950. Visa is also introducing a fee of 10 cents for each transaction, and 10 basis points — 0.1% — on the payment volume of certain merchant accounts.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Unpacking the New Digital Services Act

Do you hear the word “regulation” and get nervous? When it comes to the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA), you shouldn’t worry. If you’re complying with the most up-to-date card brand regulations, you can breathe a sigh of relief.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

The Perils of Relying on ChatGPT for Legal Advice

It surprised me how many people admitted that they had used ChatGPT or similar services either to draft legal documents or to provide legal advice. “Surprised” is probably an understatement of my reaction to learning about this, as “horrified” more accurately describes my emotional response.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
profile

WIA Profile: Holly Randall

If you’re one of the many regular listeners to Holly Randall’s celebrated podcast, you are already familiar with her charming intro spiel: “Hi, I’m Holly Randall and welcome to my podcast, ‘Holly Randall Unfiltered.’ This is the show about sex, the adult industry and the people in it.

Women In Adult ·
trends

What's Hot Now: Leading Content Players on Trending Genres, Monetization Strategies

The juggernaut creator economy hurtles along, fueled by ever-ascendant demand for personality-based authenticity and intimacy — yet any reports of the demise of the traditional paysite are greatly exaggerated.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

An Ethical Approach to Global Tech Staffing

One thing my 24-year career as a technologist working to support the online adult entertainment industry has taught me about is the power of global staffing. Without a doubt, I have achieved significantly more business success as a direct result of hiring abroad.

Brad Mitchell ·
opinion

Finding the Right Payment Partner

Whenever I am talking with businesses that are just getting started, one particular question comes up a lot: “How do I get a merchant account?” It’s a simple question, but it has a complicated answer.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

The Taxman Cometh for Every Business

February may be the month of romance, but it is also a time when we need to think about something that inspires very little love: taxes. April is not far away, and the taxman is always waiting. This year, federal and most state income taxes are due Monday, April 15.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

The Continuous Journey of Legal Compliance in Adult

The adult entertainment industry is teeming with opportunity but is also fraught with challenges, from anticipating consumer behavior to keeping up with technological innovation. The most labyrinthine of all challenges, however, is the world of legal compliance.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
Show More