The premise of this amateur-reality movie is awesome: real college guys direct their own fantasy porn scene starring a hand-picked female performer. This concept is executed flawlessly; you could tell just how giddy these dudes were with the excitement of having their porn dream come to life.

As with any amateur movie, the question needs to asked — will the guys get (and stay) hard enough to fuck on camera and give viewers a pleasurable jack-off experience? The answer — I’m surprised none of these college students had done porn before, as each one gives a credible accounting of himself as a cock-slinging swordsman.

Each scene kicks off with minimal setup. Savannah Stern is up first and before you know it, she is being pounded by two horny frat dudes. They both have their way with Stern before each fucks to pop on her belly. The guys’ excitement is palpable.

Shane’s World has a knack for producing great sex scenes that are accessible to everyday people, kinda like the guys in this movie. The company makes its mark by releasing nonformulaic porn that is fun and flirty yet totally hardcore. The unique premise and true reality feel of “My College Porno” makes it a winner in the Shane’s World mold.

Cast: Savannah Stern, Hailey Young, Allison Pierce, Ashley Belle, Holly West, Trisha Rey, more.